The Daly Cherrygraph

Here is a theory on why DCE asked for a release at the beginning of 2024 and can't get out of Manly quick enuf.

Nothing to do with money.

Everything to do with Seibold as being the coach. Or should I say, the coach who cannot coach.

DCE had 12 months of Seibolds inept coaching and also access to chatting to Broncos players in SOO to get an idea of the only coach to lead the Broncos to a spoon.

That is why he wants out. To play for a coach and a team that has a chance of winning a comp. No wonder he is going to the Roosters.
 
Last edited:
Here is a theory on why DCE asked for a release at the beginning of 2024 and can't get out of Manly quick enuf.

Nothing to so with money.

Everything to do with Seibold as being the coach. Or should I say, the coach who cannot coach.

DCE had 12 months of Seibolds inept coaching and also access to chatting to Broncos players in SOO to get an idea of the only coach to lead the Broncos to a spoon.

That is why he wants out. To play for a coach and a team that has a chance of winning a comp. No wonder he is going to the Roosters.
Like it or not, other than Hasler in 2021 we have looked our best under Siebold in the period ever since Tooves got the flick
 
Woodsie on Triple M this morning to Brett Read - reckons he got a tip off from someone who was at the gym talking to a local real estate agent who said they're appraising DCE's house in Curl Curl.

Read said he'll chase that down & find out what's going on.

LET THE SPECULATION CONTINUE!!!
Which one ??? 🧐
 
It's only a top 4 squad when Tom's playing and 100% fit. That's what I'm seeing now.

There is a large % of the posters stating that Tom needs to be replaced by Lehi at fullback, so according to that logic Tom is not required to make the top 4.
He certainly is required to win a comp imo.

Pappy played less games for Melb than Tom did last year for Manly. How come it didn't affect them like it does Manly?

Coaching, that is why.
 
There is a large % of the posters stating that Tom needs to be replaced by Lehi at fullback, so according to that logic Tom is not required to make the top 4.
He certainly is required to win a comp imo.

Pappy played less games for Melb than Tom did last year for Manly. How come it didn't affect them like it does Manly?

Coaching, that is why.
We don't have programmed foot soldiers like Melb has XV, we aren't that type of team unfortunately. In 2021 we got to 4th on the back of Tom's incredible season. Nothing's changed.
 
I think what we are lacking is potentially a coach who does not make its players accountable for their actions on the field as I remember last year hearing from one of the ex Melbourne players say that one of the things Bellamy does is gives the players a session altogether where they admit what they did wrong and make them selves accountable and if things are missed by themselves the coach will call them out on it. This mentality creates a stronger team as everyone admitting to what they have done and could do better gives the payers a understanding of where they are in the football team and as players.

If we are praising players all the time and the coach is saying things like we could of done better but Noone knows individually what that is then they just keep doing the same thing. I feel all the players need some hard truths spoken and players need the same for the coach. Accountability works both ways! We need to toughen up as a team and play like a Team!

I could be wromg but there seems to be to much Molly coddling going on. Look at the dogs atm as they are playing for each other cause they respect there coach and how he goes above toughening them up to make them better players so they play as a team!
 
Like it or not, we have a top 4 squad and have been under performing.
Scott Penn might think we have a top four squad, but really, we only have one forward who strikes fear into opposition packs (Haumole) and a handful of others who would struggle to strike mild concern into anyone on a good day. Our forwards just aren't good enough.

That said, no matter who our defensive coach is supposed to be, our maddening inability to tackle and compete in the ruck falls squarely on Seibold. We need to start showing improvement when we don't have the ball, and we need to do it quickly. Last year's glaring weaknesses are still this year's glaring weaknesses, which has to be a huge concern.
 
Scott Penn might think we have a top four squad, but really, we only have one forward who strikes fear into opposition packs (Haumole) and a handful of others who would struggle to strike mild concern into anyone on a good day. Our forwards just aren't good enough.

That said, no matter who our defensive coach is supposed to be, our maddening inability to tackle and compete in the ruck falls squarely on Seibold. We need to start showing improvement when we don't have the ball, and we need to do it quickly. Last year's glaring weaknesses are still this year's glaring weaknesses, which has to be a huge concern.

I don't buy that excuse either

Have a look at the Dogs pack that canned Newcastle on the weekend. Kikau was not even playing

A bunch of Neville's playing in the forwards, but playing as a well coached machine of effort on effort vs our forwards playing like a bunch of not coached individuals.
 
There is a large % of the posters stating that Tom needs to be replaced by Lehi at fullback, so according to that logic Tom is not required to make the top 4.
He certainly is required to win a comp imo.

Pappy played less games for Melb than Tom did last year for Manly. How come it didn't affect them like it does Manly?

Coaching, that is why.
Storm has better halves
 
Like it or not, we have a top 4 squad and have been under performing.
Top 4 squad of backs

Bottom 4 squad of forwards

Honestly , if the whole lot were put on the market there’s only one that other clubs would knock the door down for.

And where did yesterdays problems lie???

The coach 🤷🤷🤷

The backs 🤷🤷🤷

OR the bog average forwards ✅✅✅
 
Top 4 squad of backs

Bottom 4 squad of forwards

Honestly , if the whole lot were put on the market there’s only one that other clubs would knock the door down for.

And where did yesterdays problems lie???

The coach 🤷🤷🤷

The backs 🤷🤷🤷

OR the bog average forwards ✅✅✅

The age old saying "they need to lay the platform"
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 5 5 0 0 66 10
2 Broncos 5 4 0 1 66 8
3 Storm 4 3 0 1 62 8
4 Warriors 4 3 0 1 8 8
5 Rabbitohs 5 4 0 1 4 8
6 Sea Eagles 5 3 0 2 28 6
7 Raiders 5 3 0 2 -2 6
8 Titans 4 2 0 2 -4 6
9 Knights 4 2 0 2 -24 6
10 Sharks 5 2 0 3 15 4
11 Tigers 5 2 0 3 12 4
12 Dragons 4 1 0 3 -4 4
13 Cowboys 5 2 0 3 -50 4
14 Dolphins 5 1 0 4 -10 2
15 Panthers 5 1 0 4 -20 2
16 Roosters 5 1 0 4 -62 2
17 Eels 5 1 0 4 -85 2
Back
Top Bottom