Tommy Talau

[XV-1]

If souths sign wighton we shoukd find some cash for Campbell Graham

Why would Graham leave Souths for us regardless if Wighton signs?

 

[hozza]

Why would Graham leave Souths for us regardless if Wighton signs?

If Souths sign Wighton, he’ll play centre. And there’s no way they can keep some of there players coming off contract (14). Graham and Tatola both off contract among others, you’d think graham may get pushed out as he’s a centre..

Personally I’d keep Graham

 

[Nordburg]

If Souths sign Wighton, he’ll play centre. And there’s no way they can keep some of there players coming off contract (14). Graham and Tatola both off contract among others, you’d think graham may get pushed out as he’s a centre..

Personally I’d keep Graham

You know League teams have two centres right?Campbell Graham won’t be going anywhere

 

[HK_Eagle]

Wrong thread, my bad

 

[hozza]

You know League teams have two centres right?Campbell Graham won’t be going anywhere

Get the fuk out? Really?

In all seriousness you may be right, and I’d certainly be keeping Graham. But he is off contract and if Wighton is signed will impact Souths cap. Giving teams like the Dolphins to go hard for him among others. Graham in the top 5 centres for me.

 

[HK_Eagle]

Get the fuk out? Really?

In all seriousness you may be right, and I’d certainly be keeping Graham. But he is off contract and if Wighton is signed will impact Souths cap. Giving teams like the Dolphins to go hard for him among others. Graham in the top 5 centres for me.

Cap? eh?

 

[Nordburg]

Get the fuk out? Really?

In all seriousness you may be right, and I’d certainly be keeping Graham. But he is off contract and if Wighton is signed will impact Souths cap. Giving teams like the Dolphins to go hard for him among others. Graham in the top 5 centres for me.

He is but Souths advantage in the cap,is that they are paying relatively little for their halfback,Ilias,compared to all the top sides and his current contract runs through to 2025

 

[hozza]

Cap? eh?

I know, apparently only applies to 70% of the competition. Definitely applies to us.

 

[XV-1]

Get the fuk out? Really?

In all seriousness you may be right, and I’d certainly be keeping Graham. But he is off contract and if Wighton is signed will impact Souths cap. Giving teams like the Dolphins to go hard for him among others. Graham in the top 5 centres for me.

So wighton signs for 800k per season

What do we pay Graham? 600k

And not re-sign/upgrade Koula as we have a cap as well and very top end loaded with 3 players.

Personal given the choice,Koula every day.

 

[hozza]

He is but Souths advantage in the cap,is that they are paying relatively little for their halfback,Ilias,compared to all the top sides and his current contract runs through to 2025

In coming years they’ll have to upgrade Ilias. No doubt they’ll be prepping for that. But who knows you may be right, if they hang on to Graham, zero doubt they’ll lose several other players. Tatola being one. Assuming of course the cap applies to Souths.

 

[winnyason]

Talau seems decent depth upgrade over Parker/Harper. He has got size

 

[hozza]

So wighton signs for 800k per season

What do we pay Graham? 600k

And not re-sign/upgrade Koula as we have a cap as well and very top end loaded with 3 players.

Personal given the choice,Koula every day.

I agree. Ideal world I’d love Graham and Koula.
Koula is young and on the rise..

No chance we have room for Graham, other teams though no doubt will go hard at him.

 

[Nordburg]

In coming years they’ll have to upgrade Ilias. No doubt they’ll be prepping for that. But who knows you may be right, if they hang on to Graham, zero doubt they’ll lose several other players. Tatola being one. Assuming of course the cap applies to Souths.

Both Cook and Walker come off contract at the end of 2025 and I’d be surprised if one or both don’t hang up the boots after that,given they’ll be 34&35 by that time.

 

[winnyason]

I agree. Ideal world I’d love Graham and Koula.
Koula is young and on the rise..

No chance we have room for Graham, other teams though no doubt will go hard at him.

Yeah we won't have dollars for Graham. Koula upgrade extension and Josh schuster probable new deal means our cap will be non existence.

 

[hozza]

Both Cook and Walker come off contract at the end of 2025 and I’d be surprised if one or both don’t hang up the boots after that,given they’ll be 34&35 by that time.

So? Someone could come in next year and offer Ilias 1.1m next year, changing everything. They’ll have to upgrade in the next 12 months. We all know contracts mean sh!t.

If Wighton signs, guaranteed they’ll lose Graham or Tatola. And it’s Soufffs, so let’s hope it’s both..

 

[Nordburg]

So? Someone could come in next year and offer Ilias 1.1m next year, changing everything. They’ll have to upgrade in the next 12 months. We all know contracts mean sh!t.

If Wighton signs, guaranteed they’ll lose Graham or Tatola. And it’s Soufffs, so let’s hope it’s both..

So now you’re talking in hypotheticals,yet before you were questioning the Rabbits ability to fit these players in the cap.I’ve just explained it to you how it’s possible to fit them into the cap,but you want to come up with some argument based on your speculation with no substance

 

[hozza]

So now you’re talking in hypotheticals,yet before you were questioning the Rabbits ability to fit these players in the cap.I’ve just explained it to you how it’s possible to fit them into the cap,but you want to come up with some argument based on your speculation with no substance

On the Rums mate?

Hahaha It’s all hypothetical. Nothings happened yet!!!!!!!!! Lol And Iv just explained to you, that things change in the cap. It’s a moving part. But honestly I couldn’t give 2 fuks. But my moneys on Souths losing either Graham or Tatola if Wighton is signed. Or are you saying you can see into the future? I can’t.

Maybe it’s time for a water??

 

[Nordburg]

On the Rums mate?

Hahaha It’s all hypothetical. Nothings happened yet!!!!!!!!! Lol And Iv just explained to you, that things change in the cap. It’s a moving part. But honestly I couldn’t give 2 fuks. But my moneys on Souths losing either Graham or Tatola if Wighton is signed. Or are you saying you can see into the future? I can’t.

Maybe it’s time for a water??

You’ve come to a battle of the minds unarmed,go back to working on your conspiracy theories that other clubs are cheating the cap and Manly are hard done by

 

[eaglebuzz]

I hope we can agitate to get him released early, it would be handy to have him now!

 

[Disco]

Quite the tizz you two are having.

Come Nov 1 clubs can speak to Graham, Koloamatangi, Tatola, T Burgess and Arrow amongst others.

They sign Wighton and they will have to sacrifice elsewhere.