Pre-Game Panthers V Manly [Round 8, 2025]

Kick Off In:
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds

V

0 0
CommBank Stadium

26 Apr 2025 07:35 PM


Team Lists


Might be a good opportunity to see Simpkin for 80min and Tevaga as lock/prop where he belongs. If Bullemor and Aloiai both play, and play well, then the pack might still resemble a first grade side

08 Aloiai
09 Simpkin
10 Taukeiaho
11 Ola'akautu
12 Trbojevic
13 Tevaga / Brown
14 Brown / Tevaga
15 Waddell
16 Bullemor
17 Navale

A win is virtually impossible, but we just need to see some character and pride in the jersey. I couldn't care less if we don't score a point. But if another 40-50 points get past our line then we all know where 2025 goes
Didn "t watch the match but after noticing the outcome in the Strom - Dolphins game , and the dramatic turnaround in the Dolphins favor , would think anything is possible in terms of a side "s ability to turn things around if a side is up to it
And even with a couple out , Manly should still have the personal to fit into this category and if they are up for it
 
Like Mestrov milking a cow or Penn shearing a sheep the relevance of an image or inspirational quote to a footy forum doesn't matter. Words and more of the same words repeated over and over ad infinitum is what matters because what is a a fan forum without meaningless words. It is like a cow without milk or a sheep without wool? When we get that milk we all live in hope that the milk will be fresh and not past the expiry date and that the milk will live up to the legendary standards of past milk and if the milk is not fresh we will sack the dairy farmer and not the shop keeper who let the milk go bad. However, when the milk is fresh we will all celebrate the dairy farmer with a cold glass of milk at the end of long day and that is the message of the day my feathered friend.

View attachment 29971
Ewe rule, @Wombat64 !!
 
As long as the side can regroup and rally sufficiently and Aloiai and Bully are ideally match fit , might be within range of being quite competitive against the Panthers and some chance .
Again with the prospect T K O and Aloiai starting props and Bully , Jake and Brown to complement the rotation .
But looks like Jass is on stand by as a prop option so maybe not looking that good with all of the other options being available .
Sure that Navale will really make an effort but would think at least also two of Bully , Aloiai or Brown being available as well to consolidate the pack better .
Surely the backs can offer something worthwhile with or without Turbo and again be a bit more fluent in attack or the attacking plays a bit better co ordinated all round .
Tend to think or must be a bit obvious now that D C E is being affected with some injury niggle , no excuse for some wayward play the other night but the whole attacking structure was totally off in the i st half .
Not sure if they can definitely turn thigs around sufficiently this week to give themselves a chance and very disappointing form wise recently of course but that type of a year again for most sides with consistency and fluctuating form and no time like the present for Manly to bounce back again
If DCE is not injured and he's just playing below par, surely ego alone would lift him against Cleary.

We'll see.
 
Might be a good opportunity to see Simpkin for 80min and Tevaga as lock/prop where he belongs. If Bullemor and Aloiai both play, and play well, then the pack might still resemble a first grade side

08 Aloiai
09 Simpkin
10 Taukeiaho
11 Ola'akautu
12 Trbojevic
13 Tevaga / Brown
14 Brown / Tevaga
15 Waddell
16 Bullemor
17 Navale

A win is virtually impossible, but we just need to see some character and pride in the jersey. I couldn't care less if we don't score a point. But if another 40-50 points get past our line then we all know where 2025 goes
This may not go down well but I actually think Jazz at 13 may be an upgrade to Jake. And also that one Panthers win does not make a season. They have been bog average this year and a win over a pretty ordinary Easts side doesn't mean their season has automatically turned around. I don’t think we will win with all our outs but if Turbo is back and our pack can somewhat resemble that list, we might be a show. But agree with the point in that they just need to turn up and have a dig. I can accept a loss if they at least have a crack. And we’ve also had a good break so should be fresh.
 
This may not go down well but I actually think Jazz at 13 may be an upgrade to Jake. And also that one Panthers win does not make a season. They have been bog average this year and a win over a pretty ordinary Easts side doesn't mean their season has automatically turned around. I don’t think we will win with all our outs but if Turbo is back and our pack can somewhat resemble that list, we might be a show. But agree with the point in that they just need to turn up and have a dig. I can accept a loss if they at least have a crack. And we’ve also had a good break so should be fresh.
I agree that Jake’s best spot is no longer 13. He should be in the front row rotation. Jazz has a decent passing game (as evidenced by his reasonable ability at dummy half) and so should be able to work in at 13. I do think Jakey will be missed though this week in defence.
 
The two games Penrith have won this year, Mitch Kenny has been their starting hooker and has finished the game.

Their 5 losses, he only played half a game back in Round 2, missed the rest...

Manly at $3.06 to win is juicy, especially with Turbo back
 
Manly at $3.06 to win is juicy, especially with Turbo back
There are no 100% Guarantees in life
Every thing is Possible
It is not what we have
It is what we do with what we have

The Moral of the Story
Get Rid of the Excuses
and Get the Most of what You Got
1745295066493.webp
 

Manly facing prop crisis​


Penrith’s next opponents have problems of their own, namely a mounting injury toll that has added gravitas to Manly coach Anthony Seibold’s claims that a gruelling fixture list has pushed his players to their physical limits.

The Sea Eagles, who were flying high in second spot on the points table after winning three of their first four games, have nosedived to 12th after consecutive losses against Melbourne (48-24), Cronulla (24-18) and St George Illawarra (20-18).

The mini-slump has coincided with Manly having to play five games in 25 days - the last three of which came in an 11-day block that included travelling to and from Perth.

That prompted Seibold to speak out after Thursday’s loss to the Dragons at Brookvale.

The coach now faces the challenge of selecting a patched-up team for Saturday’s clash at Commbank Stadium with the revitalised four-time champions.
In particular, the Sea Eagles are pondering what would appear to be an engine-room crisis.

Towering Taniela Paseka is unlikely to play again this season after rupturing his Achilles playing against Canberra last month.

Toafofoa Sipley was referred straight to the judiciary for a hip-drop tackle against the Dragons and is facing a likely long-term suspension.

Jake Trbojevic suffered a grade-one concussion on Thursday and will miss the clash with Penrith.

In addition, Nathan Brown (shoulder) and Ethan Bullemore (knee) were both injured against the Dragons and are racing the clock to prove their fitness.

“They’ll need to be monitored and won’t train, if available, until the back end of the week,” Seibold said of Brown and Bullemore.

“They both couldn’t finish Thursday’s game so are in doubt.”

Meanwhile, veteran Matt Lodge, who is on a train-and-trial contract that allows him to play in the NRL in round 10, suffered a toe injury recently that has hindered his preparations.

Winger Tommy Talau is also in doubt this week with a lower-leg problem.

Desperately needing some reinforcements to bolster his pack, Seibold is hoping Josh Ailoai, who has missed two of the past three games with a shoulder injury, will be available this week, while Corey Waddell will return from suspension.

He is also optimistic that talismanic Tom Trbojevic is “a good chance” to return from a knee injury that has sidelined him for three games.

Manly have lost all three of those games, adding to their cursed record minus “Tommy Turbo”. Of the 50 games he has missed since 2021, they have won only 16.

Seibold admitted the Sea Eagles are “a bit beaten up at the minute” and told this masthead that the playing schedule had hindered Manly’s selection options.

“The short turnaround after Perth prevented Josh Aloiai from playing,” he said.

“Over this period we have had Tom Trbojevic, Tommy Talau, Jason Saab and Josh Aloiai miss games due to the playing schedule / short turnaround that on normal turnarounds would have been available.”
 
Relax apparently a few named are in doubt so you may yet get your wish.
Quite a few were pushing the idea of Talau as a bench player recently so they should be happy at least. 🤷‍♂️
Yes, I'd be shocked if all 3 players that were replaced on Thursday, actually played Saturday.

I'm not even convinced that Navale will add that much to the team (even though I do think he's been going ok in the games I've seen him play in reserves) but he at least needs a go given how slow our pack is.
 
If Brown and Bully don't end up making the cut due to their injuries we really WILL be seeing a whole new team - one that many on here keep saying they want to see. Let’s see how that goes if it eventuates. I’m not so sure it’ll be that great.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 6 6 0 0 98 14
2 Storm 6 4 0 2 70 10
3 Raiders 7 5 0 2 46 10
4 Warriors 6 4 0 2 -18 10
5 Broncos 7 4 0 3 54 8
6 Sharks 7 4 0 3 41 8
7 Dragons 6 3 0 3 20 8
8 Rabbitohs 7 4 0 3 -36 8
9 Cowboys 6 3 0 3 -42 8
10 Dolphins 7 3 0 4 28 6
11 Sea Eagles 7 3 0 4 20 6
12 Tigers 7 3 0 4 12 6
13 Titans 6 2 0 4 -36 6
14 Knights 6 2 0 4 -60 6
15 Panthers 7 2 0 5 -10 4
16 Roosters 7 2 0 5 -80 4
17 Eels 7 2 0 5 -107 4
Back
Top Bottom