Garrick general news thread

[Disco]

Of course everyone will **** on this post because everyone acts like everything’s rosy with this club but ask yourself the question. How many good games has Garrick had as opposed to how many poor games he’s had?

I’d have it at about 8-5 in favour of **** but nothing will change until the season’s over. Story of this club in recent years!

Why does everything have to be either rosy or ****???

Seems the way of everything these days, seems to have to be at one extreme end or the other.

Garrick is not ****, pathetic or the worst player in the team by a country mile. That is hyperbole IMO.

He does need to improve his defense, certainly, and in all facets too.

That said Garrick is nowhere near the reason we lost tonight.

 

[Top End Eagle]

M

Ouch, that’s as brutal as the tree was to Kenty

Mate I'm not Paul Kent lover, he's a grown man I happen to think writes and comment bravely in a world that rewards soft approaches with access. And I personally know how many blokes like to white knight around the issue of domestic violence to clout chase. And I watched this forum explode in a circus of hate when they pretended to be better than someone whose actual job is to stir the pot.

Don't mess with a Hashira kid. You'll keep on coming off like a salty regard. You brought Paul Kent into this. You have no knowledge of the game or anything that anyone here appreciates.

Jog on.

 

[JakeyB789]

Why does everything have to be either rosy or ****???

Seems the way of everything these days, seems to have to be at one extreme end or the other.

Garrick is not ****, pathetic or the worst player in the team by a country mile. That is hyperbole IMO.

He does need to improve his defense, certainly, and in all facets too.

That said Garrick is nowhere near the reason we lost tonight.

Garrick’s defence and goalkicking was a big reason we lost tonight. I certainly don’t think he’s a **** player, in fact at his best he is origin quality, but since the move to centre we are certainly getting more bad than good from him. I don’t think swapping him and Talau is a tough decision for anyone let alone an NRL standard coach

 

[Waz13]

Why does everything have to be either rosy or ****???

Seems the way of everything these days, seems to have to be at one extreme end or the other.

Garrick is not ****, pathetic or the worst player in the team by a country mile. That is hyperbole IMO.

He does need to improve his defense, certainly, and in all facets too.

That said Garrick is nowhere near the reason we lost tonight.

Things are never as good as they appear and they are also never as bad as they appear. If a few on here applied that mindset we’d have a few more balanced posts.

That said Garrick is a winger not a centre imo.

 

[Disco]

Garrick’s defence and goalkicking was a big reason we lost tonight. I certainly don’t think he’s a **** player, in fact at his best he is origin quality, but since the move to centre we are certainly getting more bad than good from him. I don’t think swapping him and Talau is a tough decision for anyone let alone an NRL standard coach

I'd have to rewatch the tries, but Garrick was not at direct fault for any from memory.

The first try is already advantage To'o when he gets the ball, he scores there 9 times out of 10.

Though certainly agree his defence needs to improve.

 

[danny-boy]

I don’t get it I really don’t. I mean what is it? Is the centre position a deal he was promised for not going to the Knights? Does he have photos of Seibold?

What is it? Bennet and Bellamy wouldn’t stand this ****. How is this happening?

 

[joeboy]

It’s not really just the poor goal kicking today,

It’s the poor tackling, (made 11, missed 6 ) and conceding of post contact metres , the stupid skip in his hit ups, the loss of leg drive, which result in largely terrible runs. The not knowing how and when to pass to Saab.

not alone in being largely average though.

Needs to be in the wing.

 

[robbiea]

You cant blame missing goals from the sideline for losing a match.He makes more than he misses.
No structure or gameplan killed it for us.

 

[madmax]

No he genuinely sucks. If you don't think he does then you're the problem.

This place used to be filled with people who knew rugby league. Now it's full of people just wanting to belong, be 'part of a tribe' or some crap.

Can't kick can't tackle, Parker is ten times the player this myth is.

You’re the problem mate! Moaning, whingeing twat! The only one that has no clue about rugby league is YOU!

 

[madmax]

M

Mate I'm not Paul Kent lover, he's a grown man I happen to think writes and comment bravely in a world that rewards soft approaches with access. And I personally know how many blokes like to white knight around the issue of domestic violence to clout chase. And I watched this forum explode in a circus of hate when they pretended to be better than someone whose actual job is to stir the pot.

Don't mess with a Hashira kid. You'll keep on coming off like a salty regard. You brought Paul Kent into this. You have no knowledge of the game or anything that anyone here appreciates.

Jog on.

It’s you no one appreciates Lolol. It’s you that knows nothing about the game…..disappear!

 

[God]

Solid on the wing Terrible at centre one of the worst centres in the comp, defensively worse than Morgan Harper

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Looks like a tantrum over 3 missed sideline conversions to me but each to their own.

Four missed (albeit difficult) conversions and he has a point. Why has coach Marvin the Martian turned his back on Parker?

However it should also be highlighted that there were at least two forward passes in the lead up to two (perhaps more) of the Penrith Peasants’ tries.

 

[Top End Eagle]

You’re the problem mate! Moaning, whingeing twat! The only one that has no clue about rugby league is YOU!

Thanks champ, you're obviously a Reuben sandwich fan. Is it that scar on the lip, makes him feel attainable for you if you just tell him he's still beautiful. Don't want any part of that fantasy to be honest.

 

[Eagledare2dream]

He's a good player and kicker and we lost because of him today. MOMENTUM is the key, if he got those kick it would have lift us alot but instead it lifted them. Advice to the team and him is, practice more kicking please 80% make it 90%. Saab stay on your man don't come in, if they score not your fault. F##KKKK up my tipping got every game so far was gonna change at the last minute but stayed loyal. Would have moved to the top of the ladder because no body tip Manly also extra 3pts for a perfect round if eels win for ex Eagle CGutho 200 game tomorrow but still 3rd on the table but I gotta stop tipping the boys cause I tipped them always and it cost me every year.

THINK OF MY HEAD NOT MY HEART

 

[Top End Eagle]

Four missed (albeit difficult) conversions and he has a point. Why has coach Marvin the Martian turned his back on Parker?

However it should also be highlighted that there were at least two forward passes in the lead up to two (perhaps more) of the Penrith Peasants’ tries.

You have remained in my almost fifteen years on this sub a constant. A constant bamboozlement at most times, but a constant none the less. Never change.

 

[eagleron]

He's the worst player in this team by a country mile.

He's not a centre and if Seibold continues with this experiment we'll finish in the bottom four, if we can all see it why can't he? I'm fast losing patience, we're playing the same sh1t as in the past five years, wake up Seibold or fck off

 

[Top End Eagle]

Garrick outside Koula or Talau is so obvious. He's been promised centre of or some reason I can't fathom. He's a first grade winger and goal kicker, he doesn't even look happy playing centre.

 

[Heckenberg]

He’s been pretty bad at centre. Defensive reads are abhorrent and leaves saab (who isn’t a great hit and stick defender) isolated far too often. I’d have him back to left wing with koula back on the right centre and talau at left. It’s a **** hill to die on jeprodisring our season just to try someone who was unreal at wing In another position based on potential.

 

[Eagledare2dream]

Bring back MRidge

 

[hozza]

Whole right side flank is fuking horrible in defence, point blank. Starting with concrete feet D$E , Garrick and the poor winger.
Garrick to wing may fix it, then again may not. It’s definitely not working with Garrick at centre though..