Silvertails greatest ever whipping boy

[mosto]

Just flicked on Fox League to have as a bit of background noise while I work. They're replaying Eagles v Sharks from 2004. First play I saw was a very lean and fit looking Hoppa making a break from dummy half, drawing the fullback and hitting a wide open Jye Mullane right on chest who promptly spilled his lollies. I immediately thought of what a whipping boy (justifiably) Mullane was on here back in the day.

With that in mind, which player in your time on ST has been the biggest whipping boy? Which player, rightly or wrongly, copped the most flack on here? Two others that immediately come to mind (also both justifiably) are Nate Myles and Lewis Brown.

 

[MadMarcus]

Lewis Brown has probably been the biggest but I think Nate deserved it more!

 

[mosto]

Forget the Whipping boys
They have been whipped long enough

Time to put up a posts about Silvertails Greatest Poster Boy !
View attachment 29165

C'mon Bozo, surely you've got one last crack at Parker in you....

 

[BOZO]

C'mon Bozo, surely you've got one last crack at Parker in you....

Let the Manly Man Retire in Peace
He did his personal best and that is to Play in our Legendary clubs colors
A feat that all of us feathered friends only dreamed of doing .

 

[The Wheel]

There has been a few - Willo, Ian Donnelly

 

[joeboy]

Luke Williamson . One of our duds for sure

 

[Uber Eagle 72]

Jye mullane ?

 

[The Indian]

Kane Cleal was one who's ears were burning back in the day. That early 2000's team was chock a block with whipping boys.

 

[manlyfan76]

DCE copped it in his first year.
Orford before that.

 

[nightster]

There has been a few - Willo, Ian Donnelly

Villiame

 

[Disco]

As soon as I saw this thread title I thought of Mullane

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Mullane was a perennial favourite on here for years.

But I think Nate Myles & Aaron Woods in more recent times

 

[double hoops]

Wasn't Willow referred to as the GOAT.

Ah no that's right he had the 🐐 photos.

 

[maxta]

I reckon most who have copped critisism deserve it, hell I kick myself up the ass everyday when Im not performing and fans have a right to throw out opinions, as long as its not a low blow or too personal and has legs....in saying that Myles springs to mind and I think I give a thumbs up to every post about those terrible performances and lack of effort....and there was a fullback from NZ named Yogi or something when I was a kid, absolute nightmare player and was run out of Manly pretty quickly by memory

 

[Ryan]

You know you're doing something well, when a Mullaniac Stand @ Brooky was invented just to troll the poor bloke. @Dan also had a thing for Steve Matai's pants Was it Matai's pants? Possibly George Carmont?

 

[Dan]

You know you're doing something well, when a Mullaniac Stand @ Brooky was invented just to troll the poor bloke. @Dan also had a thing for Steve Matai's pants Was it Matai's pants? Possibly George Carmont?

George carmonts socks it was like he had short shorts on because he wore tiny socks

 

[Ryan]

George carmonts socks it was like he had short shorts on because he wore tiny socks

That was it mate ! GOLD hahaha. But ooooof, how bad is my memory. Sending you a text mate - good news 🙂 I'm a happy boy

 

[Dan]

That was it mate ! GOLD hahaha. But ooooof, how bad is my memory. Sending you a text mate - good news 🙂 I'm a happy boy

Sweet look forward to it. Remember how much we yelled at him on the sidelines?

Particular highlights were matas getting that panthers winger to stick his finger up at us from Reggie's and thr touch judge in another game sticking his finger up at us

 

[Ryan]

Sweet look forward to it. Remember how much we yelled at him on the sidelines?

Particular highlights were matas getting that panthers winger to stick his finger up at us from Reggie's and thr touch judge in another game sticking his finger up at us

My all time favorite still mate was you tearing the Dragons players apart on the sideline at Albion Park, with @Chuck Wood and I ! This huge unit of a woman stands up and tells you to stop cursing or she'll get her husband to do something about it. We all looked at the husband, and he shakes his head to say **** no, I won't, ****ting himself ! hahaha

 

[LeonardCohen]

Villiame

Do you mean Brayden Wiliame?