The list of most points in a first grade season for Manly (Top 5 only)
286 - Reuben Garrick (20 tries, 103 / 128 goals (80.47%)) in 2021*
257 - Matthew Ridge (11 tries, 106 / 129 goals (82.17%), 1 field goal) in 1995
242 - Graham Eadie (14 tries, 100 goals) in 1975
242 - Jamie Lyon (16 tries, 89 / 128 goals (69.53%)) in 2013
234 - Matthew Ridge (5 tries, 106 / 132 goals (80.30%), 2 field goals) in 1994
List of most first grade points for Manly from 1947 (Top 10)
1,917 (71 tries, 847 goals, 3 field goals) - Graham Eadie (1971–1983)
1,410 (86 tries, 533 goals) - Jamie Lyon (2007–2016)
1,154 (40 tries, 501 goals, 18 field goals) - Bob Batty (1959–1971)
1,093 (32 tries, 477 goals, 11 field goals) - Matthew Ridge (1990–1996)
958 (20 tries, 447 goals, 2 field goals) - Ron Willey (1956–1962)
842 (46 tries, 352 goals) - Ron Rowles (1950–1954)
652 (163 tries) - Brett Stewart (2003–2016)
602 (151 tries, 1 goal) - Steve Menzies (1993–1999, 2003–2008)
578 (54 tries, 181 goals, 2 field goals) - Michael O'Connor (1987–1992)
578 (40 tries, 209 goals) - Reuben Garrick (2019–)*
List of most first grade goals kicked for Manly from 1947 (Top 10)
847 - Graham Eadie (1971–1983)
533 - Jamie Lyon (2007–2016)
501 - Bob Batty (1959–1971)
477 - Matthew Ridge (1990–1996)
447 - Ron Willey (1956–1962)
352 - Ron Rowles (1950–1954)
246 - Matt Orford (2006–2009)
209 - Reuben Garrick (2019–)*
181 - Michael O'Connor (1987–1992)
167 - Mal Cochrane (1983–1990)
List of most first grade tries in a season for Manly
27 - Phil Blake (1983)
23 - Kevin Junee (1974)
22 - Steve Menzies (1995), Terry Hill (1997), Brett Stewart (2008), Tom Trbojevic, Jason Saab (2021)*
21 - Bob Fulton (1976)
20 - John Ribot (1982), Steve Menzies (1996, 1998), Jorge Taufua, David Williams (2013), Reuben Garrick (2021)*