Based on his performance levels so far - you would have to pass. He might turn out to be the greatest player ever but so far he has seemed not up to NRL standard. Now maybe he wasn't fit enough but if he wasn't - why not? That in itself shows a lack of application and desire on his behalf. But yep I am not a fan at all.... yet. He has a lot to prove I think but I gather it wont be in the maroon of Manly. Maybe a Hopoate Saab swap?Maybe its time for another vote (snicker snicker). I think unless he goes to the Dogs, and that would be literally what happens to him, he will sign with Manly.