Sea Eagles Elimination Game 2025 (pre-season forum game)

[Carl]

Looks like there might be a concurrency issue with this process.

I see turbo went up to 10 and back to 9 without being down voted.

 

[Disco]

Tooves knows what we need

 

[mosto]

Aaron Schoupp (4)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7) (+1)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (9)
Tommy Talau (5)
Aitasi James (2)
Ben Trbojevic (4) (-1)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (7)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)

==============

ELIMINATED:

1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan#post 8
2. Josh Aloiai (Harmlesss post #19)

@mosto you might have forgotten to award a minus

No I gave a minus to Aloiai

 

[rmd]

Aaron Schoupp (3) -1
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (9)
Tommy Talau (5)
Aitasi James (2)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (8) +1
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)

 

[Ryan]

Aaron Schoupp (2) - - - - -
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6) ++++
Aitasi James (2)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (8)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)

1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19

* Tom Trbojevic amended back to correct value

 

[NREagle]

Aaron Schoupp (2)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Aitasi James (1) - - - -
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (9)++++
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)

1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19

 

[deanm]

Aaron Schoupp (2)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)++++++
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Aitasi James (1) - - - - - - - -
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (9)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)

 

[rmd]

Hi Ryan

So you say 'one per day'? By the beginning of pre season we are likely to have BA on the list. Is that the idea?

 

[Dion Johnson]

Aaron Schoupp (2)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (4)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (6) +++++++
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Aitasi James (1)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (9)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (4) - - - - - - -
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)


1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19

 

[Disco]

Did Atasi James get minuses two posts in a row but stay the say???

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Some player, shame injury has cut his career short

Did Atasi James get minuses two posts in a row but stay the say???

@Ryan - also I've assumed we can't select the same players we did before (?) (hard to keep track of!)

 

[nightster]

If everyone does it this way it will work better ..... imho - " Indicate the increase in green (or at least use a + sign), and the decrease in red (or at least use a - sign)."

 

[nightster]

Aaron Schoupp (2)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (7)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (3)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (6)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Aitasi James (1)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (9)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (4)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)


1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19

 

[NREagle]

Aaron Schoupp (2)
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (8)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (2) - - - -
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (6)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (10)+++++++
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (4)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)


1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27

**updated post to amend DCE to correct value (and delete James)

 

[NREagle]

Did Atasi James get minuses two posts in a row but stay the say???

I've corrected this (and DCE's tally) with my latest post.

 

[maxta]

Aaron Schoupp (1) - 1
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (9) +1
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (8) + 1
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (2) - - - -
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5) + 1 (Sorry but apart from a great try ordinary 2024)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (7) + 1 (One of few players to be at 100% every week)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (3) - 1 ( Fell away as season went on 2024)
Ethan Bullemor (6)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (11)+++++++ (The Best Forward NRL 2025)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (7) + 1 (Slow but inspirational leader)
Jazz Tevaga (5) + 1 ( Limited, but Will add plenty)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (4) + 1 (Never reached potential...as yet )
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (8) + 1 (Looks mean in pre season training 🙂
Toff Sipley (6)

1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27

**updated post to amend DCE to correct value (and delete James)

 

[Ryan]

Aaron Schoupp (1) - - - - -
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (8)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (2)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (6)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (7) + + + +
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (10)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (4)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)


1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19

 

[Ryan]

@Ryan - also I've assumed we can't select the same players we did before (?) (hard to keep track of!)

Yes, you can pick the same player each day - i.e. you could vote for Jake for a + + + each day, and say another other player for a - - - - each day

 

[Ryan]

Aaron Schoupp (0) - - - -
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (9)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (8)
Luke Brooks (5)
Raymond Vaega (2)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (5)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (7)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (3)
Ethan Bullemor (7) + + +
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (11)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (7)
Jazz Tevaga (5)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (4)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (8)
Toff Sipley (6)

1. Dean Matterson by @Ryan post #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27
4. Aaron Schoupp by @Ryan post # 36

Hey mate, thanks for taking part. Can you please do a single plus on ONE player, and a minus on ONE player per day - I had to exclude your post because it was too hard to unwind, so please feel free to try again within the rules of the game - thanks mate.

 

[Stuey Davis’s Socks]

Aaron Schoupp (0) - - - - -
Clayton Faulalo (5)
Daly Cherry-Evans (8)
Jake Arthur (5)
Jason Saab (5)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (7)
Luke Brooks (6)++++
Raymond Vaega (2)
Reuben Garrick (5)
Tolutau Koula (6)
Tom Trbojevic (10)
Tommy Talau (6)
Ben Trbojevic (4)
Corey Waddell (4)
Ethan Bullemor (7)
Gordon Cham Kum Tong (5)
Haumole Olakau'atu (10)
Jake Simpkin (7)
Jake Trbojevic (6)
Jazz Tevaga (4)
Lachlan Croker (5)
Michael Chee Kam (5)
Nathan Brown (5)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (6)
Taniela Paseka (7)
Toff Sipley (6)


1. Dean Matterson by @Ryanpost #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19