I'd go for the most inspirational person at each club (as opposed to just the biggest star).
So for the Raiders I'd go Ricky Stuart (he inspires anyone with no ability or brains at coaching that they can make a squillion dollars out of delivering nothing).
Bulldogs would be Josh Reynolds, (I mean anyone who can be more hated than Mick Ennis needs to get something).
Souths would be the fans (who can't be inspired by a group that get excited around March every year, only to realize their team sucks, and then do it all again next year??)
Storm I'd go Cooper Cronk (anyone who can be in Melbourne for more than a few years and still be seen as a half decent human being deserves something, and he actually does)
I could go on all night.
For us in all seriousness it's a tough one, but I'd say Snake. Because the adversity he has overcome since 2009 has been remarkable. To go from the face of the game, to all the rubbish he put up with, add on top injury concerns, and to now be back to his best......INSPIRATIONAL.