Wasted resource

[globaleagle]

I like the outside the box thinking @SeaEagleRock8, and while it won't happen, it would be interesting to get a Silvertails consensus on what the team should be every week via poll and see how it matches up against the team selected.

It would be interesting seeing as there is rarely a consensus on the 3-2-1 voting and we all watch the same game!

 

[Fibro Eagle]

It’s not a bad idea but would never happen
It has a feeling of the lunatics running the asylum

 

[globaleagle]

It’s not a bad idea but would never happen
It has a feeling of the lunatics running the asylum

What would happen if some ST'ers marched up to the 'chosen ones' on a training day and handed them a petition?????

 

[Fibro Eagle]

What would happen if some ST'ers marched up to the 'chosen ones' on a training day and handed them a petition?????

They might suggest come and help us practice tackling .... Paseka will say you stand there and brace yourself

 

[globaleagle]

They might suggest come and help us practice tackling .... Paseka will say you stand there and brace yourself

I typed it badly, I was trying to make a joke that if 5 or so silvertail posters go and help out coaching....

the rest of us might march down to the club and make demands of them!

 

[Kez]

Week one of the fans coaching

1.Koula
2.Tuipulotu
3.Turbo
4.Harper
5.Saab
6.Schuster
7.Foran
8.Paseka
9.DCE
10.Jake
11.Parker
12.Olaku'atu
13.Saddler

14.Cust
15.Taufua (Backrow)
16.Keppie
17.Aloiai

Lose by 54

Week 2 of fans coaching

1.Funa
2.Koala
3.Suli
4.Tuipulotu
5.Taufua
6.T Trbojevic
7.DCE
8.Taupau
9.Walker
10.Sironen
11.Schuster
12.J Trbojevic
13.Saddler

14.Foran
15.Aloiai
16.Olaku'atu
17.Paseka

Lose by 62

Week 3 of fans coaching

1.T Trbojevic
2.Saab
3.Walker
4.B Trbojevic
5.Funa
6.Schuster
7.Humphries
8.Paseka
9.Foran
10.Saddler
11.Aloiai
12.Olaku'atu
13.DCE

14.J Trbojevic
15.Taupau
16.Cust
17.S Fainu

Lose by 48

Rise and repeat

You under estimate alot of people you dont know personally..fanatical fans that eat breathe and **** footy know more than you give them credit for..you think watching footy for 30+ years you learn nothing at all..i dont know about you but i think alot of things i have read here makes more sense than what des is doing..why we are here answer this if you can..when sirro is fit does schuster go back to blacktown or bench or does he stay put and sirro goes to blacktown cause i am sure des will slot sirro back in

 

[Disco]

You under estimate alot of people you dont know personally..fanatical fans that eat breathe and **** footy know more than you give them credit for..you think watching footy for 30+ years you learn nothing at all..i dont know about you but i think alot of things i have read here makes more sense than what des is doing..why we are here answer this if you can..when sirro is fit does schuster go back to blacktown or bench or does he stay put and sirro goes to blacktown cause i am sure des will slot sirro back in

Not implying that fans dont have great knowledge but the thought that a professional sporting club should be getting an commitee of fans together to advise its coach is absurd.

If any club had that little faith in your coaching staff then you sack and replace your coaching staff (which I'm personally in favour of with Des).

As for your Schuster question, he will be in first grade the rest of the year. Sironen, I'd say he will come back in somewhere.

The bigger concern is will Des play Olaku'atu.....

 

[Budgie]

@Technical Coach will be delighted with this great idea

Until I show up and offer Des antidepressants.

 

[maxta]

Hey Ser8 - great idea, but Des and the crew could not afford my expertise, so you are stuck with my insight right here on Silvertails !!