Origin 1 - 2024

Who will win?

  • NSW

    Votes: 9 42.9%
  • QLD

    Votes: 9 42.9%
  • Don’t care…

    Votes: 3 14.3%

  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .
Good riddance to him... shouldn't have been picked in the first place
I don’t agree. I think he’s deserved a start. It was a poor tackle. He got down low but not low enough. Walsh slipped into it as well. I think it deserved 10 not a send off. A send off has basically ruined this game and probably the series. QLD win this game and that’s basically series over.
 
View attachment 27237

I think that is a good edit to his wiki
Well he definitely ruined this one..

Rules

Mitigating factors include;

Tackler clearly bent at the waist and/or knees to make contact with ball Carrier legally and ball carrier unexpectedly and rapidly loses height (where deliberate, penalty may be reversed), and the tackler is unable to adjust.

A spectacle ruined without any deliberation to reflect on what happened.. 🤡 🤡
 
I don’t agree. I think he’s deserved a start. It was a poor tackle. He got down low but not low enough. Walsh slipped into it as well. I think it deserved 10 not a send off. A send off has basically ruined this game and probably the series. QLD win this game and that’s basically series over.
Well, it's Melb next, even tho they go for Qld down there.
 
Give him a chance champ, he's only just come on.
I’ve said it all along. I don’t think he’s up to origin pace. Hope I’m wrong and he goes nuts in the second half but doubt it will happen sadly. Hope he doesn’t lose confidence from this.
 
I thought it was a good tackle, Walsh slipped into it, no way a send off, possible penalty at best, ref didn’t pull it up in the run, wasn’t until the Qld’s started carrying on that the bunker called the ref, bloody shame, series rooted.
 
I thought it was a good tackle, Walsh slipped into it, no way a send off, possible penalty at best, ref didn’t pull it up in the run, wasn’t until the Qld’s started carrying on that the bunker called the ref, bloody shame, series rooted.
I thought Fatty summed it up very well, got to feel for Walsh with the category 1, though the crowd that turned up and paid to watch a contest would feel robbed..
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 21 17 0 4 168 40
2 Storm 21 16 0 5 252 38
3 Bulldogs 21 15 0 6 120 36
4 Warriors 21 13 0 8 12 32
5 Panthers 21 12 1 8 115 31
6 Broncos 21 12 0 9 114 30
7 Sharks 22 13 0 9 67 30
8 Roosters 21 11 0 10 92 28
9 Dolphins 21 10 0 11 109 26
10 Sea Eagles 21 9 0 12 -24 24
11 Tigers 21 9 0 12 -107 24
12 Dragons 21 8 0 13 -54 22
13 Cowboys 22 8 1 13 -144 21
14 Eels 21 7 0 14 -156 20
15 Rabbitohs 22 8 0 14 -191 20
16 Knights 21 6 0 15 -186 18
17 Titans 21 5 0 16 -187 16
Back
Top Bottom