ROBBED AS USUAL

[maxta]

If Peachey didn't touch it, how did his fingers bend backwards??

 

[mave]

How were we robbed?
walker was a 50 50.. 1 angle showed he was off the last one looked good but was only shown quickly.
uate knocked on
peachey the dud didn't touch it he just fuked up and couldn't catch it
we should of killed them but we played poorly and barley spread the ball or offloaded when we should of and we let Cleary do what he liked all night. Kelly dropped it over the line after turbo set him up. We had a good year and next year will be better of we get some more depth.. lussick stood up.. why no Lawrence until 60th and then only for 10 mins... afb was great. green was off with his kicks and Barretts plan backfired.

If you believe Walkers "try" was a 50/50, and went up as a "TRY ", then explain to me how we were not robbed when the bunker said "NO TRY".....isnt the entire charter of the bunker to have to CONCLUSIVELY FIND EVIDENCE TO CHANGE THE ONFIELD REFS DECISION.

50/50 is not conclusive evidence.

 

[desreturnoftheking]

View attachment 6587

hahaha that doesn't prove jack he missed it he's just ****house. The other angle you can see he misses it. uate knocked on 2 so

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

hahaha that doesn't prove jack he missed it he's just ****house. The other angle you can see he misses it. uate knocked on 2 so

I didn't know they made Braille keyboards

 

[castle eagle]

https://www.instagram.com/p/BY0Z5OEhDuO/?hl=en&taken-by=nrl_meemes

this says it all

 

[HoldenV8]

 

[desreturnoftheking]

If you believe Walkers "try" was a 50/50, and went up as a "TRY ", then explain to me how we were not robbed when the bunker said "NO TRY".....isnt the entire charter of the bunker to have to CONCLUSIVELY FIND EVIDENCE TO CHANGE THE ONFIELD REFS DECISION.

50/50 is not conclusive evidence.

easy he was offside that's it

 

[desreturnoftheking]

fellow manly fans we sucked and should of won with the chances we had but didn't. they got 2 garbage tries off kicks and we're lucky were we weren't . we all know the nrl wants the west to do well its no surprise two dud teams like parra and the Pennys made the 8 but end of we aren't good enough

 

[desreturnoftheking]

and didn't deserve to win we sucked the big 1

 

[desreturnoftheking]

pity they showed that angle after it was too late aye buddy. The nrl is a joke we all know this

 

[Captain Moondog]

We're sitting alone, me and the dog, i feel like punching someone, he looks at me, we share a certain simpatico. I wish Greenberg was here......

 

[mave]

easy he was offside that's it

Was he conclusively offside ???

 

[The Royal Soup]

How much $$$ does the bunker cost?

And I can do this on my phone in 30secs

 

[Spartan Eagle]

There's no way Walker was conclusively off side.
It was line ball, his right foot is the problem...............but no way it should have been overturned.

Agree. We are talking a blade of ****ing grass.!! How the **** is that supposed to be conclusive to overturn decision.??

 

[MuzztheEagle]

pity they showed that angle after it was too late aye buddy. The nrl is a joke we all know this

What other angle could they have possibly ruled on? And from that angle how could they tell when the ball actually left his foot?

 

[desreturnoftheking]

Was he conclusively offside ???

mave... Lol

 

[mave]

mave... Lol

Was he conclusively offside?
You seem to want to avoid having to answer.....

 

[yokahontas]

What other angle could they have possibly ruled on? And from that angle how could they tell when the ball actually left his foot?

And this is the issue - even with that frame frozen, and the line drawn along the grass - you still can't conclusively say where Walker's feet are in relation to the ball. You can't actually see most of the ball, only Green's boots/legs.

Therefore: inconclusive, so you go with the onfield decision!

Unlike Peachey's little performance, where you can see both the trajectory of the ball and the position of his fingers move as they make contact with each other - although that one begs the question, what was the onfield arseclown doing even sending that one up as a try in the first place?!

 

[MuzztheEagle]

It's easy to say that we should have played better and made the most of our chances but we had all the momentum when both those tries WERE scored and having them disallowed like that is always going to hit a team's moral. You can say they should have played better but you can't deny the impact of those decisions on the result.

 

[desreturnoftheking]

Was he conclusively offside?
You seem to want to avoid having to answer.....

yes there was mave. yes there was