1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.


Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by sue ridgepipe, May 11, 2005.

  1. sue ridgepipe

    sue ridgepipe Active Member

    +0 /0
    does menzies stand a chance of displacing waterhouse at lock for origin?if it is accepted that nsw will play 4 props plus wing and kennedy or watmough as seems likely then the great beaver must probably rid that dirty panther from the side.kennedy seems to be on the bench in rep stuff always at this stage of his carreer so i cant see him starting.i reckon their is a small chance anasta may knock all of them out at lock.big enough,playing great and with rugby knocking at the door.....if beaver was not available i would pick him over waterhouse . on form the legendary beaver should be picked.
  2. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    +1,429 /38
    Obviously I think he should be picked, but after seeing the Bundy test squad, I wont stick my head out and say that he will. On form he would tear the match up but im not sure how many people have looked past Kennedy and Watmough as far as Manly / Rep spots go. Beavers work, since NE days has most often gone un-noticed but his defencive work in city country will go a long way to helping his cause.
  3. Canteen Worker

    Canteen Worker Well-Known Member

    +215 /5
    Agreed. Beaver is more mobile than Waterhouse and also has utility value to cover a range of positions. It will be up to what Stuart wants one guesses!
  4. sue ridgepipe

    sue ridgepipe Active Member

    +0 /0
    following on from that.is wing a certianty.anasta can cover backrow and 5/8 and buderus is an 80 minute man and captian.wing does add that explosiveness off the mark late in the halves which probably gets him over the line but he has been down on form with easts.still,he never lets the side down come this time of tear.as a queenslander i simply hope they make the worst decision possible.
  5. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    +1,429 /38
    As long as stuart is the coach and wing is still playing decent footie, he will be there. Sad, but true.
  6. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    +5,869 /213
    I think wing will be there

    he is the rep version of dunley - not matter what bad stuff he does his good stuff is always considered enough to justify any descisions to have him there (im talking more 2004 dunley)
  7. sue ridgepipe

    sue ridgepipe Active Member

    +0 /0
    i think dunley has fixed his discipline problem and is an essential element in our attack.we are not a brilliant side,more workmanlike and his spark is invaluable at the moment.
  8. Volley

    Volley Well-Known Member

    +1,111 /54
    I'd love to see Beaver get a run, but unfortunately I can't see it happening.

    Watch for Joel Monaghan to snag a wing spot. If he doesn't get a run he should sue for breach of contract.
  9. Chip and Chase

    Chip and Chase True Supporter Staff Member Administrator Premium Member Super Coach Member 2018 Tipping Competitor

    +9,156 /89
    Team from Game 3 2004

    Fullback Anthony Minichiello - Sydney Roosters

    Wing Luke Rooney - Penrith Panthers

    Centre Matt Cooper - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Centre Mark Gasnier - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Wing Luke Lewis - Penrith Panthers

    Five Eighth Brad Fittler - Sydney Roosters

    Half Back Trent Barrett - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Lock Forward Shaun Timmins - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Second Row Craig Fitzgibbon - Sydney Roosters

    Second Row Nathan Hindmarsh - Parramatta Eels

    Prop Forward Mark O’Meley - Bulldogs

    Hooker Danny Buderus © - Newcastle Knights

    Prop Forward Jason Ryles - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Interchange Willie Mason - Bulldogs

    Interchange Brent Kite - St George Illawarra Dragons

    Interchange Ben Kennedy - Newcastle Knights

    Interchange Craig Wing - Sydney Roosters

    Obviously Fittler, O'Meley and Mason won't be there this year. Also think Timmins will struggle to make side on current form. Bailey in for O'Meley ?? Maybe Anasta / Hill at 5/8 or push Barrett out and play Kimmorely / Finch / Gower at half.

    There are a couple of back row spots up for grabs.
  10. sue ridgepipe

    sue ridgepipe Active Member

    +0 /0
    timmins retired.kimmorley/barrett certianties.they hate hill for some reason.
  11. Canteen Worker

    Canteen Worker Well-Known Member

    +215 /5
    As well as Kite is going for Manly I can't see him in there ahead of Ryles, Bailey and Clinton. (Maybe has a chance as 4th Prop!
  12. Matabele

    Matabele Well-Known Member

    +516 /14
    Menzies is ahead of Waterhouse in experience and recent form. And who can forget the picture of Waterhouse coming off after 15 minutes game time in Origin One last year and putting hands on knees and gasping for breath.
  13. CC_Eagle

    CC_Eagle Member

    +1 /0
    Beaver pro's -

    *Previous experience in Origin and Test.
    *There isn't a more reliable player in the game.
    *A human brick wall
    *Play's 80 minutes.
    *I'm yet to see him ever get penalised and rarely does he make errors.
    *Gus wouldn't shutup about him on Friday night. Here's hoping he has been in Sticky's ear.
    *His C/C game was ouststanding.
    *Current form. Both invidual and team.

    Con's -

    *Waterhouse was in the test squad.

    Beaver for sure!
    <span class='smallblacktext'>[ Edited Wed May 11 2005, 08:15PM ]</span>
  14. byso

    byso Well-Known Member

    +85 /0
    Beaver deserves the gig.
  15. Canteen Worker

    Canteen Worker Well-Known Member

    +215 /5
    I would be happy if Beaver misses out (only for selfish Manly reasons) - then he plays for Manly against Parra. Hope they pick Hindmarsh, Grothe and QLD take as many slimes as they can. (Tahu, Riddell, Morrison are unlikely but the more Eels the better the chance to snag our first Friday night win. Work will be unbearable if we lose to them!!!!

Share This Page