Rd 6 Manlys most improved/best player

First Grader
I think Witt played very well.....his best so far.

Kicked well in general play. good defence.
 
Journey Man
Willos best game

biggest improvement on last week - Steppa

but the award goes to

Kylie - made about 90m and was smashing them in defence again. His attack was great this game. He was making huge in roads and hitting the line heaps harder than eny other game this year.
 
First Grader
So no one rated Witts performance?
<span class='smallblacktext'>[ Edited Mon Apr 18 2005, 03:23PM ]</span>
 
UFO Hunter
Witt was good.

Most improved is Matai by streaks! He will kill it in 1st's when he has secured a permanent spot.

Best on the weekend was BK, Kite and the Beaver. 3 way tie.
 
Winging it
Witt showed a good improvement. His strengths are in defence and scramble defence and has a lot of heart. I still think his kicking game has a long way to go. He put some down Shiffy's throat and kicked to the centre of the field when the wings were a better option, and when he did kick there no one knew it was coming. Despite the negativity from me he is getting better & better.
 
Reserve Grader
I think Kite's come a long way in the past fortnight, may even reclaim his origin jumper. I thought Witt played well all year, he defends well and takes the pressure off Monaghan without trying to be too spectacular. I can live with that.
 
True Supporter
Staff member
Administrator
Premium Member
[quote author='smallblacktext'></span>[/quote]

He is going OK, I just expect a little more from a first string 5/8, especially in attack. His kicking game is too inconsistent. But having said that he is only young and definitely on the improve, just don't think he is one of our best at the moment.
 
Bencher
watching the replay just now i think he played really really well. He set up a few tries and took some pressure off Monas in attack. His defence is awesome and how does he always manage an offload?? lol

Great game from Witty.

I thought Heckenberg had his worst game (he played well just by his standard)

Fell off quite a few tackles late in the 2nd half at a crucial time. Thankfully nothing came of them. Looking forward to having Tezza back
 
Reserve Grader
Witt had a very good game , Steve Mattai gets better every week , I cant understand why Mona's didnt get 1 point in the Dally M's tho
 
First Grader
I was surprised as well I think Fly is the flavour of the month so he'll be stacking up the points. He is playing well but so is Monas and co!
 
Journey Man
Whatmough got another 3.

he leads on 11 points and is looking a chance.

Second is wesser and shiffer on 9
 
witt is hopeless.catch and pass.i was sitting in the management and ex players area and he was cursed for the whole game from go to whoa.his kicking in general play is an absolute disgrace.what games are you watching lads.
 
Bencher
most people agree he played well.. what game are YOU watching ?

I think you focus on his negatives and fail to see his positives.. I know that feeling.. i did that with Torrens.. !drunk:
 
Reserve Grader
witt is hopeless.catch and pass.i was sitting in the management and ex players area and he was cursed for the whole game from go to whoa.his kicking in general play is an absolute disgrace.what games are you watching lads.

Take it easy crackpipe, you're going to strain something.
 
First Grader
It was an improvement from his other games, to be honest though i'm not watching all moves as a critique as i'm busy taking photos.
 
Journey Man
He was much better in the first 20 mins and ran at the line a couple of times.

I havnt seen the rest of the replay yet, but he wasnt overly impressive.

Mind you, this is just game 5 with a new club after being shafted constantly by BS
 
Team P W L PD Pts
24 20 4 306 42
24 18 6 209 38
24 17 7 272 36
24 16 8 119 34
24 15 9 247 32
24 15 9 201 32
24 14 10 130 30
24 14 10 63 30
24 13 11 -36 28
24 12 12 -100 26
24 9 15 -105 20
24 7 17 -192 16
24 6 18 -205 14
24 6 18 -290 14
24 6 18 -292 14
24 4 20 -327 10
Top Bottom