Josh Aloiai

I agree, I feel for him because he seems to have some mental health issues, but even once he’s overcome them I don’t think he’s ever going to become a regular first grader anywhere.

It’s shame but I think it’s the reality.
The Reality is that Recovery is Real
Crichton at the Roosters was struggling with mental health issues and he is now playing in the best form of his career
The reality is that this can apply to the shu

Crichton received treatment in mental health facilities as he experienced different stages of mania. Manic syndrome is a symptom of bipolar disorder and is marked by feelings of euphoria, hyperactivity, risk-taking, delusions, fixations and sleeplessness
 
The Reality is that Recovery is Real
Crichton at the Roosters was struggling with mental health issues and he is now playing in the best form of his career
The reality is that this can apply to the shu

Crichton received treatment in mental health facilities as he experienced different stages of mania. Manic syndrome is a symptom of bipolar disorder and is marked by feelings of euphoria, hyperactivity, risk-taking, delusions, fixations and sleeplessness
Bipolar is only one type of mental illness. The reality is MOST people that have significant mental illness lack the drive to do the hard work necessary to succeed. Most mental health programs focus on ‘surviving’ rather than ‘striving’ As they say one step at a time.

I wish Schuster the best! I hope he surrounds himself with caring people.

Just sayin’
 
Sadly he's "genetics" will always be a problem.. no matter how hard he trains he is always only a minor injury away or even a few weeks holiday time away from ballooning out..
Aside from the personal issues which have been alluded to but not disclosed (which is fine of course) I don't think his genetics make him any bigger than a guy like Toff Sipley.

The difference is Toff has different expectations and knows he must knuckle down to build a footy career.

If Schu ever embraced the idea of being a tough front rower with skills like Artie Beetson he would surely prosper, but there's zero evidence so far that he's interested in that tough road.

I don't blame him really, he's got heaps of money for a guy his age, and his whole life ahead, I wish him well but don't expect to see him in NRL.
 

80,000km, $15,000 in fuel and 1350 hours behind the wheel: Aloiai’s drive to survive​

By Christian Nicolussi, Dan Walsh and Billie Eder

Updated July 9, 2024 — 2.43pmfirst published July 7, 2024 — 11.39am
Save


Josh Aloiai jokes that now he has a fresh contract extension with Manly, he might have to invest in a chauffeur.​

The Sea Eagles front-rower signed a two-year extension during the week that will keep him on the northern beaches until the end of 2027. But the new deal also means a lot more hours commuting from his Campbelltown home to Brookvale and back, up to five days a week.

Despite being at Manly for four seasons, Aloiai has resisted moving his family from south-western Sydney. Aloiai is behind the wheel of his Kia Sorrento by 5.30am most days, driving along the M5 Motorway, the M7, the M2, then on to Military Road and The Spit before being one of the first to training. It equates to about 900km a week, or 3800km a month.

An extra two years works out to be roughly 1350 hours of driving for 80,000km, $15,000 in fuel and $22,000 in tolls, before rebates. Before the NSW Government scheme to cap tolls each week, Aloiai was paying north of $400 a week.

“I’m yet to be late, not once,” he said. “I’m paranoid about it, which is why I’m on the road by 5.30am each day. Any later and I’ll hit traffic. Even if we start a bit later, I’ll get in early and do some prep work.

“Thankfully the tolls are now capped at $60 a week. Before that, I was paying between $1700 or $1800 a month. If I was doing a promo for the club, the tolls were tax deductible. But you can’t claim them when driving to and from work. I’ve got a diesel now, so I don’t have to fill up as often. I still wish I had a fuel card.”

Aloiai can spend up to two hours driving one way, and passes the time calling relatives in New Zealand, listening to podcasts – Joe Rogan and ex-Navy Seal Shawn Ryan are two he regularly listens to – while he relies on Sea Eagles teammates to provide him with new playlists.

Josh Aloiai behind the wheel.

Josh Aloiai behind the wheel.

“There is a lot of old-school R&B and hip-hop,” Aloiai said. “All the boys joke about me driving from Wollongong each day. It’s not that far, but it’s far.

“I’ve never wanted to leave Campbelltown. I have two sons, Uriah and Eli, and all their cousins and aunties and uncles live out west. I want them around family. I’m happy to suck up the drive.”
The only work hazard for Aloiai when having to spend so much time on the road is keeping a clean driving record.

When you ask him how many demerit points he has, Aloiai giggles and says: “That’s a strange question. I am on very thin ice with the demerits. In fact, good behaviour next week.”

Aloiai has been solid for the Sea Eagles who host Newcastle at what will be a packed 4 Pines Park on Sunday afternoon. Jake Trbojevic and Daly Cherry-Evans are missing because of Origin duty, with Tom Trbojevic to captain Manly and Haumole Olakau’atu a surprise inclusion after being overlooked by the Blues for game three.

Aloiai was glad the new contract provided job security, and said there was a lot of confidence within the club about how far Manly can push this season.
Manly prop Josh Aloiai has been in solid form this season.

Manly prop Josh Aloiai has been in solid form this season. CREDIT:GETTY

“I’ve got so many good relationships at the club, including ‘Seebs’ [coach Anthony Siebold], and assistants Steven Hales and Jim Dymock – all three of those guys I have a ton of respect for,” Aloiai said. “I’ve got that security now, and knowing I get to keep playing for people I want to play for, and play next to, it’s great and all worth it.

“We’ve spoken about our next three games until we have another bye. So these next few games are almost worth double points. They are so crucial. We need to break away from that cluster.”

Olakau’atu featured for NSW in the opening two Origins, and while disappointed to not feature in the decider, said he could understand why Michael Maguire opted for New Zealand Warriors forward Mitch Barnett. Barnett is more capable of playing in the middle and on an edge, while Olakau’atu is an out-and-out backrower. “Obviously I was a bit disappointed, but once ‘Madge’ [Maguire] broke it down, I fully understood what he was talking about,” Olakau’atu said. “For me personally, it’s hard to put a second-rower into a game when you’ve got second-rowers killing it. But I don’t blame Madge. And I’m happy for Mitch Barnett.”
 
Memo Josh:

Why on earth would you not exit the M2 at the A3 exit, then head for the Northern Beaches via St Ives, rather than pay additional tolls in the LCT and then the Falcon St Gateway exit, off the Warringah Expressway?

Alternatively, a more direct route would be via the M5 all the way to the airport and beyond?

Regards,

Uncle Terry (Moody) Zarsoff
 
Memo Josh:

Why on earth would you not exit the M2 at the A3 exit, then head for the Northern Beaches via St Ives, rather than pay additional tolls in the LCT and then the Falcon St Gateway exit, off the Warringah Expressway?

Alternatively, a more direct route would be via the M5 all the way to the airport and beyond?

Regards,

Uncle Terry (Moody) Zarsoff
For a guy who knows his travel tax deduction rules pretty well it seems Josh’s navigation skills are somewhat lacking.
 
Josh in 2024 perfectly personifies Manly’s forward pack. This guy has the zero consistency in effort , week in week out.
Last night he was poor,after playing well for a couple of weeks.

2 good weeks
1 poor week
2 good weeks
2 poor weeks
1 good week
3 poor weeks

Outside of Guac and Jake, all our forwards are like individual yoyos , never operating as a " forward " pack.

Consistency of effort is non existent. This is what Penrith and Melbourne do so well. Consistency in performance.

All our forwards outside of BenT are experienced.

What is Spoony going to do coaching wise to have our forwards provide consistency in performance?
 
Josh in 2024 perfectly personifies Manly’s forward pack. This guy has the zero consistency in effort , week in week out.
Last night he was poor,after playing well for a couple of weeks.

2 good weeks
1 poor week
2 good weeks
2 poor weeks
1 good week
3 poor weeks

Outside of Guac and Jake, all our forwards are like individual yoyos , never operating as a " forward " pack.

Consistency of effort is non existent. This is what Penrith and Melbourne do so well. Consistency in performance.

All our forwards outside of BenT are experienced.

What is Spoony going to do coaching wise to have our forwards provide consistency in performance?
Boy, i miss the days of Gifty and co hunting like a pack in defence. We were relentless in those days.
 
Josh in 2024 perfectly personifies Manly’s forward pack. This guy has the zero consistency in effort , week in week out.
Last night he was poor,after playing well for a couple of weeks.

2 good weeks
1 poor week
2 good weeks
2 poor weeks
1 good week
3 poor weeks

Outside of Guac and Jake, all our forwards are like individual yoyos , never operating as a " forward " pack.

Consistency of effort is non existent. This is what Penrith and Melbourne do so well. Consistency in performance.

All our forwards outside of BenT are experienced.

What is Spoony going to do coaching wise to have our forwards provide consistency in performance?

Whats Josh Aloiai going to do about it as well to improve his consistency?

He's an experienced player as you say. Its not only on the coach.
 
Josh in 2024 perfectly personifies Manly’s forward pack. This guy has the zero consistency in effort , week in week out.
Last night he was poor,after playing well for a couple of weeks.

2 good weeks
1 poor week
2 good weeks
2 poor weeks
1 good week
3 poor weeks

Outside of Guac and Jake, all our forwards are like individual yoyos , never operating as a " forward " pack.

Consistency of effort is non existent. This is what Penrith and Melbourne do so well. Consistency in performance.

All our forwards outside of BenT are experienced.

What is Spoony going to do coaching wise to have our forwards provide consistency in performance?
Fix this, bring in Simpkin and move Garrick back to wing and we are a top 4 team in 2025.

Mr Penn, these changes also shouldn’t cost you an extra cent! Simples!
 
Whats Josh Aloiai going to do about it as well to improve his consistency?

He's an experienced player as you say. Its not only on the coach.

Totally agree, but it's up to the coach to hold THEM ALL accountable for their performances and provide a structure in D and attack in very simple terms that they can follow.

Not to say he is proud of them all,win, lose or draw.
 
Totally agree, but it's up to the coach to hold THEM ALL accountable for their performances and provide a structure in D and attack in very simple terms that they can follow.

Not to say he is proud of them all,win, lose or draw.
I don't disagree with any of that. What i would say, is I think Aloiai is past it and in games like yesterday just isn't good enough, no matter what the coach does.
 
I don't disagree with any of that. What i would say, is I think Aloiai is past it and in games like yesterday just isn't good enough, no matter what the coach does.

You could day the same thing about Tent, Brown, Lodge, Waddell, Sipley.
They are all experienced enough to have better consistency in performance.
 
You could day the same thing about Tent, Brown, Lodge, Waddell, Sipley.
They are all experienced enough to have better consistency in performance.
My view is that they are all trying - they just aren't good enough when we are talking about playing the best teams. And all too similar players i.e slow, big and old. Not to say there isn't talent there of course.
 
You could day the same thing about Tent, Brown, Lodge, Waddell, Sipley.
They are all experienced enough to have better consistency in performance.
Just my opinion but I don't think they lack consistency, as much as they aren't good enough. By consistency I mean desire and intent to play a strong game.

The weeks that they play well are when the opposition let them, not when they decide to 'turn up'. I believe the Sharks and Roosters games are classic examples of the team starting with intent and losing the fight.

Our middles are trying and have occasional strong games when they play opposition that are either inferior or lacklustre on the day but if both packs turn up, we're done because we just aren't that good.
 
My view is that they are all trying - they just aren't good enough when we are talking about playing the best teams. And all too similar players i.e slow, big and old. Not to say there isn't talent there of course.

Just my opinion but I don't think they lack consistency, as much as they aren't good enough. By consistency I mean desire and intent to play a strong game.

The weeks that they play well are when the opposition let them, not when they decide to 'turn up'. I believe the Sharks and Roosters games are classic examples of the team starting with intent and losing the fight.

Our middles are trying and have occasional strong games when they play opposition that are either inferior or lacklustre on the day but if both packs turn up, we're done because we just aren't that good.

Even more reason Seibold needs to come up with simple systems to help the forwards become a true forward pack.

This guy studied under Bellamy for quite a few years, but learnt nothing about forward play and systems to make each forward accountable.

Bellamy has similar forwards to us, but gets a better more coherent consistent performance week n week out than Seibold does.

Easier said than done, I know.
 
Last edited:
He’s useless. At least with Paseka, Lodge, Bully, Brown, even Sipley they’ve all had games where they’ve been best, or at least close to best on ground. I don’t think that could be said about Aloiai and he’s just finished his 4th season here.

At his best he’s a serviceable 3rd or 4th best prop for a good team, at his worst he goes MIA against better sides and/or comes up with costly penalties and errors. And that’s not even taking into account time missed due to injuries or suspension, or some of the questionable comments that have come from his mouth (not saying he’s not entitled to that, but would prefer it’s matched with decent play on the field too)

Re-signing him until 2027 was one of the more moronic decisions by the club in recent years, and there’s a fair bit of competition in that regard
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
Back
Top Bottom