MVP: Rd 18 v Souths

[mosto]

Solid win, last 20 min a bit disappointing.

3 DCE
2 Turbo
1 Koula

Also thought Simpkin was good and good early stint from Lodge.

Vote away!

 

[Buddy Love]

3. Garrick
2. Turbo
1. DCE

 

[XV-1]

DCE
KOULA
SIPS

 

[Uk eagle]

3 Tom
2 Simpkin
1 Koula

I thought DCE was dreadful so I may have to watch again to see what others are seeing

 

[manlyfan76]

Gee Sipley played a good game.

3 turbo
2 sips
1 chez

 

[bob dylan]

3 Tom
2 Simpkin
1 Koula

I thought DCE was dreadful so I may have to watch again to see what others are seeing

He was dreadful in the 2nd half and not much better in the first.

 

[bob dylan]

3 Garrick - I dont like giving wingers top votes but Rubes was strong all game.
2 Sipley - best game for club.
1 Jake - Stunning defence, just cracking.

TKO, Lodge, Simpkin, Waddell and Burbo all good in the forwards.

Tom - I am feeling good about about him. Wouldnt it be great if he played 12 more games for us this season.

 

[Highflier]

3 Turbo
2 Simpkin (we look quicker in the middle as soon as he is on)
1 Waddell (did his job ,no errors that I can recall)

Honorable mention Sieu,Koula ,Garrick,JAzz and DCE 1st 40 mins ,also Brooks D was good and went to the line

 

[davohan123]

3. Koula
2 Simpkin
1 Turbo

 

[Carl]

Sipley
Bully
Koula

 

[TWO DOGS]

3) Jake T
2) Turbo
1) Lodge

 

[Fred]

3 Garrick back where he belongs
2 Sips looked pretty good
1 Turbo for looking more interested today

 

[bigd1972]

3. Koula
2. Simpkin
1. Turbo

Sipley , TKO layed a good platform and just miss points

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

3 Jake (but sub him out quicker for a rest!) top game though
2 tom - but defence is shown up a bit in the centre. Good luck against that Storm bloke with the floppy hair-style. Run harder! (but still a key player) 🙂
1 Garrick- if he wants to be a centre he is screwing himself by playing so well on the wing! (would have got an extra point if his goalkicking was better) 🙂

Not sure about honourable but ... danger mention: Koula probably our most dangerous player now - give him the bloody ball more often in better spots and Manly can still win this crazy comp)

 

[madmax]

Garrick
Koula
Turbo

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

3. Turbo
2. Simpkin
1. Koula

Again though, Lodge and TKO were good first up, and Sipley had his best stint in a long time.

 

[JakeyB789]

3 Tom
2 Simpkin
1 Koula

I thought DCE was dreadful so I may have to watch again to see what others are seeing

Story of his career. Getting praise in a win regardless of whether he plays well or not, I guess a try assist or two makes up for the 20 other **** ups he usually has during games.

3 - Koula - our actual best and most consistent player this year
2 - Simpkin - nothing outstanding but the only Manly hooker in the last 5 years to run the ball when needed and not throw hospital balls
1 - Garrick - a winger playing well on the wing

 

[Fibro Eagle]

Koula
Garrick
Simpkin

 

[HoldenV8]

3 - TKO
2 - Jake the 1st
1 - Lodge

I know it was only Souths who aren't exactly flying high, but our forwards today gave the backs room to move.

 

[Jay Eagle]

Solid team effort for me..without anyone being outstanding
1- Tom
1- Lodge
1- Garrick
1- Sipley
1- Jake
1- Simpkins

Not enough points to go around for me
Brookes and SKO deserve a point also