Kasiano cleared to play
- Thread starter Eagles2nv
- Start date
Jatz Crackers
First Grader
Daniel said:
We have a rule that the judiciary sometimes follows and other times doesnt follow.
That rule should be held to carry more weight than an interpretation of what the intent of the person was. Right or wrong in this instance matters not. Past incidents have attracted a penalty. This one should have aswell.
well it should open a whole new range of biomechanic experts at the judiciary.
Whilst understanding the 'arm can't vanish' argument, at what point does the judiciary agree are acceptable time frames v distance?
Is it 50cm in 0.4 seconds as was this case, 60 in 0.8? What about reflex tests? A halfback has quicker reflex's than a forward usually.
etc
etc
Sometimes it's better to go, listen, it may have been an accident but have a week on the sideline.
Whilst understanding the 'arm can't vanish' argument, at what point does the judiciary agree are acceptable time frames v distance?
Is it 50cm in 0.4 seconds as was this case, 60 in 0.8? What about reflex tests? A halfback has quicker reflex's than a forward usually.
etc
etc
Sometimes it's better to go, listen, it may have been an accident but have a week on the sideline.
Fluffy
Journey Man
Kite got rubbed for a week or 2 in 09 or 10 for the same thing, hitting a guy on the head who fell into it, didnt break his jaw though.
What else was T-rex supposed to do when he got rubbed for 7 weeks? No intent, less chance to change things and result on player a lot less.
Manly loading goes both ways
What else was T-rex supposed to do when he got rubbed for 7 weeks? No intent, less chance to change things and result on player a lot less.
Manly loading goes both ways
Utility Player
Bencher
ThatKiwi Eagle said:
mosto
I have a well known member
I initially thought the penalty was sufficient, but thought I should look at it as the judiciary would. I think the contact was accidental and the 2 grading was a bit harsh. That being said, any contact with the head is usually punished. A grade 1 careless high tackle would have been adequate, which is 75 points and not a suspension on it's own. However, I believe he has 45 carry over points, which takes him to 120 points and a one week suspension.
I think this would probably have been a fair result. No suspension on it's own, but given carry over points, he should have got a week.
I think this would probably have been a fair result. No suspension on it's own, but given carry over points, he should have got a week.
I'm glad he'll be playing. I think he offers some problems for them in and around the ruck. His defense isn't terribly good and he's not that mobile. That said, he runs the blocking play for defenders when they attack the line along with Pritchard. Hopefully the idiots in pink will see that illegal play, though I doubt it. The real problem for us is those same two in the middle.
That, and Ennis's forward passes off the ruck. They are so obvious, though rarely penalized.
That, and Ennis's forward passes off the ruck. They are so obvious, though rarely penalized.
Their set move of the double wrap around or the block for Barba is so obvious when they start setting up for it. Off of a scrum they start setting up for it usually from the second play and run it on the 3rd tackle.
They take two runs to the right to get themselves to the right of the uprights and then they run the blockers towards the post.
It may be hard to defend but usually Pritchard and Kasiano moving into a wider position is the dead give away.
If we look for it we should defend it well. We need to bring players in from the left edge to defend, freeing up man on man defense to our left with a possible extra.
Wolfman needs to stay out on his wing and Lyon needs to come up to meet Morris whilst the inside defenders keep an eye out for Barba trying to go himself with Lyon moving up
They take two runs to the right to get themselves to the right of the uprights and then they run the blockers towards the post.
It may be hard to defend but usually Pritchard and Kasiano moving into a wider position is the dead give away.
If we look for it we should defend it well. We need to bring players in from the left edge to defend, freeing up man on man defense to our left with a possible extra.
Wolfman needs to stay out on his wing and Lyon needs to come up to meet Morris whilst the inside defenders keep an eye out for Barba trying to go himself with Lyon moving up
ManlyBacker
Winging it
Daniel said:
Agree Wolfie has to stay out on the wing - Lyon reads plays so well. And on the other side it applies even more to Jorge. At least we have Matai back - if Buhrer was out there again it could be over. No Glenn (probably) for the clean up work up the middle is the other worry.
Stevo said:
Moi Moi's head was at about thigh height when contact was made. a 100+ kg bloke falls hard and fast, and a big bloke cant move his arm that fast.
Saying that he should have been rubbed out because a guy was knocked out is weak. What if he fell into Kasiano's knee, same result, should he be suspended?
pffft, an arm moves faster and in more directions than a knee.
becoming a bit straw man there.
becoming a bit straw man there.
the mauler
Bencher
JMG said:
He wouldnt be playing Friday night that's for sure.
Users who are viewing this thread
| Team | P | W | L | PD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 38 | 4 |
|
2 | 2 | 0 | 16 | 4 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 36 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 22 | 2 |
|
2 | 1 | 1 | 10 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 8 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
|
2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
|
2 | 1 | 1 | -2 | 2 |
|
2 | 1 | 1 | -30 | 2 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -2 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -6 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -8 | 0 |
|
2 | 0 | 2 | -16 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -30 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -38 | 0 |