Josh Aloiai 10 min Sin Bin

[##fanboy88]

Can someone explain why he was sin binned ? A penalty maybe but 10 mins ?

 

[The Wheel]

Can someone explain why he was sin binned ? A penalty maybe but 10 mins ?

Because Trell hit a rooster in the head, broke his cheekbone and didn’t get sent off

 

[##fanboy88]

Because Trell hit a rooster in the head, broke his cheekbone and didn’t get sent off

Ahhhh yes !

 

[Brissie Kid]

This wasn't a penalty and match review said not a fine or suspension.

Not Found | Fox Sports Videos

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[47MVEagle]

Initially I thought he was hard done by as it looked to me like he was swinging his leg around in the process of getting onto his front in order to get up & play the ball but the replay clearly showed him looking at Jackson as he did it so I can understand them thinking he had intent.

That said, it wasn't like he pistoned his leg out to connect with Jackson so thought a penalty would have sufficed.

As others have said, possibly the NRL being ultra sensitive after Latrell's tackle on Friday night, so an overreaction.

 

[ManlyArmy]

If Aloiai deserved a sin bin, then we deserved a penalty try for Meaney kicking the ball out of Garrick's hand two minutes in

 

[winnyason]

He was our best today I like to see him and Keppie start tbh

 

[SeaEagle21]

It was BS and i'm feeling sick that come finals something like this will change the game. It was against a limp Bulldogs attack but against a top 4 or 8 team we would have been in trouble.

 

[Rafferty]

Josh was placed on report, surely he doesn’t have a case to answer, from memory he is carrying 75 points from his last early guilty plea, fingers crossed nothing comes of it or at worst a fine, the big fella is just starting to get his game back on track.

 

[JakeyB789]

Was a terrible call, he was just trying to get back to his feet with Jackson lying all over him. Wouldn’t have been an issue if the ref blew 6 again like he should have but he was letting the Dogs get a way with a lot in the ruck. You won’t hear anything about that though as people really think the Dogs were robbed in a game they were never going to win anyway.

Josh has been our best forward the last 2 weeks and a front row rotation of him, Paseka, Marty and Sipley/Keppie is very exciting going into the finals. I really like Sips but he can be a bit lazy and slow in defence so I think Keppie might be a better option in the finals, I’m sure Dessy has it all under control though

 

[The Who]

Every finals match will be influenced by a Bunker decision.
Get ready for the outrage when the better team loses because of them.

 

[QueefRichards]

I think it shouldve been a bin but not by the standards the refs have set this year.

 

[Remy]

Needs to get that out of his game. Had a great game. But stuff like that can cost us a finals game.

 

[master blaster]

This wasn't a penalty and match review said not a fine or suspension.

Not Found | Fox Sports Videos

www.foxsports.com.au

He has a habit of kicking out young Lattrel. I remember a tigers game he did the same and got suspended for that

 

[MadMarcus]

Needs to get that out of his game. Had a great game. But stuff like that can cost us a finals game.

Agree. It’s not the first time he has done something grubby and unnecessary. Somebody needs to tell him we’re not the Storm.

 

[Eagle 1]

This wasn't a penalty and match review said not a fine or suspension.

Not Found | Fox Sports Videos

www.foxsports.com.au

Beauty...Was hoping that was the case, Josh has carry overs from the last suspension, so all's well.

 

[ManEagle]

Probably against the grain but I felt he deserved the bin and penalty.
At first I thought he just accidentally collected while trying to play the ball.
On replay you can clearly see him looking straight at the dogs player, to me looked intentional.

Arguably the latrine kick out looked more accidental than Josh's.

We don't need to give ref's any more excuses and that was asking for it and no need.

 

[cc eagle]

Probably against the grain but I felt he deserved the bin and penalty.
At first I thought he just accidentally collected while trying to play the ball.
On replay you can clearly see him looking straight at the dogs player, to me looked intentional.

Arguably the latrine kick out looked more accidental than Josh's.

We don't need to give ref's any more excuses and that was asking for it and no need.

Latrell is good at looking the other way and lashing out, if he collects someone then he's innocent cos he's not looking, he did one against Garner

 

[sharx]

I’m that particular tackle I through the that josh was hit high

 

[ManlyArmy]

Josh is free to play this weekend after receiving a fine only