Alex Johnston

I don’t believe we need to recruit anyone ‘special’......ok maybe Saab who really is an unknown to be honest. He hasn’t shown anything special from the games I’ve watched but his height is an advantage on what we have.
Tom T
Funa
Walker
Suli
Harper / Garrick
Schuster
DCE
Cust to 14......
 
madmax said:
I don’t believe we need to recruit anyone ‘special’......ok maybe Saab who really is an unknown to be honest. He hasn’t shown anything special from the games I’ve watched but his height is an advantage on what we have.
Tom T
Funa
Walker
Suli
Harper / Garrick
Schuster
DCE
Cust to 14......
Click to expand...

Exactly what I've been thinking about Saab.

If we truly want an upgrade on our outside backs, we should be looking at someone who is named every week in a teams 17, not a player who can't even make a team that also sits outside the 8 like us.
 
Im not really thinking players are keeping away from Manly, more the fact there is so much tied up with DCE, Tom and Jake, we are limited to what can be offered in comparison to other NRL teams...
 
So stayed at souths.

Did he want to go or just testing the market through the media?
 
maxta said:
Im not really thinking players are keeping away from Manly, more the fact there is so much tied up with DCE, Tom and Jake, we are limited to what can be offered in comparison to other NRL teams...
Click to expand...
He's not getting picked because he wants out! Only Des plays players who are leaving next year.
Saab would be a massive upgrade on Garrick and Taufua. He will be a gun, he is only young but is about ready to fire. He is the 1 signing I really want! I'd even let Walker go to get him. Use the spare money for a hooker
 
Jigzkiller said:
He isn't a star sure but after DCE and Turbo (when fit) he would be our best back yet your relieved we missed out on him lol.
Click to expand...
If we want to spend 400-500K on a back id rather so so many backs than AJ. What my point is, is that AJ would be invisible without Trbo and DCE because he is a finisher, so I don't see how that is worth the investment when we lack game breakers like Staggs (not suggesting we are a realistic chance of Staggs). He's a decent back and a good option but I think you're a little too invested in AJ, he'd be a risky signing if we entered a bidding war for him. He is a better version of Garrick
 
ricardo said:
I'd say Johnston, JAC and Vunivalu are the top three strike wingers off contract this year. Need to make a play for two of them imho
Click to expand...
Vuni signed with The Reds and JAC looking to play fullback

Im happy with Johnston but think he is being overrated here a little
 
ManlyArmy said:
Exactly what I've been thinking about Saab.

If we truly want an upgrade on our outside backs, we should be looking at someone who is named every week in a teams 17, not a player who can't even make a team that also sits outside the 8 like us.
Click to expand...

Dont support this logic at all

Saab is a youngster on the up. Now he is no sure bet but by your logic none of the clubs below should have signed the players listed as the were youngsters that hadnt really broken through at their respective clubs

Storm signing JAC from the Tigers
Storm signing Papy from the Tigers
Roosters signing JWH from us
Sharks signing Ramien from us
Penrith signing Kikau from the Cowboys
Parra signing Sivo from Penrith

Could go on and on, part of be succesful in the salary cap era is taking the right punt on the right young players
 
Disco said:
Dont support this logic at all

Saab is a youngster on the up. Now he is no sure bet but by your logic none of the clubs below should have signed the players listed as the were youngsters that hadnt really broken through at their respective clubs

Storm signing JAC from the Tigers
Storm signing Papy from the Tigers
Roosters signing JWH from us
Sharks signing Ramien from us
Penrith signing Kikau from the Cowboys
Parra signing Sivo from Penrith

Could go on and on, part of be succesful in the salary cap era is taking the right punt on the right young players
Click to expand...

Fair point and you could say we've done the same with the likes of Garrick, Suli, Harper etc. which is why I made the point of also looking at someone who has proven consistency to be selected because we can only bring in so many rookies before we need to start looking at other options, especially when the Storm, and to an extent the Roosters had a lot more experienced campaigners in their sides compared to us.
 
ManlyArmy said:
Or could be to do with them originally going after Addo-Carr but then unable to get his signature.
Click to expand...
They never associated chasing JAC with resigning Johnson funnily enough, they maintained it was that kid they want to shell the $$ for as why they couldn't fit Johnson and part there of why their fans were livid.
 
johnperi01 said:
So happy to take unders to stay with Souths, when not long ago couldn’t fit within the cap. Obviously nothing to see here, which is why there needs to be more transparency around salaries.
Click to expand...
Maybe the "sacrifice" he made that was in the news is that he won't get to play FB staying at Souffs, not that he took unders to stay.
 
Disco said:
Dont support this logic at all

Saab is a youngster on the up. Now he is no sure bet but by your logic none of the clubs below should have signed the players listed as the were youngsters that hadnt really broken through at their respective clubs

Storm signing JAC from the Tigers
Storm signing Papy from the Tigers
Roosters signing JWH from us
Sharks signing Ramien from us
Penrith signing Kikau from the Cowboys
Parra signing Sivo from Penrith

Could go on and on, part of be succesful in the salary cap era is taking the right punt on the right young players
Click to expand...
Didn’t know about Kikau....man, that must burn the Cowboys big time.
Its a good point you make @Disco. You’ve got to take a punt at some stage on the next (hopefully) big thing.
 
ManEagle said:
They never associated chasing JAC with resigning Johnson funnily enough, they maintained it was that kid they want to shell the $$ for as why they couldn't fit Johnson and part there of why their fans were livid.
Click to expand...

Do you really think a kid at that age and of this generation would knock back $100K?

I’ll bet my left proverbial that there is a third party deal happening somewhere where this kid gets more than what they are claiming.

The gladiator has people in the know so it probably took a few phone calls to get it over the line.
 
Lindsay Drake said:
Do you really think a kid at that age and of this generation would knock back $100K?

I’ll bet my left proverbial that there is a third party deal happening somewhere where this kid gets more than what they are claiming.

The gladiator has people in the know so it probably took a few phone calls to get it over the line.
Click to expand...
Not sure your point ?
I was replying to a post that assumed one potential signing falling through resulted in Johnson resigning. I was in essence saying it smelt like a brown paper bag job to stay under the radar. TPA's are the new potential paper bag
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)

Members online

Total: 291 (members: 3, guests: 288)

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0

Online statistics

Members online
3
Guests online
288
Total visitors
291
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Latest posts

Newest members

Stay Connected

Back
Top Bottom