That is interesting, and refreshing to hear.
In Jake's case, I think it's probably true as well: everybody loves him and the way he plays, not just Manly fans. And he's won State of Origins and a World Cup for Australia. Tom, too, has dominated State of Origin games, although injuries have also limited his opportunities.
I guess the "tragedy" of them not winning a premiership for Manly would really only be from a fan's perspective. But they'll be remembered as champion players and Manly greats no matter what.