David Williams no try

[CliffyIsGod]

Move on.

 

[The Wheel]

OK it should have been a scrum

 

[Jatz Crackers]

"Move on."

Isnt this a forum where we discuss Manly & league issues ?

I am not hung up on the issue, I am simply debating the merits of the ruling. Is that OK with you ?

 

[Fro]

No Jatz we must all join hands and sing songs

 

[Jatz Crackers]

No Jatz we must all join hands and sing songs

Never did like that sing song rubbish around the campfire. Must be those scout master peodophile types.

So........what do you reckon. A scrum should have been called or do you think play should have been allowed to continue ? Or do you still think penalty ? (if so how come)

 

[Fro]

Yeah Penalty, only because I never admit I'm wrong

 

[Canteen Worker]

It is a penalty or a try. There is no rule in the book to allow a scrum. Black or white, not the shades of grey a few are looking for.

 

[SilentBob]

Where accidental obstruction irregularly affects the play, the game should be stopped and restarted with a scrum.

Aren't most of them accidental???

 

[Jatz Crackers]

Where accidental obstruction irregularly affects the play, the game should be stopped and restarted with a scrum.

Aren't most of them accidental???

No better example than the Williams try. Lyon was facing Williams when Campese ran into the back of him. Should make the footage of this incident the definition of accidental obstruction in a video dictionary.

 

[Canteen Worker]

Jatz you are right and I bow to your superior knowledge. Well done. Over and out!!!!!

 

[The Wheel]

There you go Ryan Canteen can admit he is wrong...

 

[Jatz Crackers]

Jatz you are right and I bow to your superior knowledge. Well done. Over and out!!!!!

And I bow to your wise & gracious nature. (inset bowing emoticon here)