Expressing an opinion and defaming somebody are two very different things. In the context of the Geyer situation that was clearly defamatory wrongly identifying a person in a video of that nature. I can't for the life of me understand why somebody would do that and think that it was okay. We are entitled to our opinions about selections and player's abilities and weaknesses. There is nothing derogatory about those types of discussions. These however are very different to reckless rumour spreading. The difference is very easy to identify.