Sack Seibold Immediately

[Lyons2beaver]

I think Penn backing Seibold for another season is the worst news to come out of
Manly all season, hopefully after a run of losses early next year he is politely move to someone else in the Club away from coaching, we can only hope.

 

[CRPSI eagle]

I see a wooden spoon coming our way! This imbecile will not rest till he adds another spoon on his resume.
What a disaster, you could not write this script to this horror show.

 

[Brookie1973]

I did that last Monday..... 5 memberships not being renewed. We've been season ticket members in Jane Try for 15 years and when I advised them I am not renewing the families tickets I received an email that thanked me for my 4 years of membership? I don't get how they get that wrong?

If I was CEO of an organisation that just had a 15 year grandstand ticketed member cancel their membership, I would be on the phone /contacting that member asap to understand why and see if I could convince them to change their mind. The fact you got crickets speaks volumes.

 

[Phobia]

The bottom line will be a lot worse, if Seibold remains the face of the coaching department next season. The thoughts echoed on here regarding membership aren't unique to Silvertails, and no doubt will affect Fluffy's margin.

I don't think the leaking of Ennis earlier in the season was accidental. I think some of it has come from management to get a gauge for how the community feels about the options for next year.

That response was:
Seibold: ****ing ****
Ennis: Why
Ballin: Okay

This is based upon nothing but rumours, but I expect our coaching structure to be something like:

Coaching Director (or some other background role): Seibold

Head Coach: Ballin

Assistants: Not sure. I would think Dymock, and in particular, Hales, would be under a lot of pressure.

Specialist: Ennis

 

[Damien2812]

I did that last Monday..... 5 memberships not being renewed. We've been season ticket members in Jane Try for 15 years and when I advised them I am not renewing the families tickets I received an email that thanked me for my 4 years of membership? I don't get how they get that wrong?

Same with my membership. The membership team don't know how long I've been a continuous member and printed "since 2022" on my membership card.

 

[Ben]

Doubt if any S L club would be prepared to outlay any more then 300 - 350 K for him but see where you are coming from
Would give Walsh a crack at 6 irrespective if Brooksie stayed on or not
Brooks "s defence has still largely measured up this season again but attack or options has been way off in general
Maybe Fogarty ;s presence can help and a bit more go forward with a hopefully full strength pack again but definitely like the notion again of Walsh being given a go at 6 starting with the trials or seasons preparation
May even happen this season in the last few games at 6 or 7

If you watch Fogarty closely he isn’t on the ball as much as DCE but that could also be a structure that the Raiders have in place. Usually he barks instructions directing traffic off the ball sometimes only touching the ball in a set to kick down town, where DCE receives the ball and tries to create.
For this reason this could unlock Brooks a little more as he will have more opportunities with ball in hand. Or also could go the other way and highlight how poor he can be. It’s going to be a hard swing either way.

You see how great Strange has been running the ball, just not sure if Brooks will have the same impact.

Walsh on the other hand is a different storey.

 

[CoreyWaddellSuperFan]

They're talking about Ennis for 2027 with the dud coach as football manager and the dud coach continuing next year and with Ennis not stepping into his first ever assistant role but continuing as a dud attack consultant?

Is that right?

I need a proper team to support

 

[Brookie1973]

They're talking about Ennis for 2027 with the dud coach as football manager and the dud coach continuing next year and with Ennis not stepping into his first ever assistant role but continuing as a dud attack consultant?

Is that right?

I need a proper team to support

Sounds like the plan, yes. Good times.

 

[madmax]

They're talking about Ennis for 2027 with the dud coach as football manager and the dud coach continuing next year and with Ennis not stepping into his first ever assistant role but continuing as a dud attack consultant?

Is that right?

I need a proper team to support

Don’t let the door hit you on your way out mate….plenty of other teams out there waiting for your support.

 

[madmax]

If you watch Fogarty closely he isn’t on the ball as much as DCE but that could also be a structure that the Raiders have in place. Usually he barks instructions directing traffic off the ball sometimes only touching the ball in a set to kick down town, where DCE receives the ball and tries to create.
For this reason this could unlock Brooks a little more as he will have more opportunities with ball in hand. Or also could go the other way and highlight how poor he can be. It’s going to be a hard swing either way.

You see how great Strange has been running the ball, just not sure if Brooks will have the same impact.

Walsh on the other hand is a different storey.

Interesting summation….nice!

 

[The Who]

They're talking about Ennis for 2027 with the dud coach as football manager and the dud coach continuing next year and with Ennis not stepping into his first ever assistant role but continuing as a dud attack consultant?

Is that right?

I need a proper team to support

Ennis is, apparently, our 'attacking' coach. Seriously? A hooker guiding how our backs play?
How has our attack gone over the past month? A 50-year low!
And what are his successes? He's been at Canberra, Parramatta, Cronulla and Manly -- four clubs in six years. At this rate he'll get paycheques from all NRL clubs before he retires.

 

[Not Paul Kent]

Conceded 30 against that rabble. Still pull the trigger please Scottie!

 

[madmax]

Conceded 30 against that rabble. Still pull the trigger please Scottie!

Yep & scored 58!!!

 

[Hertera]

Conceded 30 against that rabble. Still pull the trigger please Scottie!

Not happening

 

[CoreyWaddellSuperFan]

Don’t let the door hit you on your way out mate….plenty of other teams out there waiting for your support.

Sorry. Once more for the dills. I want my team to be a proper team again. My team that I've supported for over half a century.

Keep up, you ignorant little twat

 

[DieHardManlyFan]

Don’t let the door hit you on your way out mate….plenty of other teams out there waiting for your support.

This is the trash I personally hate to see. Show some respect to the people showing passion for our club and wanting better than what we have been dishing out for the past 10 years. I’ve been a fan for over 30 years and it’s something I’ve noticed has been happening recently. Either be part of our community and respect each other or I’ll be happier to see the door hit you on the way out.

 

[DieHardManlyFan]

Sorry. Once more for the dills. I want my team to be a proper team again. My team that I've supported for over half a century.

Keep up, you ignorant little twat

100% mate, I’m sick of seeing this behaviour being directed towards our community. Been experiencing it on multiple platforms, a true manly fan wants what’s best for the club and our supporters

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Conceded 30 against that rabble. Still pull the trigger please Scottie!

That "rabble" are the 2nd best attacking outfit in the NRL this year.

 

[Not Paul Kent]

That "rabble" are the 2nd best attacking outfit in the NRL this year.

I don’t think think any of their tries looked particularly masterful

 

[Frogz]

Yep & scored 58!!!

Yep and Dolphins now have 160 put on them over the last 3 weeks. The wheels have well and truely fallen off the Phins. You can have the best attack, but if you cant stop the points, you're stuffed.