Injury list atm
- Thread starter Disco
- Start date
-
We had an issue with background services between march 10th and 15th or there about. This meant the payment services were not linking to automatic upgrades. If you paid for premium membership and are still seeing ads please let me know and the email you used against PayPal and I cam manually verify and upgrade your account.
The better Robbo
Bencher
Crazy list there!
Turbo and Cust back next week and hopefully Siro or Olakau-atu are back to replace Gosiewski.
A few back next week hopefully, Guaca and Turbo will improve us.
Brisbane Tragic
Bencher
arghhhhhhh. But that will mean Jetski has played his last game for Manly I would think
I was just going through the 'Casualty Ward' webpage on the NRL website and I was amazed at the amount of players out through leg injuries for 15 of the 16 NRL Teams. Only the Penrith Panthers escape the list of leg related injuries.
Here is a summary list of leg injuries for all teams barring the Panthers:
The Casualty Ward
Brisbane Broncos
Here is a summary list of leg injuries for all teams barring the Panthers:
The Casualty Ward
Brisbane Broncos
- Kotoni Staggs - (knee, mid-season)
- Josh Hodgson - (hip, TBA)
- Jake Averillo - (ankle, round 5)
- Jeremy Marshall-King - (foot, round 10-12)
- Raymond Faitala-Mariner - (foot, round 18-22)
- Jayden Okunbor - (knee, round 20)
- Christian Crichton - (knee, season)
- Ronaldo Mulitalo - (knee, round 5)
- Royce Hunt - (knee, round 7)
- Shaun Johnson - (Achilles, round 7-8)
- Sione Katoa - (knee, round 8-10)
- Jackson Ferris - (foot, round 10)
- Jamal Fogarty - (quad, round 5)
- Anthony Don - (hip, TBC)
- Jack Gosiewski - (ankle, TBA)
- Dylan Walker - (hamstring, TBA)
- Tom Trbojevic - (hamstring, round 6)
- Jorge Taufua - (Achilles, round 6)
- Curtis Sironen - (knee, round 6-8)
- Karl Lawton - (Achilles, round 11-12)
- Andrew Davey - (knee, season)
- Brenko Lee - (hamstring, round 5)
- Harry Grant - (knee, round 5-6)
- Dale Finucane - (calf, round 6)
- Jack Howarth - (hamstring, round 6-7)
- Cooper Johns - (hamstring, round 6-7)
- Max King - (Achilles, round 8-10)
- Edrick Lee - (foot, round 6)
- Tex Hoy - (hamstring, round 7-8)
- Phoenix Crossland - (knee, round 8)
- Bailey Hodgson - (knee, round 9)
- Dom Young - (knee, indefinite)
- Jirah Momoisea - (Achilles, indefinite)
- Tom Gilbert - (broken fibula, round 5)
- Mitch Dunn - (foot, round 6)
- Michael Oldfield - (knee, rounds 6)
- Waqa Blake - (calf, round 6)
- Taane Milne - (knee, rounds 6)
- Blake Taaffe - (ankle, round 8)
- Braidon Burns - (knee, round 8-9)
- Brock Gardner - (Achilles, indefinite)
- Jayden Sullivan - (hamstring, round 5)
- Ben Hunt - (leg, round 8)
- Cameron McInnes - (knee, season)
- Lindsay Collins - (ankle/head knock, round 6)
- Sam Verrills - (knee, round 8-10)
- Lachlan Lam - (knee, round 9)
- uke Keary - (knee, season)
- Addin Fonua-Blake - (knee, round 19-20)
- Peta Hiku - (knee, round 7)
- Euan Aitken - (ankle, round 9-11)
- Chanel Harris-Tavita - (foot, round 13-14)
- Billy Walters - (knee, round 6-7)
Totals:
- 22 x Knee
- 7 x Hamstring
- 6 x Achilles
- 6 x Foot
- 5 x Ankle
- 2 x Calf
- 2 x Hip
- 3 x Other (Quad, Broken Fibula, Un-Named Leg Injury)
The Who
Journey Man
My theory on why there are so many injuries, compared to yesteryear, is this:
Tacklers these days are intent on hurting their opponent, not simply bringing them to the ground. They go high to wrap up the ball, so collisions are greater. And there is much more gang tackling these days. Have you noticed the number of head clashes this year?
When I was playing my aim was to tackle around the legs and allow the momentum of my opponent to do the rest, toppling over like a tree without its roots. The great exponents of this technique included Ima Martian, Alan Thompson and Beaver Menzies.
There will always be leg injures (knees, ankles hammies, groin strains) because at pace these limbs are not created to be suddenly stopped or twisted.
I also believe that being muscle-bound, rather than lithe, leads to more impact injuries.
Tacklers these days are intent on hurting their opponent, not simply bringing them to the ground. They go high to wrap up the ball, so collisions are greater. And there is much more gang tackling these days. Have you noticed the number of head clashes this year?
When I was playing my aim was to tackle around the legs and allow the momentum of my opponent to do the rest, toppling over like a tree without its roots. The great exponents of this technique included Ima Martian, Alan Thompson and Beaver Menzies.
There will always be leg injures (knees, ankles hammies, groin strains) because at pace these limbs are not created to be suddenly stopped or twisted.
I also believe that being muscle-bound, rather than lithe, leads to more impact injuries.
manly al
First Grader
Be interesting to compare the N R L "s injury type or level against the English Super league injury stats . Still quite a reasonable standard of footy there but generally a much more attacking orientated style of play and usually not the same intensity in defence . Maybe their injury stats are not that dissimilar to the N R L but would tend to think not as serious in severity or of a higher incidence level . Lot of twisting and turning in N R L tackles , unfortunately must put a lot of extra strain on leg areas in particular . As for the muscle bound suggestion , probably not a big factor when some of the gang tackles are occurring and of course the perennial luck factor and guys like Beaver and no doubt some others who were or are almost impervious to serious injury .
Mitchell P1ss is missing from the Nots list.
They've copped it pretty badly this year too.
I still think we have the gold medal though. As Disco pointed out. A whole team virtually. And 6 may be vacant but I'm pretty sure Foz's knee is farked. He's just battling on. So pencil him in.
They've copped it pretty badly this year too.
I still think we have the gold medal though. As Disco pointed out. A whole team virtually. And 6 may be vacant but I'm pretty sure Foz's knee is farked. He's just battling on. So pencil him in.
Eagle Eyed
Member
Totally agree with this, and I have always thought similar, I saw with some of the older games with Tommy Raudonikis recently, there were less in tackles, more of the one or two players on one attacker, and of course none of all the other modern tackling techniques added, which has seen modern players suffer injuries they didnt as much before with all the twisting, heavier bodies etc I thought a possible change in tackling rules, such as one or maximum two defenders in tackles, (one below, one above) easier on the attackers being only two, not a gang, less friendly fire with the defence with stray elbows on team mates, may add to the game overall as attackers have a greater chance of busting the tackle, less head clashes as well as its not an over crowded situation, it would all lead to a more potentially open game but hopefully less injuries associated with tackling overall, too many in tackles makes it too hard for the classic Beaver tackle also, worth a consideration.
manlyfan76
There is no A.I. Just better computers
For this to work you would need less interchanges to keep it interesting.
John Nicholson
Nicko
Knees, hammies and ankle injuries have been around forever.
The amount of workload has changed, however with increased speed in the game and more demanding coaching KPI's.
Accordingly, you are going to see more injuries.
HIA's are now a different stat. as they weren't worried about before, or even counted? They are occurring through accidental head clashes (speed of the game) and poor tackling techniques.
How many HIA's do you see where the defender puts his head/neck in front if the ball carrier's hip. Too high or too low!
Again, high tackles give not only head clashes but friendly fire from loose arms and elbows from team mates, all scrambling to stop the offload.
The speed of the game has been discussed before, however it is up to the coaches and defensive assistants to train players in safety.
The amount of workload has changed, however with increased speed in the game and more demanding coaching KPI's.
Accordingly, you are going to see more injuries.
HIA's are now a different stat. as they weren't worried about before, or even counted? They are occurring through accidental head clashes (speed of the game) and poor tackling techniques.
How many HIA's do you see where the defender puts his head/neck in front if the ball carrier's hip. Too high or too low!
Again, high tackles give not only head clashes but friendly fire from loose arms and elbows from team mates, all scrambling to stop the offload.
The speed of the game has been discussed before, however it is up to the coaches and defensive assistants to train players in safety.
Here's a list of current Head Knock/Concussion injuies:
The Casualty Ward
Canberra Raiders
- Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad (Head Knock)
- Lachlan Lewis (Head Knock, round 6)
- Wade Graham (Head Knock, TBC)
- Josh Dugan (Head Knock, TBC)
- Phillip Sami (Head Knock, TBC)
- Kurt Mann (Head Knock, round 6)
- Murray Taulagi (Head Knock, round 5-6)
- Reuben Cotter (Head Knock, round 5-6)
- Justin O'Neill (Head Knock, round 6)
- Ryan Matterson (Concussion, round 6)
- Jaxson Paulo (Head Knock, round 5)
- Liam Knight (Concussion, indefinite)
- Boyd Cordner (Concussion, indefinite)
- Jake Friend (Head Knock/Concussion, retired)
Total:
- 14 x Head Knock/Concussion
Thank you Craig Bellamy !!
Agree , the aim is to maim!
They can deny it all they like but it’s a fact !!
40 years an eagle
Bencher
Manly Sea Eagles
Add Boyle to that list and our injury toll is a blessing in disguise.
AFB moving on is as well.
Walker filling in for Tom and Suli (as usual) have been horrible and have played a fair part toward our dismal performances...and i'm really over Walker for MANY reasons.
Tom back af FB next week. Winner
Harper will deservedly hold Suli's spot, and I wish Funa would partner him in his best position.. Winner
Sipley gets a run because AFB is gone. Winner
Guacamole to replace Jack from next week. Winner
Hopefully Saddler gets a shot because of Sirro's injury. Winner
Lawton would have been cheap because of his injury and will be useful when he is healed. Winner
Davey is a loss...but helps allow Saddler a crack. 50/50
Cust is not on the list and should be back next week.
My team next week because of our injuries.
Tent
Cust
Aoli
Gauc
Jake
Shoe
DCE
Foz
Saab
Harper
Funa
Garrick
Tom
Koula
Marty
Sipley
Saddler
- Jack Gosiewski - (ankle, TBA)
- Dylan Walker - (hamstring, TBA)
- Tom Trbojevic - (hamstring, round 6)
- Jorge Taufua - (Achilles, round 6)
- Curtis Sironen - (knee, round 6-8)
- Karl Lawton - (Achilles, round 11-12)
- Andrew Davey - (knee, season)
Add Boyle to that list and our injury toll is a blessing in disguise.
AFB moving on is as well.
Walker filling in for Tom and Suli (as usual) have been horrible and have played a fair part toward our dismal performances...and i'm really over Walker for MANY reasons.
Tom back af FB next week. Winner
Harper will deservedly hold Suli's spot, and I wish Funa would partner him in his best position.. Winner
Sipley gets a run because AFB is gone. Winner
Guacamole to replace Jack from next week. Winner
Hopefully Saddler gets a shot because of Sirro's injury. Winner
Lawton would have been cheap because of his injury and will be useful when he is healed. Winner
Davey is a loss...but helps allow Saddler a crack. 50/50
Cust is not on the list and should be back next week.
My team next week because of our injuries.
Tent
Cust
Aoli
Gauc
Jake
Shoe
DCE
Foz
Saab
Harper
Funa
Garrick
Tom
Koula
Marty
Sipley
Saddler
The better Robbo
Bencher
I like it but with Koula still playing 18s I doubt he will get a shot this year. Happy to carry a back on the bench, maybe Tuipulotu...
Some word on Lawton, he may be fit for round 9.
Staff online
-
Kiwi EagleModerator
| Team | P | W | L | PD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
6 | 5 | 1 | 59 | 12 |
|
6 | 5 | 1 | 20 | 12 |
|
6 | 4 | 2 | 53 | 10 |
|
6 | 4 | 2 | 30 | 10 |
|
7 | 4 | 2 | 25 | 9 |
|
7 | 4 | 3 | 40 | 8 |
|
7 | 4 | 3 | 24 | 8 |
|
7 | 4 | 3 | -8 | 8 |
|
7 | 4 | 3 | -18 | 8 |
|
7 | 3 | 3 | 20 | 7 |
|
7 | 3 | 4 | 31 | 6 |
|
7 | 3 | 4 | 17 | 6 |
|
6 | 2 | 4 | -31 | 6 |
|
7 | 3 | 4 | -41 | 6 |
|
7 | 2 | 5 | -29 | 4 |
|
6 | 1 | 5 | -102 | 4 |
|
6 | 0 | 6 | -90 | 2 |
