The impossible question perhaps never to be fully Answered.

[sheridanstand78]

In 1st, Wombat, 4 premierships, Manly team of the century full back, Snake 2nd, wonderful player, poetry in motion when running the ball, Tommy Turbo is still young in his career and if he stays healthy long term he will be right up there with those two guys. Special mention to other great full backs we had like Bob Batty, Dale Shearer and Matthew Ridge

 

[Under the Sticks]

#addwombattopoll

 

[Uk eagle]

I don't see where winning premierships comes into the debate about an individual player. It's virtually impossible to call between players of different generations as the game evolves all the time, you can only look at their contribution to the team. For mine Tommy is a great young player with the world at his feet, we should be grateful he chooses to play in the maroon and white because I would sure as hell hate for us to be facing him

 

[BOZO]

In terms of resilience The Wombat is number one
4 grand final wins and 12 amazing match winning years
Number 2 is the Electrifying Snake . Its a shame injury held him back
Number 3 is Terrific Turbo the new kid on the block who has all the potential to climb to number 1

 

[Supreme Leader]

Yep. Until Tommy wins a premiership, there's no comparison.

or punch a Melb player who's fighting his brother

 

[cherry_poppins]

Sorry Tommy but it's Snake all day and it's not even close

Snake to me should be an immortal, I've never seen a player like him, he made it look like he was that kid who shaves in under 10s, he was just that much better

Tom is a freak athlete and a footballer, Snake was a God by comparison