I think its a fair result. Look at how many times Queensland lifted us in tackles last night but because there was no Beau Scott type interaction it goes un penalised because there's no rotation. It's a difficult conundrum, do you punish the action or the outcome of the action. Most of these lifting tackles that end up ugly are due to the other 1 or 2 tacklers who rotate the player, not so much the player doing the lifting. Reynolds is a bit of a grub but I don't think there was any intent in that tackle on Tate, just a good up and under tackle that got ugly because of Beau Scott's efforts.
