2024 Optimist/Pessimist Thread - How are you feeling?

[Mark from Brisbane]

Still very optimistic, in 2024 any side can beat any side and playing sides after a huge loss is a curse ( for all sides ).

Whilst not in any way blaming the refs last night , there was a huge amount of penalties / 6 agains , our way , SO there was always going to be an even up , and when that occurred, they got the momentum, got a lucky try , and they never looked back.

**** happens , and we move on.

Hope the Phins win big this weekend as that’ll help.

 

[Hibyemama]

confident of a top 8. any further would be a bonus.(defence is terrible, no top 4)

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

confident of a top 8. any further would be a bonus.(defence is terrible, no top 4)

It’s a long season , and it’s a lottery.

Literally any of the current top 10 could end up being top 4.

 

[mickqld]

Top 4 will be out of 6
Penrith , Storm , Rorters , Broncos , Phins, Gummies (on another easy draw).
We have terrible defense not anywhere near good enough for top 4 will be lucky to squeeze into top 8.

 

[Cliffy's Jockstrap]

On our roster if we don't get into the top 8 there really should be an inquiry, that would be a startling underperformance. At the same time, I think Origin period will be a particular problem for us and in general we just don't have the focus and consistency to make a really big impact. 6 - 8 is as well as we can hop to go. 9 - 11 as badly as we can fear to go.

 

[mickqld]

On our roster if we don't get into the top 8 there really should be an inquiry, that would be a startling underperformance. At the same time, I think Origin period will be a particular problem for us and in general we just don't have the focus and consistency to make a really big impact. 6 - 8 is as well as we can hop to go. 9 - 11 as badly as we can fear to go.

Imagine when we don't make the 8 for the 3rd year in a row. My head will explode for starters. Think we would lose a lot of young supporters.

 

[BOZO]

It’s a long season , and it’s a lottery.

Literally any of the current top 10 could end up being top 4.

Hello Mate @Mark from Brisbane I hope all is well in your part of the world
Life Can be a lottery but we Can also make our own luck by making the right choices

The moral of the story
Choose to make the right choices or Lose

 

[Brocky]

Don’t have the coach/players/culture to win

 

[Ryan]

I'm holding to my original position on the team @Mark from Brisbane. We'll have ups and downs, but our recruitment for the past 3-4 years have laid a duck egg, and not filled clear & obvious gaps in our squad.

We have a winger playing centre
We have a prop playing Lock
We have a half-back playing Hooker
We have a utility that can play only backrow / hooker
Plus, all out forwards are too similar (larger, slower, immobile, power types) that drop off, and regularly get injured.
A NSW Cup team that is absolute arse.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I'm holding to my original position on the team @Mark from Brisbane. We'll have ups and downs, but our recruitment for the past 3-4 years have laid a duck egg, and not filled clear & obvious gaps in our squad.

We have a winger playing centre
We have a prop playing Lock
We have a half-back playing Hooker
We have a utility that can play only backrow / hooker
Plus, all out forwards are too similar (larger, slower, immobile, power types) that drop off, and regularly get injured.
A NSW Cup team that is absolute arse.

All fair comments.

There’s a bit more to happen in my opinion and it’s taken a while to “ De-Des” the team , it’ll be interesting to see who gets added in 25.

By then it’s all Seibold and on his back from then on.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I'm holding to my original position on the team @Mark from Brisbane. We'll have ups and downs, but our recruitment for the past 3-4 years have laid a duck egg, and not filled clear & obvious gaps in our squad.

We have a winger playing centre
We have a prop playing Lock
We have a half-back playing Hooker
We have a utility that can play only backrow / hooker
Plus, all out forwards are too similar (larger, slower, immobile, power types) that drop off, and regularly get injured.
A NSW Cup team that is absolute arse.

It could be worse ( as @tajhay knows) you could have played the last 4 games & not won one of them !!

Warriors looking extremely ordinary

 

[eaglebuzz]

Honestly this comp is so unpredictable, we are only a few minor improvements away from being top of the table and it feels like anybody can beat anybody.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Honestly this comp is so unpredictable, we are only a few minor improvements away from being top of the table and it feels like anybody can beat anybody.

Exactly , footy tipping is a nightmare

 

[Hotspur2014]

It’s not that anybody can beat anybody, it’s the officiating that determines the momentum of games and finally the result.
Never before have we seen teams get thumped by 40 one week and then win the next week.
Never before have we seen teams run to big early leads and then get beaten because the officiating gets the losing team back into the game.
The NRL has become an entertainment industry and no longer the combat sport that we used to know.
We are not quite yet like WWE wrestling where matches are scripted , but we are certainly on the way there based on what we are starting to see now on a weekly basis.

 

[sheridanstand78]

On our day we are more than capable of beating good sides but when you lose games you should nail you undo all that good work.

Bottom half of the 8 is our best scenario I believe, the team needs to develop consistency as the trend of giving up leads is our biggest weakness this season!

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

It’s not that anybody can beat anybody, it’s the officiating that determines the momentum of games and finally the result.
Never before have we seen teams get thumped by 40 one week and then win the next week.
Never before have we seen teams run to big early leads and then get beaten because the officiating gets the losing team back into the game.
The NRL has become an entertainment industry and no longer the combat sport that we used to know.
We are not quite yet like WWE wrestling where matches are scripted , but we are certainly on the way there based on what we are starting to see now on a weekly basis.

Yep, I’ve been saying it for a few years now and have been told to put my tin foil hat away , but you just cannot get this situation where a team gets thumped by 40 - 50 & next week they are world beaters without shenanigans going on.

Look at the games this weekend , I didn’t watch all of them but teams jumping out to a lead , and then getting run down was a common theme.

And disgraceful ref / bunker decisions determining how games are won ( Drizzle / Titans ) not forgetting our debacle at the end in NZ ( which I saw happen again this weekend for absolutely nothing to happen ).

It’s why I’m not losing my **** like most others about Thursday night.

It’s a lottery , who knows if we’ll feature come September, it’s anyone’s guess.

 

[The '47ers]

Is there a defeatist option 😔

 

[Eagles4Life]

I'm still confident we'll finish in the top six, and if things go our way for the rest of the season, a top four spot isn't out of the question. We're going into Round Ten in fifth spot, with all the teams ahead of us, including their bye in the points total. Go Manly.

 

[davohan123]

Well optismic people

This is been pathetic
Season over
Turbo gone

Just utter garbage from us

 

[davohan123]

I'm still confident we'll finish in the top six, and if things go our way for the rest of the season, a top four spot isn't out of the question. We're going into Round Ten in fifth spot, with all the teams ahead of us, including their bye in the points total. Go Manly.

After tonight my friend
No chance