Nordburg
First Grader
I have no idea what game Andrew Johns was watching last night when he said Cust was Manly’s best.Obviously showing his bias by the fact Cust lived with his brother for a while
Cust will tip Elgey to partner DCE
- Thread starter maxta
- Start date
frank stokes
I discriminate indiscriminately
Andrew John's is still burnt by the fallout from Stillettos... any course of action he suggests for Manly should be avoided at all cost....
I think this battle of the halves has a few more scurmishes to be played out before a clear winner is announced ... I have stated earlier that given we will have DCE for a few years yet .... the eventual winner will be the one that compliments DCE the best at 5/8 .. and at the moment .... that is still undecided ...
HoldenV8
Journey Man
I don't really want to start anything here.....but sometimes I get the feeling that you say things just for the sake of creating arguments in here.
LG is crap. He was crap at the Tits and has been crap here. The only reason he has played 11 out of 12 first grade games this year is because he was given first crack at being DCE's halves partner, and then after he was dropped for not being up to standard, both Croker and DCE got injured which meant he got a reprieve because we needed a halfback.
I hope this never happens, but if DCE got a season ending injury in Origin, I'd rather Des used Croker and Cust as our halves before even considering LG. Hell, I'd even go so far as to have Parker and Suli in the centres when they return and play Walker in the halves before having to put up with more of the crap that LG delivers.....and I don't think Walker should be anywhere near the halves again.
There was one point last night in the second half where we were actually attacking the Panthers line. LG got the ball on the 5th only 10 metres out and instead of kicking to the in-goal.....he passed it off to Garrick who had nowhere to go and got buried resulting in a turnover. He didn't want to take on the line himself and obviously didn't want to kick it, so he passes it off like he's passing the buck.
Have a read of what @Sue said on the first page of this thread about LG. Its 100% correct.
With Cherry and Croker out right now, LG has had the perfect opportunity to put his hand up and say "I'm the Man" to Des, his team mates and to us fans. He hasn't come close to doing that, not even against the Sharks when he was actually shown up by a first game rookie (Cust).
HoldenV8
Journey Man
Let me put it this way.....
After watching him run around for Manly this year I can understand why Tits fans weren't happy that DCE backflipped to stay at Manly because it meant they had to put up with LG for 4 years.
A halfback in his 5th year of first grade should be showing a hell of a lot more than putting up medium height midfield bombs that put the opposition under no pressure whatsoever when his side is 15-0 down 70 minutes into an 80 minute game. Cust was also crap for the most part last night, but at least he never gave up out there. At least he was willing to take the line on and have a go.
After watching him run around for Manly this year I can understand why Tits fans weren't happy that DCE backflipped to stay at Manly because it meant they had to put up with LG for 4 years.
A halfback in his 5th year of first grade should be showing a hell of a lot more than putting up medium height midfield bombs that put the opposition under no pressure whatsoever when his side is 15-0 down 70 minutes into an 80 minute game. Cust was also crap for the most part last night, but at least he never gave up out there. At least he was willing to take the line on and have a go.
Last edited:
Cust would be the bottom of all my options at 6, his kicking game is worse then Elgey’s and his passing game hasn’t been shown yet either. He has shown a nice running game, so I could only have him in the 14 shirt if one of the hookers got injured at the moment
Is easy to look at Custs flashy plays in the final 10mins and say he is the man, but in some very major aspects of the game he is not close to first grade standard at the moment but can hone that in the grade below and come back better
Is easy to look at Custs flashy plays in the final 10mins and say he is the man, but in some very major aspects of the game he is not close to first grade standard at the moment but can hone that in the grade below and come back better
Snake
Snake's Alive!
Brilliant post!
100% true.
Cust has always had a dubious kicking game and you are correct that when playing in the halves, you need one. It can be masked somewhat by DCE but sooner or later, Cust will need to stand on his own two feet.
Croker has a good kicking game and composure. I hope he gets the nod when fit.
Ryan
Journey Man
Jesus , I support Walker. Get hammered. Support Elgey. Get hammered. Support Brown. Get hammered. Support Lussick. Get hammered. Critique Suli. Get hammered. Critique Boyle. Get hammered. Support Barrett. Get hammered.
Etc, etc, etc. Y'all just a bunch of bullies. Hahaha.
It's actually bordering funny. The numbnuts here that froth at the mouth if someone dares to disagree with them, rather than just debate the topic at hand.
Like I've said numerous times, guys like Woodsie, Bazeagle, and many others will be driven away by the mob here, just like Darren, Byso, Matabele and many others. Then it'll be as boring af, vanilla, don't dare buck the gangs opinion forum. Like the official forum used to be that was run by the bogans back then. Thankfully the mods here are much better.
pjayz
הנשרים ישרור בעוד שנתיים מיום הנשרים
I thought Cust bounced back well in the second half. As another poster mentioned, it would have been easy for him to drop his head but he didn't. He is only three games into his NRL career - some posters are a bit harsh on him I feel. There is no doubt his kicking game is the area that he needs the most work on. He is much better than most rookie halves in defense, he has a quality running game, is active, confident and seems to be a good talker - all qualities needed for a half. His kicking game was below average and he seems to struggle for distance; however, these things can be developed. Crocker showed very little in terms of a kicking game last year - in fact, it was his greatest weakness, yet in the brief appearance he made this year he seemed to have improved in this area - who is to say Cust cannot do the same?
At this stage it is clear that Elgey is not the man we need in the halves. As I mentioned after the game (as did many), if DCE plays that game, we would have won. I also wanted to see more out of Api in that first half, taking control as the more experienced player in the spine. When Api is in a mood and decides to run, he is very dangerous, I would have loved to see more of that from him.
I don't think the Panthers handle an up tempo game with running halves and hookers keeping them on their toes through the ruck - we didn't make the most of exploiting that weakness.
On a side note; Fisher Harris is a grub and looked at where he aimed his knee - he knew exactly what he was doing to Fainu.
At this stage it is clear that Elgey is not the man we need in the halves. As I mentioned after the game (as did many), if DCE plays that game, we would have won. I also wanted to see more out of Api in that first half, taking control as the more experienced player in the spine. When Api is in a mood and decides to run, he is very dangerous, I would have loved to see more of that from him.
I don't think the Panthers handle an up tempo game with running halves and hookers keeping them on their toes through the ruck - we didn't make the most of exploiting that weakness.
On a side note; Fisher Harris is a grub and looked at where he aimed his knee - he knew exactly what he was doing to Fainu.
NYEagle
Bencher
Elgeys kicking game was downright horrible even when there was no pressure on him.
Both Cust and Croker are miles ahead in that department already,
NYEagle
manlyfan76
There is no A.I. Just better computers
Id have Fainu ahead of LG
You’re a good man Ryan, been debating with you for over 15 years now and only had 1 serious crack at each other from memory, you are entertaining and do love to hammer a point home lol
On your man Boyle, how do you think he would go on the wing ? 😉
No chance ... I come from a discipline that values facts above concensus .....
The under 18 team were in the raiders dressing room last night and he is a decent size already. I reckon by next season he could be too big for five eighth
Users who are viewing this thread
Latest posts
| Team | P | W | L | PD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
