I actually really liked his idea that when you're offered a penalty you get one play. You kick for touch you go for goal or you tap it.
This is one of the worst ideas I’ve heard!
Under this rule, Manly would be rucking the ball out from their goal line and the opposition just need to lay over us or be offside and give away a penalty early in the count. Instead of us having 6 tackles we could end up with only 1 after the penalty.
Any defending team would be desperate to give away a penalty if it only meant one tackle to the opposition.
The other idea about not getting the ball back after missing I kick, I like... although most goals are taken close to the posts and not many miss these days.