The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

[bob dylan]

We have a side that can easy make the top 4. But they dont care. Seibs most definitely needs to go.

I agree with the 2nd part of this.

 

[Hertera]

Don’t think a discussion is needed,he shouldn’t get an extension.The team has not improved in his 18 months.They are losing the same way as last season and much like last year,the wins are far from convincing.No excuses this year,this is his(managers) team

They will now blame injuries

 

[bob dylan]

He can stick his manly mentality and all his corporate mumbo jumbo and piss right off. He is a pretender. If Mestrov even thinks about extending him he can **** off too. Time to get toovey back

Reminder me Toovey was ever sacked?

It certainly wasnt performance.

And make Jake captain at least he cares.

 

[XV-1]

They will now blame injuries

Will they also blame we only have 26 players signed.

 

[Uk eagle]

I’m done with Seibs. The whole approach to the way we play is off…got some many naturally gifted footballers…all they needed was someone to bring hard edge and we’d be fine…instead he decided to coach us to throw the ball around all off season. Worst defence in the league by a long way….

Could you imagine a Wayne Bennett approach with our roster? We'd be top two for certain, there's no way we would have lost the games we have this year

 

[Cameron]

Yep sack him and Mestrov

 

[Jerry1]

His numbers when compared to a lot of other current NRL coaches are pretty similar. In fact, when comparing his numbers (win/loss %) to Kevin Walter's numbers, they are almost exactly the same. His numbers would suggest that he is an average NRL coach, but certainly no worse than a lot of his peers. Personally, I think out of all of the other similar NRL coaches (excluding Bellamy, Cleary, Robinson, Bennett etc), Seibold has the greatest upside. He is currently shaping the Manly side for 2024/2025. Let's see how he goes next season (I see him improving his win/loss percentage with us to around the 60% range next year). Go Manly.

Team	Name	Time as coach	Prem	W	L	D	GC	Win%	Prem	W	L	D	GC	Win%
		Current							Career
Brisbane	Kevin Walters	2 years, 235 days	0	27	30	0	57	48%	0	27	30	0	57	48%
Canberra	Ricky Stuart	9 years, 235 days	0	115	107	1	223	51.8%	1	236	230	2	468	50.5%
Canterbury-Bankstown	Cameron Ciraldo	235 days	0	4	6	0	10	40%	0	7	9	0	16	44%
Cronulla-Sutherland	Craig Fitzgibbon	1 year, 235 days	0	22	11	0	33	67%	0	22	11	0	33	67%
Gold Coast	Jim Lenihan †	2 days	0	0	0	0	0	0%	0	0	0	0	0	0%
Manly-Warringah	Anthony Seibold	235 days	0	4	4	1	9	48%	0	36	39	2	77	47%
Melbourne	Craig Bellamy	20 years, 279 days	3	364	158	2	524	69.8%	3	365	158	2	525	69.5%
New Zealand	Andrew Webster	235 days	0	5	5	0	10	50%	0	5	8	0	13	38.5%
Newcastle	Adam O'Brien	3 years, 235 days	0	32	46	2	80	41.5%	0	32	46	2	80	41.5%
North Queensland	Todd Payten	2 years, 235 days	0	29	31	0	60	48%	0	35	39	0	74	48.5%
Parramatta	Brad Arthur	9 years, 235 days	0	126	115	0	241	52.4%	0	126	115	0	241	52.4%
Penrith	Ivan Cleary	4 years, 235 days	2	78	24	1	103	75.8%	2	218	178	4	398	55.3%
Dolphins	Wayne Bennett	235 days	0	6	4	0	10	60%	7	561	322	14	897	63%
South Sydney	Jason Demetriou	1 year, 235 days	0	23	14	0	37	62.3%	0	23	14	0	37	62.3
St. George Illawarra	Ryan Carr †	39 days	0	2	2	0	4	50%	0	2	2	0	4	50%
Sydney Roosters	Trent Robinson	10 years, 235 days	3	166	93	0	259	64.5%	3	166	93	0	259	64.5%
Wests Tigers	Tim Sheens	235 days	0	2	7	0	9	22%	4	342	329	11	681	50.4%

Doesn't have his Brisbane stats in that does it?

 

[Nordburg]

They will now blame injuries

We have 10 rounds of evidence to show that there has been no improvement.Minimal injuries this season prior to tonight

 

[Hertera]

Will they also blame we only have 26 players signed.

Yeah any excuse they can use will be trotted out

 

[mickqld]

Yep sack him and Mestrov

Both full of spin , piss and wind.

 

[The '47ers]

Could you imagine a Wayne Bennett approach with our roster? We'd be top two for certain, there's no way we would have lost the games we have this year

We probably would still lose them games, they are pea hearts. They wouldn't get a run on a Mardi gras float.

 

[skull61]

Just sack everyone and move the club to Perth with Schu as captain

 

[Hertera]

Whoever signed Scu again should walk as that will handicap our recruitment going forward when he had shown he was not worthy of an extension.

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

He crucified Brisbane a few years ago because he has no idea about defence & now it’s happening here.Agree with you all he needs to go.

 

[Uk eagle]

We probably would still lose them games, they are pea hearts. They wouldn't get a run on a Mardi gras float.

No heart? I don't think they'd get picked by Bennett

 

[Heckenberg]

He can stick his manly mentality and all his corporate mumbo jumbo and piss right off. He is a pretender. If Mestrov even thinks about extending him he can **** off too. Time to get toovey back

Guy needs to use less PowerPoint presentations and buzzwords and get this pack of bludgers running through brick walls for him. We need a motivator not a technician. Our team has all the talent in the world but no spine.

 

[Jerry1]

NRL Press Conference: Dolphins v Sea Eagles - Round 10, 2024 He hasn't got a clue..

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

And we wanted des out what a twist of events.

 

[Dion Johnson]

Will they also blame we only have 26 players signed.

I don’t think they can blame the amount of players signed, the administration side of things with filling the 30 had been extremely slow since Fulton left on the 15TH of March officially and they haven’t acted visibly from his departure let alone Schuster moving on in April.

 

[Rocky]

Do you guys ever blame the players?

I saw a lot of bad things that had nothing to do with the coach.

The reality is Tom is a shadow of his best, DCE is rocks and diamonds and there are some lazy forwards.

I'm not giving Seibold a free pass but honestly blaming the coach for everything is fcking as lazy as Matt Lodge.