2 abysmal seasons mate... and you have posted many times that our roster is at least a top 6 side... so us scraping into the finals and going out the door in week one is hardly an amazing result when it gets sandwiched between the sg1t of 2016 and 2018. You’ve been watching this game for long enough to recognise how appalling our defence was under Barrett... his record speaks for itself mate. Worst coaching record in Manly history kind of says it all really...
Yeah, I know, and I'm a bit of a hypocrite making excuses for him , when I also complain about the club making excuses (and that not being good enough).
What I did like about Barrett (and I guess that means nothing now with him going):
+ Seemed to have a close relationship with the playing group.
+ Seemed to develop players well (Kelly, Trbojevic's, Lane, AFB) etc etc etc all gone on to bigger things
+ Gave youngsters a go (Wright, Parker, Kelly, Suli etc)
+ Players like Thompson said he was a big reason they came here, so he was a drawcard
+ Had a very good reputation by outside sources
+ Had the balls to stick it to Penn, and demand better conditions
+ Has representative experience (City/Country)
+ Was even keeled for most of his tenure
+ Team was constantly up the top of the tables / stats attacking wise
+ Was very passionate about the results and playing group (even went to tears)
+ Experienced players like DCE claiming he was still developing him
+ Wasn't afraid to try things (Wright at Hooker, Walks at 5/8 etc).
Okay, I know there's a flipside to that coin mate, but I guess these are some of the things that endeared me to him.