top 5 most over rated players

[The answer]

in no order:

trent barrett
brett finch
brett kimmorley
scott hill
jason ryles

 

[byso]

Oh, is he still at Manly next year Kiwi?

Tookey well put. But I think he was better the previous year. This year he ran around like a fool giving away penalty after penalty. Pretty stupid really. For a young fella trying to make an impact.

The least a PL player can do is keep there nose clean when given a chance in the NRL.

 

[andrew]

That is a good point Tookey & Kiwigirl,but i aslo agree with Byso that his form did go backwards this season from last year.He looked so out of his depth when he played first grade this year.Too slow and predictable,a bit like Jim Curtis.They tried hard but just not upto first grade standard.I heard Jim Curtis was talking with the Panthers.We shall have too see what happens next year for young Cleal,i heard they signed him up for another couple of years???

 

[kiwigirl]

Yes you all have very valid points and I agree - too many silly penalty's given away. Heard the same about Curtis - not sure where it has ended up, but I know some who aren't happy about it. Kane is looking at his options and as of yet has NOT signed.

 

[byso]

Interesting, I like the kid to be honest. But the penalties sheesh!