The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

[Waz13]

There is a guy called Des coaching at the Titans, who seems to now have his team firing

Didn’t they lose to the last place team a week ago. Good win on the weekend tho.

 

[Ohgeez]

Didn’t they lose to the last place team a week ago. Good win on the weekend tho.

Yeah they are as inconsistent as us & have lost by 13+ 5 times this year. 5 points behind us on the competition ladder but to some people that’s firing?

 

[XV-1]

Didn’t they lose to the last place team a week ago. Good win on the weekend tho.

We also lost to Canberra. That former last placed team thrashed Canberra this weekend.

 

[Rocky]

We also lost to Canberra. That former last placed team thrashed Canberra this weekend.

And Manly beat the Roosters who thrashed Canberra, but beat Manly, who beat Penrith, who lost to St George who lost to Manly who lost to Brisbane who beat NQ.

What was your point again?

 

[Scorpio]

There is a guy called Des coaching at the Titans, who seems to now have his team firing

The Titans at nearly full strength got beaten by the Bunnies 46-12 only two weeks ago.

 

[BOZO]

There is a guy called Des coaching at the Titans, who seems to now have his team firing

We all Love Des as Des was a Manly Legend Lest We Forget
But his second coming at Manly was sombre
and he currently has the Titans firing blanks on the bottom of the table

Our Success is Defined by our Results
Keep scrolling down the Ladder and see just how Des's hot and cold and Inconsistent Titans are going

Pos	Team	Pos		Played	Points	Wins	Drawn	Lost	Byes	For	Against	Diff.	Home	Away	Form	Next
1		1	Storm	14	26	11	0	3	2	384	281	103	7 - 1	4 - 2	3 - 1	Raiders
2		2	Panthers	14	24	10	0	4	2	336	218	118	5 - 1	5 - 3	3 - 1	Cowboys
3		3	Sharks	14	24	10	0	4	2	354	276	78	5 - 2	5 - 2	1 - 3	Bulldogs
4		4	Roosters	15	20	9	0	6	1	440	279	161	4 - 3	5 - 3	3 - 1	Wests Tigers
5		5	Dolphins	14	20	8	0	6	2	365	305	60	3 - 4	5 - 2	1 - 3	Dragons
6		6	Bulldogs	14	18	7	0	7	2	300	237	63	6 - 0	1 - 7	3 - 1	Sharks
7		7	Broncos	14	18	7	0	7	2	335	298	37	4 - 3	3 - 4	0 - 3	Warriors
8		8	Cowboys	15	18	8	0	7	1	381	389	-8	3 - 3	5 - 4	3 - 1	Panthers
9		9	Dragons	14	18	7	0	7	2	296	346	-50	4 - 2	3 - 5	2 - 2	Dolphins
10		10	Raiders	14	18	7	0	7	2	296	375	-79	4 - 3	3 - 4	1 - 3	Storm
11		11	Sea Eagles	15	17	7	1	7	1	351	323	28	6 - 2	1 - 5	2 - 2	BYE
12		12	Knights	14	16	6	0	8	2	248	303	-55	3 - 4	3 - 4	0 - 3	Eels
13		13	Warriors	15	15	6	1	8	1	312	359	-47	4 - 3	2 - 5	2 - 2	Broncos
14		14	Rabbitohs	14	14	5	0	9	2	286	398	-112	4 - 4	1 - 5	4 - 0	BYE
15		15	Titans	14	12	4	0	10	2	305	376	-71	2 - 6	2 - 4	2 - 2	BYE
16		16	Wests Tigers	14	12	4	0	10	2	253	358	-105	3 - 4	1 - 6	2 - 2	Roosters
17		17	Eels	14	12	4	0	10	2	283	404	-121	4 - 4	0 - 6	1 - 3	Knightshttps://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2024/round-17/knights-v-eels/

 

[Cameron]

This is Brisbane all over again good juniors being lost. If humphries is off to souths that's another kid from the 2021 sg ball and Harold Matts side that both made gfs that will be gone.

Interesting on 360 last night braith asked should Siebold be punted if manly miss the 8.

Brent reed who is one of Siebold circle jerkers was quick to say no there's been Extenuating circumstances this year because Toms been injuried. That horse**** needed to be called out respectfully here's my tweet to that four eyed flog.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Brent curious about your comments on 360 regarding Seibold mate. If manly miss the 8 he should be gone. Penn has said it's a result driven business. Des made the top 4 was sacked the next season as was toovey. This season he has the team he wants having let many of the successful 2021 Ball and Matts team go to other clubs.

There's no Extenuating circumstances? Didn't des have that as well in 2022 with Tom having a season ending injury and the pride jersey but was still punted. Please no more excuses for poor results this is Brisbane all over again. Siebold out and Brad Arthur or toovey in.

 

[Ryan]

This is Brisbane all over again good juniors being lost. If humphries is off to souths that's another kid from the 2021 sg ball and Harold Matts side that both made gfs that will be gone.

Interesting on 360 last night braith asked should Siebold be punted if manly miss the 8.

Brent reed who is one of Siebold circle jerkers was quick to say no there's been Extenuating circumstances this year because Toms been injuried. That horse**** needed to be called out respectfully here's my tweet to that four eyed flog.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Brent curious about your comments on 360 regarding Seibold mate. If manly miss the 8 he should be gone. Penn has said it's a result driven business. Des made the top 4 was sacked the next season as was toovey. This season he has the team he wants having let many of the successful 2021 Ball and Matts team go to other clubs.

There's no Extenuating circumstances? Didn't des have that as well in 2022 with Tom having a season ending injury and the pride jersey but was still punted. Please no more excuses for poor results this is Brisbane all over again. Siebold out and Brad Arthur or toovey in.

Would you be cool with Tooves / Arthur (assistant) like it used to be? Good blend ! Tooves statistically has one of the most successful records tbh !

 

[Hotspur2014]

We all Love Des as Des was a Manly Legend Lest We Forget
But his second coming at Manly was sombre
and he currently has the Titans firing blanks on the bottom of the table

Our Success is Defined by our Results
Keep scrolling down the Ladder and see just how Des's hot and cold and Inconsistent Titans are going

Pos	Team	Pos		Played	Points	Wins	Drawn	Lost	Byes	For	Against	Diff.	Home	Away	Form	Next
1		1	Storm	14	26	11	0	3	2	384	281	103	7 - 1	4 - 2	3 - 1	Raiders
2		2	Panthers	14	24	10	0	4	2	336	218	118	5 - 1	5 - 3	3 - 1	Cowboys
3		3	Sharks	14	24	10	0	4	2	354	276	78	5 - 2	5 - 2	1 - 3	Bulldogs
4		4	Roosters	15	20	9	0	6	1	440	279	161	4 - 3	5 - 3	3 - 1	Wests Tigers
5		5	Dolphins	14	20	8	0	6	2	365	305	60	3 - 4	5 - 2	1 - 3	Dragons
6		6	Bulldogs	14	18	7	0	7	2	300	237	63	6 - 0	1 - 7	3 - 1	Sharks
7		7	Broncos	14	18	7	0	7	2	335	298	37	4 - 3	3 - 4	0 - 3	Warriors
8		8	Cowboys	15	18	8	0	7	1	381	389	-8	3 - 3	5 - 4	3 - 1	Panthers
9		9	Dragons	14	18	7	0	7	2	296	346	-50	4 - 2	3 - 5	2 - 2	Dolphins
10		10	Raiders	14	18	7	0	7	2	296	375	-79	4 - 3	3 - 4	1 - 3	Storm
11		11	Sea Eagles	15	17	7	1	7	1	351	323	28	6 - 2	1 - 5	2 - 2	BYE
12		12	Knights	14	16	6	0	8	2	248	303	-55	3 - 4	3 - 4	0 - 3	Eels
13		13	Warriors	15	15	6	1	8	1	312	359	-47	4 - 3	2 - 5	2 - 2	Broncos
14		14	Rabbitohs	14	14	5	0	9	2	286	398	-112	4 - 4	1 - 5	4 - 0	BYE
15		15	Titans	14	12	4	0	10	2	305	376	-71	2 - 6	2 - 4	2 - 2	BYE
16		16	Wests Tigers	14	12	4	0	10	2	253	358	-105	3 - 4	1 - 6	2 - 2	Roosters
17		17	Eels	14	12	4	0	10	2	283	404	-121	4 - 4	0 - 6	1 - 3	KnightsKnights v Eels

Add the outstanding second byes Roosters are 22pts and 4th,Cowboys 20pts and 6th, and WE are 19pts and 7th in the Top 8.
But even in saying that “I’m proud of the boys” Siebold is a soft c..k, and not the DNA we need at Manly.
Could you imagine our team with a Bellamy “no nonsense “ style coach leading the way instead of this “pussyfoot” approach we currently have.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Could you imagine our team with a Bellamy “no nonsense “ style coach leading the way instead of this “pussyfoot” approach we currently have.

Bellamy is Bellamy, but there are heaps of 'no-nonsense' style coaches who only have very mediocre results.
Finding the right coach is all but impossible, so historically Manly has produced it's own top coaches from former greats who were tough and bled for Manly. But even that doesn't always work, Thommo and Tooves for example.
Seibs is under contract for now, lets see if this year shows improvement from last year, if so sacking him without a better replacement would be cutting of our nose to spite our face.

 

[Disco]

This is Brisbane all over again good juniors being lost.

Can you elaborate on this one please?

What good junior's left Brisbane whilst Seibold was there?

He issue was he lent too much on youth and had no leaders.

All the below were under 23 and got minutes minutes under Seibold. Fifita and Deardon left after Seibold.

TURPIN,
CROFT,
CARRIGAN,
ARTHARS,
O'SULLIVAN,
STAGGS,
FLEGLER,
HAAS,
FARNWORTH,
RIKI,
PAIX,
BULLEMOR,
FIFITA,
COATES,
DEARDEN,
NIU,

 

[SeaEagleSI1]

Seibold set to face ‘hard questions’ after ‘diabolical’ Manly showing, head-scratching call​

'Diabolical!" Sea Eagles slip out of 8 | 02:30

Daniel Nuttall from Fox Sports
June 25th, 2024 8:09 am
Questions have been raised over the future of Manly coach Anthony Seibold after the Sea Eagles dished up a “horrific” performance in a 14-0 loss to South Sydney.
In a game veteran journalist Brent Read labelled as “awful”, Manly looked listless in attack without star halfback Daly Cherry-Evans, gun back rower Haumole Olakau’atu, Jake Trbojevic and Reuben Garrick.
NRL360 host Braith Anasta didn’t mince words about the Sea Eagles after they failed to score a point against a Rabbitohs team that was also missing stars Latrell Mitchell and Cam Murray.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

A case of "plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose,"?

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Re: the Nutty Daniel Foxtel excerpt, who is asking the hard questions? No mention there of Penstrov asking the hard questions.

 

[Cameron]

Seibold set to face ‘hard questions’ after ‘diabolical’ Manly showing, head-scratching call​

'Diabolical!" Sea Eagles slip out of 8 | 02:30

Daniel Nuttall from Fox Sports
June 25th, 2024 8:09 am
Questions have been raised over the future of Manly coach Anthony Seibold after the Sea Eagles dished up a “horrific” performance in a 14-0 loss to South Sydney.
In a game veteran journalist Brent Read labelled as “awful”, Manly looked listless in attack without star halfback Daly Cherry-Evans, gun back rower Haumole Olakau’atu, Jake Trbojevic and Reuben Garrick.
NRL360 host Braith Anasta didn’t mince words about the Sea Eagles after they failed to score a point against a Rabbitohs team that was also missing stars Latrell Mitchell and Cam Murray.

Brad Arthur is the man. Maybe with Tooves as his assistant. No madge or jd

 

[Ryan]

Seibold set to face ‘hard questions’ after ‘diabolical’ Manly showing, head-scratching call​

'Diabolical!" Sea Eagles slip out of 8 | 02:30

Daniel Nuttall from Fox Sports
June 25th, 2024 8:09 am
Questions have been raised over the future of Manly coach Anthony Seibold after the Sea Eagles dished up a “horrific” performance in a 14-0 loss to South Sydney.
In a game veteran journalist Brent Read labelled as “awful”, Manly looked listless in attack without star halfback Daly Cherry-Evans, gun back rower Haumole Olakau’atu, Jake Trbojevic and Reuben Garrick.
NRL360 host Braith Anasta didn’t mince words about the Sea Eagles after they failed to score a point against a Rabbitohs team that was also missing stars Latrell Mitchell and Cam Murray.

Wait, wasn't the performance brave, and something to be proud of given all our players missing? That's what I've been told to feel, anyway? Surely Cooper Cronk, Braith Anasta, Gordon Tallis (who have all played for Australia) don't know as much as our Silvertail bretheren? Surely those ex-players and I are missing something. Come ON guys, we didn't give up, and tried !!!

 

[Rocky]

46 pages of Sack Seibold and the best replacement I've seen put forward is Brad Arthur?

FMD....marginal upgrade at best, and won't move the needle.

Thats not to say Seibold shouldn't go if we miss the 8..but it really is slim pickings.

 

[Ryan]

46 pages of Sack Seibold and the best replacement I've seen put forward is Brad Arthur?

FMD....marginal upgrade at best, and won't move the needle.

Thats not to say Seibold shouldn't go if we miss the 8..but it really is slim pickings.

Well, Cameron suggested Tooves. And others have suggested Arthur. I suggested both. Last time that occurred, we were winning plenty of games. Of coaches that have coached 10 games or more, Toovey is 40th - ever ! That's pretty impressive, given there have been 325 coaches (that's top 8-9% of coaches ever).

 

[Rocky]

Well, Cameron suggested Tooves. And others have suggested Arthur. I suggested both. Last time that occurred, we were winning plenty of games. Of coaches that have coached 10 games or more, Toovey is 40th - ever ! That's pretty impressive, given there have been 325 coaches (that's top 8-9% of coaches ever).

Hey Ryan - we all love Tooves but he inherited a pretty good team - which I would attribute to his impressive win percentage.

I think it is pretty telling he hasn't been offered a gig since. I think that ship has sailed.

 

[mave]

Hey Ryan - we all love Tooves but he inherited a pretty good team - which I would attribute to his impressive win percentage.

I think it is pretty telling he hasn't been offered a gig since. I think that ship has sailed.

Tend to agree.
Love the legend, but I'm not sure NRL coaching is for Toovs these days.