Gift's disallowed try?

[Eagleheart]

Just interested to hear your thoughts on Gift's disallowed try. I thought it looked o.k. through my maroon and white coloured glasses? 🙂

 

[Pittwater Legend]

No try. They got it right and I'm glad they did as you don't want to feel that a dud call helped you win.

 

[MissKate]

Wasn't a try but half the teams in the comp would have been given the try

 

[Eagleheart]

Hmm o.k. if it was a no try then I suppose maybe, it was fair that it was disallowed, thanks for clearing that up...! 🙂

(Maybe the lenses in my maroon and white coloured glasses are just getting thicker as I get older, lol....!)

 

[bob dylan]

No try.

The best way to judge them is this.

Pretend it's Grand Final day and Manly are ahead by 3 with 1 minute to go and replace the Manly player, in this case Glenn, with Billy Slater.

See I told you it was no try.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

No try.

The best way to judge them is this.

Pretend it's Grand Final day and Manly are ahead by 3 with 1 minute to go and replace the Manly player, in this case Glenn, with Billy Slater.

See I told you it was no try.

If applying that to all our tries last night I have a problem with all of them now 😉

 

[The Who]

I thought the video refs got all the calls right. Amazing, I know.
However, it was the on-field pinkies who continually stuffed up. They kept calling Canberra players back to the 10-metre mark, yet never penalised them. The pinkies are there to enforce the rules, not give coaching tips.
I watched the two Friday night matches and the refereeing has, unfortunately, slipped back to 2012 standard after showing a marked improvement in the early rounds of 2013.

 

[MadMarcus]

No try.

The best way to judge them is this.

Pretend it's Grand Final day and Manly are ahead by 3 with 1 minute to go and replace the Manly player, in this case Glenn, with Billy Slater.

See I told you it was no try.

Billy would have kicked the defending players in the head and put the ball down. Try.

 

[Garts]

Clear no try for me.

 

[Chip and Chase]

Close, but no cigar.

 

[panash]

If the ref on the field went with try , then i think there wasnt enough evidence to deny him , but the fact that the ref went with no try on the field , fair decision from the video ref...

but i swear it looked like he just got it down on first ground impact , then turned over !!!