Time to Replace Green With Fresh Legs Hastings?

[Tomay]

You don't make changes to the spine this close to the finals. Hastings isn't going to direct the team around and without Green, DCE's form will drop. I think people underestimate the combination these two have formed, with DCE getting a lot of ball from Green making our attack click. Not to mention the repeat sets.

 

[NLSeaEagle]

I wanna replace him, even when he has a good game. Kicking game is exceptional, other than that, he's got nothing. Moves like an old woman.

I can see the argument that Green isn't giving much ......................but it shows you the sad sorry state we are in when Hastings is put forward as the alternative!
Green my be no good but he is a damn sight better than Hastings!!

For future reference I don't think Manly should be picking up players that Bellamy is showing the door!
If there is one bloke in the NRL which can sort talent and get the best from players, it's him!!

 

[effnic]

Replace Lane with ANYONE!!!

Powered by ForumApps

 

[Snake]

I can see the argument that Green isn't giving much ......................but it shows you the sad sorry state we are in when Hastings is put forward as the alternative!
Green my be no good but he is a damn sight better than Hastings!!

For future reference I don't think Manly should be picking up players that Bellamy is showing the door!
If there is one bloke in the NRL which can sort talent and get the best from players, it's him!!

Green wasn't really shown the door at the Storm, he moved on for $$$ and Slater was back in the fold so Munster had to slot in somewhere. The Storm have lost Harris and Proctor and they are both players they would have loved to keep...it shows how tight the Storm cap is when you consider the money the big 3 are on.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Let's face it. On Sunday Green offered very little. Missed a lot of tackles and kicking game was ****. A week off might do Might do Greenie good and give Hastings a chance to play a blinder. Plus he kicks better than Wright.

 

[NLSeaEagle]

Let's face it. On Sunday Green offered very little. Missed a lot of tackles and kicking game was ****. A week off might do Might do Greenie good and give Hastings a chance to play a blinder. Plus he kicks better than Wright.

Baz is never dropping Green......................this is one of those purely fan threads designed to debate the qualities of Green & Hastings!

100% never is Hastings coming into the side for Green unless he is injured or rested!

 

[Fibro Eagle]

I think Green's good games outway his bad games when Green is on we generally win . For the remainder of this season we have to stick with Green

 

[mickqld]

I'd have Cullen at 6 before Hastings. Put Hastings to fullback move Tom to center. Tom's injection from fullback have gone missing lately and his kick catching and returns are very ordinary. At center it might stop the dumb risky passes.

 

[Sea Eagle 4 Life]

Can we bring Hastings on every time a kick at goal is required?

 

[Holmsey]

Can we bring Hastings on every time a kick at goal is required?

I think it counts as an interchange.

 

[Sea Eagle 4 Life]

I think it counts as an interchange.

Probably worth it.
Wright kicks all goals on Sunday & we at least go to golden point.

 

[lsz]

Remember when we used to bring Cliffy on when we had the ball? back in the unlimited interchange days

 

[nightster]

Replace Lane with ANYONE!!!

Powered by ForumApps

needs to make more metres but does a lot of tackling ... many in cover ... and against the tigpies didn't get much good ball .... imho he has covered pretty well for Siro

 

[Paw93]

I'd have Cullen at 6 before Hastings. Put Hastings to fullback move Tom to center. Tom's injection from fullback have gone missing lately and his kick catching and returns are very ordinary. At center it might stop the dumb risky passes.

Cullen's not an organiser. He wouldn't go well with DCE. Hastings is definitely the game manager out of the two.

 

[Manly To Win!]

Probably worth it.
Wright kicks all goals on Sunday & we at least go to golden point.

You can never say what WOULD have happened! I agree it didn't help, but you can't just assume the result would have been the same.