The Circus - Starring MWSE as The Keystone Cops. Roll up! Roll up!!

Budgie

In for the long haul.
2016 Tipping Competitor
Tipping Member
Just trying to think my way through this whole nightmare situation and, despite the eagerness of so many to blame the media or the NRL, the blame sits squarely on the sloping shoulders of the club.

Please correct me if I'm wrong but this appears to be how it unfolded:

Dean Ritchie breaks a story that the players won't play with Jackson Hastings. We all know that Dean Ritchie has just the one sauce and that sits very nicely on a sausage roll.
So a leak comes from within the club.
That leads other journos to stick their collective noses up in the air and see what they can sniff out, only to find a punch up between our captain and the vanquished player in a quiet Queensland country town after humiliating loss #1.
Next our gallant club decides to send out the coach who may or may not know about football but doesn't have much of a grasp on the media, to a surprise press conference. He tells them that it's his decision and there have been a number of documented problems over a considerable period of time, thereby publicly humiliating one of this own contracted players. This causes some players to publicly declare that they don't have a problem with the 22 year old.
Seemingly Barrett stepped up to the press because our CEO was in NZ and it takes forever to get back from there.

At some point around here, humiliating loss #2 happened.

The Barrett statement leaves many questions about what happened in that quiet Queensland country town. Keeping in mind that everyone in the inner circle knew there was something to hide about said town, it's hard to believe the complete incompetency of the organisation at this point. Of course the journos were going to sniff around further. And what do they find?
Newspaper gold - a strip club!
Around this time, Barrett's public shaming of Hastings allows Rothfield to do the sympathy interview that anyone with an ounce of media nouse would know was coming.
Enter humiliating loss #3.
Next our esteemed Captain decides he should be fined $10,000. This information is released with no detail about what the fine was for. An invitation to dig further?
Finally, weeks after the sleepy Queensland country town, the Club issues a statement that four players will be fined for breaking curfew but refuses to name them. They seem to think that the names won't come out because the journos will have lost interest completely disregarding the fact that at least 13 other players will be defending their innocence to their friends and family. Unlikely leaks there, what?
Holy ****ing mololy.

And all of this on the back of a salary cap fine - sure, we didn't cheat or at least not as well as the others do - and the mindnumbingly stupid decision to bow to the threats of Blake Green's manager and grant him a release before they had a replacement.

What a joke of a club.

Clowns ladies and gentleman, we have clowns. Roll up, roll up. Come, see the joke of the NRL!!!!
 
I may be in a minority (possibly of one) but I think - given the original leak by 'someone' at the club - we have been set an impossible task trying to settle the ****-storm down. With remarkably little success, mind you, but we were painted into a corner by that original leak and put in a no-win situation.

If anyone in management/ownership is fair dinkum the source of said leak has to be identified, told off, and shown the door.
 
Hindsights 20/20 @:cool:

1) Manly aren't answerable to anyone for non-criminal issues

2) Coach picks the Team and should never qualify it to outsiders

3)
giphy.gif
 
You nailed it BE.

also guessing Barrett at some stage will have to get Hastings back into first grade (when we run out of other players) and it will all be regurgitated by the media again. Should have just ripped off the bandaid and played him this week
 
It's all moot. Zero chance this squad with cap issues and injuries makes finals. One more key player goes down (which is likely) and we are in deep **** (read: wooden spoon ****). To get out of this mess the players would have to resolve as a group to do something, but this group ain't going to do it, especially with DCE as captain.

No we will never ever get a wooden spoon
 
It’s been a common occurrence for the club for while now since the Penns took over ,The leaks to media .
Wind back the clock a few years back with the constant leaks one Geoff Toovey had to put up with
So while there is a leak instead of keeping things in house the rot will continue
As a Manly fan I try to let it roll nothing I can do about it but support the team and hope we come out the other side and start seeing some wins
 
I can only assume the Penns are one of those dumb luck families that fall into a successful business and money by chance and with little planning and thought required to succeed? Old money lot?

Shame we had to be the bored kid’s play toy.
To quote Scott Penn himself:

I ALWAYS had an entrepreneurial spirit. When I was 10 or 11, growing up in St Ives, Sydney, I knocked on doors to see if anyone needed odd jobs done.
I did the lemonade stand, a milk run, a paper run and delivered pamphlets. I worked at Woolies as a check-out chap all through high school. By Year 12 I was the check-out superviser.

Kid always aimed high.
His amazing riches to riches story can be read here: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/bu...0abbb3cfcd?sv=893d9a405dc8b815cd8fe71298aa28f
 
It's all moot. Zero chance this squad with cap issues and injuries makes finals. One more key player goes down (which is likely) and we are in deep **** (read: wooden spoon ****). To get out of this mess the players would have to resolve as a group to do something, but this group ain't going to do it, especially with DCE as captain.

This DCE as Captain stuff is annoying. There is no one else but DCE that can Captain the team.

There are two natural leaders in the team - Marty (by actions) and Tom (by talent) but no footy brain leaders that we are used to - BK, Beaver, Cliffy, Killer, Snake, etc that can turn adversity into a positive through actions or words.

DCE's problem is that he thinks he is a leader of men because of the "C". And because of that he will always be on the nose.
Good Leaders do the right things at the right times, Good Captains do the right things the right way.

On game day DCE does things the right way, but he doesn't always do the right things at the right times.

 
To quote Scott Penn himself:

I ALWAYS had an entrepreneurial spirit. When I was 10 or 11, growing up in St Ives, Sydney, I knocked on doors to see if anyone needed odd jobs done.
I did the lemonade stand, a milk run, a paper run and delivered pamphlets. I worked at Woolies as a check-out chap all through high school. By Year 12 I was the check-out superviser.

Kid always aimed high.
His amazing riches to riches story can be read here: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/bu...0abbb3cfcd?sv=893d9a405dc8b815cd8fe71298aa28f
none of that is actually entrepreneurial
 
You nailed it BE.

also guessing Barrett at some stage will have to get Hastings back into first grade (when we run out of other players) and it will all be regurgitated by the media again. Should have just ripped off the bandaid and played him this week
You are a very wise woman Miss Kate, or are you a bloke like Susan.
 
No @Ralphie I am double X chromosomes. But hey don't we all miss Susan, I am sure he would have some great insight into fixing some of our on field issues right now
 
Thank goodness I didn't become a Manly supporter because of their media savvy .....

They could send an intoxicated Fred Jones to do an interview without his teeth and I wouldn't give a flying ****.

I'm here for the football .... and at the moment .. that sucks ...
 
Thank goodness I didn't become a Manly supporter because of their media savvy .....

They could send an intoxicated Fred Jones to do an interview without his teeth and I wouldn't give a flying ****.

I'm here for the football .... and at the moment .. that sucks ...
That's the point darl.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe
  • lsz
    First Grader

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 6 6 0 0 98 14
2 Storm 6 4 0 2 70 10
3 Raiders 7 5 0 2 46 10
4 Warriors 6 4 0 2 -18 10
5 Broncos 7 4 0 3 54 8
6 Sharks 7 4 0 3 41 8
7 Dragons 6 3 0 3 20 8
8 Rabbitohs 7 4 0 3 -36 8
9 Cowboys 6 3 0 3 -42 8
10 Dolphins 7 3 0 4 28 6
11 Sea Eagles 7 3 0 4 20 6
12 Tigers 7 3 0 4 12 6
13 Titans 6 2 0 4 -36 6
14 Knights 6 2 0 4 -60 6
15 Panthers 7 2 0 5 -10 4
16 Roosters 7 2 0 5 -80 4
17 Eels 7 2 0 5 -107 4
Back
Top Bottom