Mestrov & Penn vs DCE: Who is lying?

Who is lying?

  • DCE

    Votes: 74 67.9%
  • Mestrov & Penn

    Votes: 9 8.3%
  • Both

    Votes: 26 23.9%

  • Total voters
    109
I prefer it'd be something positive giving we're playing the eels and we still have a comp to win....

But I believe it'll be booing initially - with D$E signs in the crowd.
 
There will be boos. But knowing DCE, he will put in a match-winning performance, if anything just to spite. This will most likely continue until Origin, and then there will be an almighty crash in his commitment to the team
 
Booing .....
Booing the Manly captain is Great for Manly team Morale
The Eels players will be enjoying DCE getting more Boos than them
Another smart Initiative by our Club Leaders
They planned this big match day celebration to perfection
 
Booing the Manly captain is Great for Manly team Morale
The Eels players will be enjoying DCE getting more Boos than them
Another smart Initiative by our Club Leaders
They planned this big match day celebration to perfection
Dumping the club you're captain of and played your whole career for like this is also great for team morale..... He's an absolute wanker.
 
Dumping the club you're captain of and played your whole career for like this is also great for team morale..... He's an absolute wanker.
I am sorry for you and for so many divided Manly people that feel anger for DCE and for our Clubs Decisionmakers feathered friend .

Who Dumbed who ?
The Elite player wanted to stay at his Elite Market Value asking price
The CEO Disregarded DCE's Market Value Price and wanted to Down grade him which is another way of saying I am not prepared to give you what you are worth .
Which was an Insult to the Manly captain
 
Last edited:
So what will the reception be like for DCE on Sunday??? Booing, respect or polite applause
Hard to say, probably a bit of both - I'm torn myself.
Hopefully he will give his all for the rest of the season, still an opportunity to have his first and last seasons as a Mighty Sea Eagle as a premiership winner and this time as captain, if so he will be cheered.
However if he drops his full effort for us and plays poorly (I doubt he will), he will get booed and rightly so.
 
However if he drops his full effort for us and plays poorly (I doubt he will), he will get booed and rightly so.
We all saw his form on the weekend when he orchestrated the Manly win like Elite halves do
He had already known his fate from the Manly Decision makers prior to that game
Nothing will change the Elite players Professionalism
DCE is an Elite Class on and off the field and would be an asset to any club that is prepared to accept his Value
To the Manly Ceo
You pay peanuts and you get Monkeys
The Highly Decorated DCE is no Mug or Monkey and does not accept any one to treat him that way
 
DCE will always chase the money and loves the spotlight. Never seen a player go about it like this Reynolds could have done this too with south’s but he didn’t. This has totally turned me off going to the game this week vs Eels I wouldn’t be able to control myself when he got the ball he deserves to be heckled by the crowd. To turns down the 2 year offer live on air too is a disgrace real kick in the guts !!!!
 
Im very confused by 'we wont make an offer unless another club does'. Can anyone explain how that makes an ounce of sense.
to me that sounds like your'e old its a risk , we dont want to give you an offer so you can go shop it, see what offers are available, and we will counter offer and make sure we are looking after you. thats the way I see it. But we aren't a club in a position to do this because if someone like the dogs, roosters or Brisbane are keen , we will never be able to match their 3rd party deals
 
Im very confused by 'we wont make an offer unless another club does'. Can anyone explain how that makes an ounce of sense.
No…

I suspect it had to do with the 1 year vs 2 year argument though as that came out before the jump ship…

Maybe….
Chez: I want 2yrs
Club: We will give you 1 + 1 (in our favour)
Chez: I will go to market
Club: Let us know how that works out for you and we can talk then
———Radio silence——-
(insert media rumours)
Chez: Hello? Channel 9? Would you like an exclusive?
 
On the surface, it seemed to me that Manly had made an absolute mess of this situation.

Just watched the 100% interview and I'm not so sure now it was a complete stuff up by the club.

Lots of fumbling from DCE including contradictions of his own words from only moments before and of course the obvious stuttering when attempting to make his point. He also seemed very nervous and he never shows nerves in interviews.

I don't believe there is much point going into who said what. Body language to me is a very large indicator of the situation. So yeah, I have strong doubts now about the story DCE is attempting to put forward.

Plenty of media over the last week were indicating that they couldn't see him leaving a club where he could complete his NRL career with one of the greatest legacies. Clubs have also come out today saying they haven't bothered as the believed the same thing. They were all wrong it seems!

Never thought I would say this but maybe Choc was right?
 
Last edited:
The Sea Eagles announced late on Monday night that CEO Tony Mestrov would address the media on Tuesday about Cherry-Evans' decision


This will be interesting. Will this be Mestrov and Manly trying to cover their useless arses or throwing out an olive branch.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
2 2 0 44 6
3 3 0 32 6
3 2 1 38 4
3 2 1 36 4
3 2 1 36 4
3 2 1 33 4
3 2 1 6 4
2 1 1 4 4
3 2 1 4 4
3 2 1 -4 4
3 2 1 -12 4
3 1 2 -6 2
2 0 2 -9 2
3 1 2 -38 2
3 0 3 -28 0
3 0 3 -64 0
3 0 3 -72 0
Back
Top Bottom