Cust V Croker

[Will on the hill]

Lots of differing opinions on this. Let's have show of hands.

 

[sheridanstand78]

I would choose Cust out of these two, however I would go for Schuster hands down!

 

[Cioran]

If Cust can offer the attack he showed last year while becoming a solid defender I expect him to become one of the elite 5/8 ths in the game, if not the best.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I would choose Cust out of these two, however I would go for Schuster hands down!

Ditto and I think Schuster might jump over and take the spot at some stage.

 

[The better Robbo]

As a starter Croker but as a bench option Cust. Sounds odd I know but you want impact off the bench, something that Croker doesn't have compared to Cust. As a starter however Croker has great defence and is a workhorse so he gets the nod to start if Levi gets injured.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Croker in the past has displayed some sterling tackling so he will get the nod as 14 for the first few rounds (until he gets injured again 😱 although I hope he doesn't because he deserves some luck by now)

 

[Budgie]

Cust. You can’t go through life with those ears and not get a break somewhere along the way.

 

[maxta]

Cust between those 2...but there is better options that will get the jump

 

[double hoops]

Croker to start the year. They will all get to show their wares through out the season.

 

[Sheikheagle]

I reckon Izzard will squeeze into the top 30 and will hurdle both of them for the utility spot. The fact that he played the nines suggests they wanted to have a look at him. Greater utility value than the other 2 can play 6,7,9 and second row. Could also play centre at a pinch.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Edwin for mine.

 

[joeboy]

I’m hoping that both Cust and Croker are not required this year, it was a bit alarming how little that both had in attack in the offence-centric nines. If a “playmaker” Can’t put players through gaps in nine a side, they will most likely have even less attacking nous in NRL.

I agree with the above, Izzard seemed to have something to him

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

Izzard did look likely. Loved watching his dad play when I was a kid - big, bullocking centre with plenty of skill. Always wished he was at Manly.

 

[winnyason]

Edwin for mine.

Yeah he seems to at least have intent, croker has no idea at all.

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

Cust will make a good hooker, hes tough likes to run he can sell a dummy and has a nice short kicking game from what i remember.

Croker is also a tough bugger but hes injury prone, fingers crossed he makes it though the year i believe he would also make a good hooker off the bench. He is crafty, would provide good service and also has a decent kicking game.

Edwin Ipape i dont know anything about..

Joel Schuster from what i hear is the next big thing and I'm keen to see how he goes once given a shot in nrl. Hopefully the Grand Master Des has a plan for this young man.

Good times ahead, loads of talent coming through and the right blokes there to make them superstars! Des Donny Ballin snake monaghan.... Go Manly!

 

[BOZO]

Some of these players have obviously more natural ability and skill than others but another factor that impacts optimal performance is the attitude that the players have

Life has taught me that complacency is the forerunner of mediocrity in every thing we do

Every Athlete gets an A Plus from their coach on their attitude

Good luck to all our players competing for spots

 

[Bearfax]

I'm not sure Cust or Croker are long term propositions. I like Cust but the second half/hooker position seems to be heading Metcalfe's way, and if Fainu eventually comes back, then Levi's is back up hooker, or they share. Croker is only ever going to be a back up. Later this year Schuster will begin his charge into first grade. I sense he's ear marked for 5/8. But alternatively, he has the skills of a back and size of a forward and would be ideal on the bench. Initially though, at least for the first half of the season, either Cust or Croker will probably be the backup half/five eighth/hooker role on the bench. My gut feeling says Cust now and Schuster later

 

[manly al]

Croker has a bit more versatility and skill level at present , no doubt also that Cust has good general footy instincts . The indications or speculation some time ago is that Croker might have been preferred . Izzard looks to have the makings of a decent footy player as well and of course Ipane is not too shabby also . Then also , what if against most expectations , Fainu becomes available latter in the season . However for the present reality , will have to be one capable utility on the bench for season "s start .

 

[Woodsie]

GoJetSki would be my utility .....

 

[MightyEagles]

Izzard did look likely. Loved watching his dad play when I was a kid - big, bullocking centre with plenty of skill. Always wished he was at Manly.

Hey Ron E, Isn't his Dad Craig Izzard??? I thought Brad is his Uncle