Who's our goal kicker poll ...

[madmax]

Who scores more points? Garrick will score more tries, make more breaks, kick more goals. Leave Foggy to organise our attack.

 

[LeonardCohen]

I think Fog is a better kicker of the ball. He has a more natural style and strikes them cleaner. I’ve noticed Garrick tries to kick the ball too hard and the style is very jerky. If you look at Garrick’s kicking from 19-21, his was hitting them sweeter than the last few years.

However, given Fog’s new role, it might just be another burden on top of marshalling the team, so for that reason, maybe it should stay with Garrick.

Neither are guys I would want kicking for my life though.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Neither are guys I would want kicking for my life though

Fortunately those situations don't arise that often

 

[Stuey Davis’s Socks]

Garrick, until he gets the yips (as he always does at some point of the season).

 

[XV-1]

Garrick for sure. Fogarty is here for 3 years Max.

If Garrick wants to stay at Manly and Manly treat him properly, he should be here for at least 4/5 years given he is 28.
If he signs for RL360 or Perth, give it to Fogarty.

 

[TheEagle]

Fogarty. Garrick seems to miss a few ones close to the posts. Fogarty probably has a bigger boot as well.

 

[robbiea]

They should both be professionals and do whatever coach says ,without harbouring hurt feelings.
Dont like it ,then **** off.

 

[Peter C]

Garrick tends to kick them high and also puts a curve on it, whereas Fogarty tends to kick them straight and lower, which is more the style nowadays, so it's Fogarty for me.

 

[C_Eagle31]

Do they both favour the same side or is one a left handside and the other a right handside. If they are different that would make the choice easy. Also TKO is a handy kicker (as long as he re-signs)

They're both right-footed kickers.

 

[DUFFMAN]

The percentages don't really mean a lot.
One player could have the majority of kicks within 10 metres either side of the post and the other the majority closer to the sidelines.

 

[Woodsie]

The percentages don't really mean a lot.
One player could have the majority of kicks within 10 metres either side of the post and the other the majority closer to the sidelines.

Over a data sample of 100 or so kicks .... the stats re actually quite accurate .... however, there is only 1 shot out of 100 between them.

So other factors will prevail.