Sack Spoony Siebold

[Brookie1973]

What about Cleary , by your measurements he’s a dud now too

My measurement is that Seibold has had zero success and our team looks poorly coached. If you think we look like a well coached team, I would be interested to hear it. There is no universe in which Seibold and Cleary should be mentioned together.

 

[Brookie1973]

100%

Our forward pack , bar 2, maybe 3 are as soft as custard.

Blow the entire place up , start again.

Love Tommy , what a champion , but we just cannot base our side around him and expect success.

Love Jake, the heart of a lion and no one is more invested , but at $950k a year it’s way way overs.

And you reckon the “cartel” sound like a broken record.

 

[seaeagle10]

Bellamy turns average players into good players, Bennet helps get the best out of his players, Robinson, has his players believing in him and themselves Siebold can successfully turn a good team into a mob of chumps. With that I would like to thank our front office/ owners for giving manly supporters so much grief

 

[CRPSI eagle]

My mail is the Trebojavic’s are the new Fulton's and becoming disliked.

 

[2830 Eagle]

Today was the first time this year I tipped against Manly, don't know if I'm happy or sad.

 

[Phobia]

My mail is the Trebojavic’s are the new Fulton's and becoming disliked.

Do you have a source in the club?

If Jake is asking for money similar to what he's currently earning, I would be put off too. They have not delivered on their contracts, good people or not. I don't blame Turbo, but Jake needed to be fitter... 5 years ago.

 

[mave]

I don't think he should be sacked, this year anyway, but we need to see some change in the line-up now.
I can understand some loyalty to bounce back after last weekends horror show, but we didn't get that today.

So time to see Navale, Paloto, get a crack.
Bully to an edge maybe (although he's better middle).

Time to send a message.

 

[Brookie1973]

Yep by those measurements he’s a complete dud

No, the fact he has won 4 premierships means he is not a dud. It’s called a proven track record. It sounds like your measurement is that Seibold is not a dud because other teams also lose games.

 

[mave]

4 comps straight buys you a lot of losing in the 5th year.

 

[fLIP]

Daly’s already clocked off. We will meander through another one win two loss repeat season we’ve seen for the last 10 years.

There’s no resilience, the first sign of pressure we go to water. I hesitate to say it’s the coach because we’ve been through a few and nothings changed.

Perhaps it’s a culture thing and now the ring leader has packed up his toys and wants to go, we might well be in for the worst.

 

[The better Robbo]

Honestly, our attack today was absolutely bereft of any meaningful direction. Apart from two intercept trays we were complete crap. This guy is one dimensional in his coaching. The Warriors made him look silly in Auckland. The Storm made him look very silly at Brookvale. And an off their game Sharks made him look like the pop gun attack coach he so obviously is.

Oh, and he's just too bloody nice, as if he's so scared of upsetting the players.

Is it the coach or is it our spine?
Tevaga and Simpkins would be at the lowest level of hookers in the 17 teams. Hoppa is a young gun and very safe but is really unable to create like the better fullbacks in the comp. DCE has always been a flat track bully. Brooks was side today but again isn't a very creative half. Personally I'd bring in Arthur, Nevale and Wakeham into the 17. I don't think we have the mix quite right. From today's team Sipley, Tevaga and Ben T out.

 

[Rafferty]

Bring back Des

Thats a big no thanks for me……..

 

[Rafferty]

Maybe Dalai

Would be an upgrade on what we currently have

 

[Cliffy's Jockstrap]

T-Baz says I'm still available!

 

[Thewestisbest]

Is it the coach or is it our spine?
Tevaga and Simpkins would be at the lowest level of hookers in the 17 teams. Hoppa is a young gun and very safe but is really unable to create like the better fullbacks in the comp. DCE has always been a flat track bully. Brooks was side today but again isn't a very creative half. Personally I'd bring in Arthur, Nevale and Wakeham into the 17. I don't think we have the mix quite right. From today's team Sipley, Tevaga and Ben T out.

Agreed with most of that Robbo. Nevertheless, this is Spoons third season as coach and he has failed to do anything much to fix the glaring problems we have in our side. The same problems he inherited when he stepped into the role.

 

[Thewestisbest]

Same thing, every loss , it’s like a cracked record.

The fact our forward pack , bar 2 , are as soft has custard has “ nothing “ ti do with it 😂😂😂

How many seasons do you want to give him to fix the bloody problems Mark? That is what a coach does.

 

[Thewestisbest]

The football team needs a complete "clean out" like the Dogs did. DCE leaving is positive for the cap and the next 2 that need serious pay reductions is Turbo and Jake. If both players are unhappy, I would be incline to let both go to the highest bidder.

Another good post Leonard.

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

Burbo sucks and keppie doing well at souffs

No comment on Burbo, but Keppie is doing Keppie things at Souths. For every good run or strong tackle there's a brain explosion that ends up costing his team. Case in point, high shot on Drinkwater, 10 in the bin, penalty right in front. That's the Keppie we all know and love.

 

[Thewestisbest]

My goodness, I just listened to the press conference and switched it off at about halfway. Siebs was really proud, DCE was really proud too and there was a lot to like about today's performance. Stick a fork in us folks, we are done barring a Turbo injury free run. Turbo only paper's over the cracks I'm afraid. Spoon just doesn't have that competitive ruthlessness sadly. He's a soft touch.

It's ridiculous to call first grade footballers soft. None of them are soft. But Spoon presents as soft in terms of being a head coach. He comes across softer than any other NRL coach.

 

[Brookie1973]

My goodness, I just listened to the press conference and switched it off at about halfway. Siebs was really proud, DCE was really proud too and there was a lot to like about today's performance. Stick a fork in us folks, we are done barring a Turbo injury free run. Turbo only paper's over the cracks I'm afraid. Spoon just doesn't have that competitive ruthlessness sadly. He's a soft touch.

It's ridiculous to call first grade footballers soft. None of them are soft. But Spoon presents as soft in terms of being a head coach. He comes across softer than any other NRL coach.

Seriously? It sounds like the mindset is we shouldn’t expect to win without Tom, so a close loss is praiseworthy. Just like the “free throw at the stumps” in that Souths game last year. Unbelievable from a first grade NRL coach to be continually “proud” about losses. What message does he think that sends to the players. Sweet, we don’t need to bust our arses to win because the coach will be ok with a close loss.

The only thing to like about today’s game was that we weren’t beaten by more by a clearly out of sorts sharks team. And it was only close because of some flukey individualist tries which had nothing to do with team structures or coaching.

Unbelievable that some people on here can’t see the bleeding obvious.