The above nominations are mainly crap. There are not many villains about currently, as per the title post, even bloody Gallen is currently a hero.
My villains used to include players such as White and certainly Crocker. But even Crocker has faded a little, he performed a matchwinning illegal act of thuggery in a grand final yet it was deemed legal and he goes about his business week in and week out, including getting smashed without complaint by Choc & Matai in '08, so I find it hard to hate him too much.
McDougall when he stomped on Toovey's face is a different matter, he'd need several lifetimes to overcome the hate from that one.
Of current players I dislike Gibbs but he is improving, Farrah for last year, Marshall for being full of himself, Fulton mainly for not living up to the name. (Seems I do not like one team ...)
Apart from that of course Slater for the boots but really where are our villains? The thugs are being rubbed out, 'bring back the biff' cries Matty Johns, maybe the sex offenders and wife bashers are the new league villains?
Ennis I actually like, I can't explain why.
ps Bailey haters, or any haters of Manly players, JGAGS