The Clean Out 2025 Edition

[BOZO]

You would you appoint as coach in the interim Bozo?
Brad Arthur would be good but he is in England. Josh Hannah, Justin Holbrook ?

I love your Manly passion @Brooke
I love your care factor for our Legendary club
Passionate People that care like you ask answers
The people you should ask this caring question are the so called Professional Manly people at our club that get paid to make the Right decisions and hire the Right people that make Manly a success

Our club is in a similar Position To the sacked Bulldogs Board who were making the wrong decisions and Investing in the wrong people and after years of prolonged wrong decision making ended with the wooden spoon

The underperforming Bulldogs Board got Removed and the Rest is History .
Smart Club Operators have the answers .The Sooners we get those People at our club the better

 

[Tomay]

I’d be building a squad around

Lehi
Ola
Tolu
Bully

Then
Turbo at centre is worth a punt at the right price.
Paseka is a bench forward with potential to be worth a starter position though struggles in defence.
I like Jazz as a versatile bench piece while he still has something left.
Fogarty is a great stop gap. Perfect to help develop some younger half next to him.

That’s pretty much it.

 

[Phobia]

We're back baby!

Lodge can go thanks

 

[mutley]

saab can go with him cant catch cant tackle

 

[madmax]

We're back baby!

Lodge can go thanks

You mean the Lodge that actually stood up today & gave it to the Dogs pack whilst the rest pissed their pants? The only ones worth anything were Lodge, TKO, Koula & Garrick.

 

[Cliffycomeback]

You mean the Lodge that actually stood up today & gave it to the Dogs pack whilst the rest pissed their pants? The only ones worth anything were Lodge, TKO, Koula & Garrick.

Lodge was easily our best forward today. He has been very good for weeks.

 

[God]

I don't get how TT2 isn't a walk up stater he's the best center we have

 

[Rocky]

I don't get how TT2 isn't a walk up stater he's the best center we have

At a minimum he's ahead of Saab

 

[eaglebuzz]

NSW cup knocked over Penrith and some very good performances in there. Surely we shake up at least a few positions.

 

[God]

At a minimum he's ahead of Saab

If Koula was to move back to FB I'd stand by the comment he's the best center we have atm - Toms not right, Garrick's not a center and I'd even be open to seeing Aaron get a run with TT2 next week and put Tom out to pasture for awhile. what were doing isn't working

 

[Rocky]

If Koula was to move back to FB I'd stand by the comment he's the best center we have atm - Toms not right, Garrick's not a center and I'd even be open to seeing Aaron get a run with TT2 next week and put Tom out to pasture for awhile. what were doing isn't working

Yep just find a way to get him in the team. We need him there

 

[CRPSI eagle]

You mean the Lodge that actually stood up today & gave it to the Dogs pack whilst the rest pissed their pants? The only ones worth anything were Lodge, TKO, Koula & Garrick.

He was our best today!

 

[CRPSI eagle]

Lodge was easily our best forward today. He has been very good for weeks.

I would resign him

 

[Phobia]

I was unimpressed with the idiot Lodge making stupid plays and carrying on, as if we weren't 26 points behind.

He's likely to be suspended too. If he has a good game, it's no good if he's not there the next week. He's a first class dumbarse, and I would prefer someone more defensively minded i.e. Navale or Tevaga in the middle.

A lot of Dogs plays were created by Lodge's inability to slide in the middle.

 

[Super Coach Eagle]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1949377019571282037

 

[God]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1949377019571282037

Only thing I disagree with is it's four of them now with the brother in law....

 

[north coast eagle]

Parramatta are moving forward because they have had a comprehensive clean out. A proper clean out at Manly would include all players who aren't performing, including senior players. Cherry Evans going is a good start, however the Trbojevic's underperform week after week and yet management want to re-sign them on deals which are still way over the value they provide. Its frustrating and I weary of the way our club is managed. Sure they have signed some young guns, but they won't get a chance in first grade because in 2026 it will be the likes Brown, Croker and the Trbojevic's plodding around on one leg while the young talent will play NSW cup all year until out of desperation they sign with other clubs and then return to give us a flogging.

 

[JakeyB789]

Lodge was probably one of our better players today but who cares? Crap bloke, has whinged about his salary and had a number of injuries in his short time here.

He might be OK at footy every now and then but if we really want to try and turn things around. Matthew should be one of the first guys tapped on the shoulder.

 

[madmax]

I was unimpressed with the idiot Lodge making stupid plays and carrying on, as if we weren't 26 points behind.

He's likely to be suspended too. If he has a good game, it's no good if he's not there the next week. He's a first class dumbarse, and I would prefer someone more defensively minded i.e. Navale or Tevaga in the middle.

A lot of Dogs plays were created by Lodge's inability to slide in the middle.

Bull$hit!!

 

[XV-1]

Bull$hit!!

Good to see you are reading the game like a blind person 😂