It was Des all along coaching thread

[anthonyb1965]

They’d be very aware of the feelings of the fans from reading Silvertails.

Their issue is if they go the cheap option they save money up front BUT they then cop it in memberships and attendances.

Not hard to rack up a million short on these.

If this is the choice it will be clear that despite the rhetoric they really don’t give a **** after all.

Don't forget the sponsors Mark, who the coach is will influence who comes on board.

 

[brad]

They’d be very aware of the feelings of the fans from reading Silvertails.

Their issue is if they go the cheap option they save money up front BUT they then cop it in memberships and attendances.

Not hard to rack up a million short on these.

If this is the choice it will be clear that despite the rhetoric they really don’t give a **** after all.

Thats right mate and say a Toovey signing would bring memberships up and put bums back on seats. I dont know if Tooves is the best coaching option , but he'd shore up a couple of things .

 

[Jethro]

My argument against Madge or any substantial coach coming to Manly ...

Madge would be asking about $700k upwards ...
Madge would likely demand the appointment of his own assistant coaches and staff.
Madge would demand a top recruitment manger and salary cap manager same as Baz ..

To facilitate Madge coming Penns would be looking at paying out Barrett for 3/4 of a year (say $400k), and possibly paying out Cartwright and Mangey for 2 years each (say $700k) .... plus employ 4 additional football club staff (say $500k) .....

or, keep Cartwright on a shoe string ... business as usual ...

PSS Mage has also seen how Penn's relationship with the past 3 coaches has ended in acrimony, legal stouches and media driven character assassinations ..ou can bet your sweet bibby that his contract would reflect the strong likihood that he will at some time receive the same treatment ...

Told all you numb-nuts 3 weeks ago that Madge was a dream not happening ...... can't believe Penn's head is so far up his own clacka he didn't know it ....

 

[Ryan]

I respect what you, Ryan and Mark of Brisbane are saying. I am operating from the likely scenario that all other options are either not available, not wanting to coach Manly at this stage or are on the nose with the Penn family. The cupboard seems bare unless a surprise emerges from the ashes. I am speaking from the point of view that Cartwright is coach. I am not suggesting he is the messiah or even a naughty little boy. He is probably average as far as coaching is concerned. If we had Hasler, Toovey or Madge I would probably be saying we are a final four chance. With Cartwright you have someone who has taken the Titans to near the top for two years with the right cattle. Manly has some fine cattle. I think he can at least get us a final 8 spot...probably no further. We may have to cope with mediocrity until some of the disasters of this club start to subside and it becomes a worth while place to play and coach again. And I actually suspect the Penn family is waiting for a big financial offer to move on, hoping to recover the fortune they have outlaid with this club.

Thanks mate. Deleted the long winded response I just made.

I'm just going to go with the masses, and agree Penn is our saviour, Gorman is amazing, Cartwright will be wonderful, and we will win the Grand Final next year, with Reuben what's his name scoring a hatrick.

 

[tookey]

Ok how about this:
Peter Sharp- coaching director
Barrett - coach first six months
Cartwong - assistant six months, coach rest of year.


Wow ive done it. Ive made our situation worse!

Ferris strength and conditioning, Luke Dorn backs and Adam Peters forwards coach

 

[tookey]

Still dont think its Cartwright .

Costanza?

 

[tookey]

Thanks mate. Deleted the long winded response I just made.

I'm just going to go with the masses, and agree Penn is our saviour, Gorman is amazing, Cartwright will be wonderful, and we will win the Grand Final next year, with Reuben what's his name scoring a hatrick.

You forgot Ferris being a friendly person as well

 

[Harvies elbow]

You forgot Ferris being a friendly person as well

And an excellent conditioner...

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

And welcome to 100 pages devoted to the Super Coach that is John Cartwrong!!

Took Brian Kelly 12 months to get to 100, and Hoss about 2 months!!

 

[lurker]

For me the outcome will be based on one fact only ....... if the Penn's want a well credentialed coach they will need to outlay upto $800k for the coach and payout about another $700k in casualties ..... or promote Carty for fish and chip money ... what will they do ?

They’ve obviously tried to pony up the cash for maguire though. Cause the article was that he was rejecting a multi million dollar offer. Buzz when he sank the slipper in made no mention of it being not enough cash. That’s why I’m so angry at baz. If we hadn’t re-signed his muppets we could have just sacked them and let Madge bring his people. But eating a million or more in payouts would be crazy. So many better things that money could be spent on

 

[lurker]

And an excellent conditioner...

He makes hair silky and smooth?

 

[davohan123]

And welcome to 100 pages devoted to the Super Coach that is John Cartwrong!!

Took Brian Kelly 12 months to get to 100, and Hoss about 2 months!!

Can you imagine the activity on here when he is announced as coach
Going to be a very long off season

 

[Bradza]

Hold your bat up ST, that’s the 100! I can’t believe how some posters manage to play the same shots over and over without tiring.

 

[40 years an eagle]

Still dont think its Cartwright .

Either do I.

 

[wedgetail eagle]

He makes hair silky and smooth?

It won’t happen overnight, but it will happen...

 

[manlyfan76]

And welcome to 100 pages devoted to the Super Coach that is John Cartwrong!!

Took Brian Kelly 12 months to get to 100, and Hoss about 2 months!!

M-a-r-v-e-ll-o-u-s.

 

[Ryan]

And an excellent conditioner...

He'd make an even better shampoo. Hell, he'd do okay just using a shampoo...and investing in a razor FFS.

 

[Ryan]

Time for bed you drone, every time I check in, you are bagging the clubs owners and pontificating.
Go and feed the seagulls ya bum

Hey mate, what's he said that's been off the mark? If our owners invested more into the club at various levels, would we not be in this mess now?

You're ripping him for having a go at the owners, but are missing that he's also backing our coach, who's been given a really rough and poor deal since signing with us.

I don't think there would be one other club, who's power brokers would allow their brand to be dragged through the mud like this, other than $cott Penn.

 

[Harvies elbow]

He'd make an even better shampoo. Hell, he'd do okay just using a shampoo...and investing in a razor FFS.

And add a dietitian to his investment portfolio...

 

[Ryan]

And add a dietitian to his investment portfolio...

I hear Willie Peters is available? Plus, he had the Bunnies fitter than they've been in years.