XX Deleted link said:
sorry Volley but they weren't between tests and they weren't at the MCG and Tremlett arguably their best bowler this series was playing. The pitch offered a bit to the poms early so smith and o'keefe had the better of the conditions. in the second innings when the conditions were equally as friendly for both batsmen white looked a class above smith! how'd your boy Khawaja go in that match again?
Sorry mate, I was thinking of this game.
http://livescores.cricket.com.au/scoreboard_2533_1.html
My bad. I forgot White tonned up for Australia A, and assumed he must have in the Victoria v England game.
For what it's worth, I think White and Smith are quite similar. Both attacking cricketers who aren't technically perfect, and great fielders. White's got a top cricketing brain, and I've heard the same about Smith at club level.
Smith still bowls though, and is 6 years younger. White doesn't have much room for improvement, while Smith is still only 21 and is going to get better.
He averages 43 in FC while White is 41.
Currently, White is better suited to Test Cricket, however Smith will overtake him imo within 3 years. I wouldn't have picked Smith this series, I would've had Khawaja at 6, and currently he's showing why. He is a class or 5 above White as a batsman, so your little dig in regards to Khawaja above looks foolish 8).