The Silvertail's optimism pulse 2025.

[XV-1]

There needs to be a status quo choice - no change from last year.

 

[Wombat64]

OK, So we're are we all at now?

No posts after the DCE announcement. Prior to that we were 81% Optimistic and 19% Pessimistic (I was already in that group)

 

[manlyfan76]

OK, So we're are we all at now?

No posts after the DCE announcement. Prior to that we were 81% Optimistic and 19% Pessimistic (I was already in that group)

Why? What's happened?

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I think we’re ****ed , but time will tell

 

[Seagles68]

Why? What's happened?

Rubes had a baby (well, his partner).

 

[manlyfan76]

Rubes had a baby (well, his partner).

We need 24-30 women volunteers so he can have a baby every round.

 

[Smokin Joe]

Probably shooting my load early ..
But thinking Storm/Sharks/Sea Eagles as GF favourites

 

[robbiea]

This game is the ultimate litmus test for the optimism/pessimism pulse !!!!!!
Our season is known soon

 

[BOZO]

We need 24-30 women volunteers so he can have a baby every round.

Good one @manlyfan76

Oh Yeh Baby .....
Rueben Scores Another Manly Try

 

[BOZO]

This game is the ultimate litmus test for the optimism/pessimism pulse !!!!!!
Our season is known soon

The Eels are no test
They are no benchmark
We can beat them with one hand tied behind our back feathered friend

 

[nightster]

The pulse is getting fainter, we need to make some big changes before we flatline

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

Six rounds in and it's deja vu all over again. Three wins, three losses, no signs of improvement anywhere. Tommy's injured, Cherry's checked out, forwards are bog average, and we have the strength and resilience of a soggy cardboard box. If you can see sunshine and rainbows in that (No! Not rainbows!), more power to you.

 

[mickqld]

The pulse is getting fainter, we need to make some big changes before we flatline

I'm calling it. Time of season 2025 death 4.50pm 12/4/25

 

[Once Was Brissie Kid]

 

[Phobia]

Six rounds in and it's deja vu all over again. Three wins, three losses, no signs of improvement anywhere. Tommy's injured, Cherry's checked out, forwards are bog average, and we have the strength and resilience of a soggy cardboard box. If you can see sunshine and rainbows in that (No! Not rainbows!), more power to you.

And Penn shall respond by sacking Seibold! For the exact same issues that plagued Des... Almost like a few long term signings prevent us from doing anything different, year after year.

I don't think we can reach the next level with those three. I want change. We haven't met the target of winning a comp with those three. Whether they're nice people or not, it's been a failure.

I see Mestrov and Seibold as strong operators, all the distractions in the Fulton's, pride jerseys, culture, etc, I think have been solved... But we are still not good enough. We simply don't have the personnel with $2 million on two players who might as well never play, and $1 million on someone who is playing like he already has a contract elsewhere.

Bring on Fogarty, Hoppa, and Navale.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

I'm calling it. Time of season 2025 death 4.50pm 12/4/25

You might be right, but meanwhile gave me a laugh anyway.
By the way everyone, Manly was outsiders in the last 2 games and not many (aside from Manly-blinded folks like us) expected us to win those games.
Not to mention Sharks had a 9 day turnaround v Manly's 6 day prep.
Yeah it's crap to lose (haven't seen the Sharks game yet) but a 6-point loss to a top 4 side... could be worse.
Not sure about optimism but at least I still have a pulse

 

[Brookie1973]

Probably shooting my load early ..
But thinking Storm/Sharks/Sea Eagles as GF favourites

Consider that load prematurely shot. Did not age well.