1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

The Silvertails Preview: Round 7 The Manly Sea Eagles v The Parramatta Eels

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by lsz, Apr 14, 2016.

By lsz on Apr 14, 2016 at 6:12 AM
  1. lsz

    lsz Well-Known Member Staff Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

    +4,843 /102
    Manly won last week, as I predicted. Fortunately for us, Koroisau and Walker both looked like they were given a kicking crash course. We managed to actually get repeat sets this week with Koroisau once again putting on an impressive performance, again staking his claim that he belongs in the halves after DCE returns. Our forwards have continued to improve, dominating the much more favoured pack of the Warriors whilst Steve Matai and Jamie Lyon also stepped up in response to calls from fans for those two to be dropped. We continued to improve for another week in a row, which is pretty good.

    As for Parramatta, Trent Barrett summed it up in that they may be the one of the form teams of the comp. They have been playing very well. It took them five years but they have finally learnt how to cheat successfully. But that is a topic that doesn’t belong in this preview really. Their forward pack is getting a roll on and their classy halves are certainly taking advantage of that. They are a very good team this year, and they completely destroyed the Raiders last week, so they have momentum.

    Team Lists:

    The Warringah Sea Eagles:

    1. Brett Stewart

    2. Jorge Taufua

    3. Jamie Lyon

    4. Steve Matai

    5. Tom Trbojevic

    6. Dylan Walker

    7. Apisai Koroisau

    8. Darcy Lussick

    9. Matt Parcell

    10. Nate Myles

    11. Tom Symonds

    12. Martin Taupau

    13. Jake Trbojevic

    14. Lewis Brown

    15. Brenton Lawrence

    16. Josh Starling

    17. Siosaia Vave

    The Parramatta Eels

    1. Michael Gordon

    2. Semi Radradra

    3. Michael Jennings

    4. Brad Takairangi

    5. Clint Gutherson

    6. Corey Norman

    7. Kieran Foran

    8. Junior Paulo

    9. Nathan Peats

    10. Daniel Alvaro

    11. Manu Ma’u

    12. Beau Scott

    13. Tepai Moeroa

    14. Isaac De Gois

    15. Peni Terepo

    16. Danny Wicks

    17. Kenny Edwards

    Manly have named the same team that lined-up against the Warriors, with their extended bench of Lurgess and Leary being dropped, telling me that any injury concerns we have are gone.

    Parramatta have also named the same side as they did last week, and have no injuries to their first choice side.


    The Eels have a very good squad, but there are weaknesses there. Michael Gordon is probably one of them. Now Gordon is not a bad player by any stretch, he kicks goals, organizes their defence and has decent kick returns but he is not remarkable in any stretch of the word. Meanwhile Brett Stewart is the most underrated fullbacks in the game, and he is due for another try or three at Brookie, so I wouldn’t be surprised if he adds to his 163 try tally this game.

    As much as I hate to say it, Foran and Norman are one of the best halves combinations in the world. Norman has a surprisingly decent long kicking game and they are both great at organizing their attack. Foran looks like he is actually trying again, which just makes me bitter, but what can you do? Meanwhile we still have a centre as one of our halves, and a hooker turned half as our other. Api Koroisau and Dylan Walker both improved their last tackle options last week, with Api demonstrating an outstanding short kicking game and pretty decent bombing game. Our halves are decent, but they are completely outclassed here by the much more experienced Norman and Foran.

    Here is an unpopular opinion, I think that Matt Moylan is the most overrated player in the game. However Nathan Peats comes in at a close second in my mind. He is just….. average. I have never seen a game he has played where I thought to myself ‘wow, this guy is awesome’, but apparently everyone else has. I have no idea why so many people want him to be in the origin frame already, because I haven’t seen a game that he has dominated. Then again I haven’t seen him in many games with him constantly being off the field. He struggles to play more than 10 games a season, what is so good about him? Seriously can someone tell me what it is that makes people cream their pants over him? Matt Parcell on the other hand is the complete package and is an amazing player. We have been aided a lot by the quick play the balls he manages to generate. Add that to his speed and ability to get our forwards rolling and he is so much better than Peats.

    Their forward pack is… well not that much better than ours honestly. At least in terms of props. Junior Paulo is one of the form props of the game, whilst Alvaro is proving to be an honest toiler, Wicks is very underrated and Peni Terepo is fine. Meanwhile Myles is…. Myles. I believe people on this site judge Myles way too harshly but he is certainly not providing the impact people expected him too. But he is obviously doing something right is he is always at the top of our stats. Lussick I think is going to be very fired up this game, he always turned up against us and I think he will do the same to his former club. Meanwhile Lawrence will be trying to up his minutes by putting in another good performance and Starling will continue to be the honest toiler he is. But then we get to Vave, and how good is this bloke? Every time he steps onto the field he looks like he’s playing for dinner. He really does remind me of top form George Rose. It is round 7 and he already has a cult following even among non-Manly fans, top stuff. People fancy these Parra props but really ours are decent as well, especially now that they seem to be finally firing together. Our forwards can easily at least match it with these guys.

    As for the second row things are tight between us. I do think Manu Ma’u is a very good player, he is a nice hole runner and can give attacking players a nice wack. Beau Scott, credit to the man because he is playing a lot better than I thought he would and is proving to be a rock solid defender. Meanwhile Tepai Moeroa does his job and as annoying as I find Kenny Edwards he is a decent player, but I will rant about him later. Meanwhile we have Tom Symonds who is desperate for a new contract and is in career best form at the moment and of course we have the best young forward in the game at lock with Jake Trbojevic. And then we get to Taupau and he seems to have finally found some consistency. He isn’t reaching the ceilings he was at the Tigers but he is also nowhere near the troughs he experienced there as well. So I would say on average his form has increased. On the bench we have Lewis Brown, and if I was typing this on a phone I would have put the poo emoticon (is that what you call them?) thingy next to his name. I really do think he is only in the side until Buhrer comes back, he hasn’t been great. I do think our second row edges out theirs, but it is a close contest.

    As for the Parramatta backs, Jennings is overrated, Semi is the best winger I have ever seen play, Gutherson is almost comically bad and Taka is nothing special. Whilst you are telling me what people see in Peats can you also tell me what is so special about Jennings? He is fast… and that is about it. As for our team, Matai and Lyon are trying to keep their spots in the side whilst Taufua seems to be on an up spiral in the rollercoaster ride that is his form. Tom Trbojevic just constantly looks like he is a week or two away from ripping a side apart, and now that it appears he is being given the kick returns, I expect to see some fireworks from him this week. Our backs need to contain Semi, that is a must. If they can do that we will be okay.

    So this isn’t related to a preview much but I need to say that Kenny Edwards with his whole ‘hugging/high-fiving opposition players when my team scores a try to rub it in’ shtick is not funny and just annoying. But you see all of these Parra fans go ‘oh look at da bantz from Kenny lol’. Like first of all, bantz is an ugly word used by dumbasses and secondly it is just grubby. Crap like this is why I miss punches, because it meant losers like this guy can’t be niggly and annoying with no repercussions. Imagine him doing this to Matai and Skivvy floored him. I know it is probably something small and not worth even mentioning but it just irritates me.

    Now let’s talk about cap cheating. I am not going to speculate about if the Eels are and aren’t guilty, but I will say that I hope that if they are stripped points that the NRL waits until after our game to announce it. Stuff like this really fires a team up, because remember what Melbourne did in 2010 when they were told they were playing for nothing? They went on a rampage in vengeance. And I am afraid that this Parra team will do the same thing if they are told season 2016 is a write off. So that is a little concerning.

    Let me just say, thank god Brad Arthur has Taka with Gutho and Jennings with Semi. See Taka is a centre that likes to set his winger up, which means a lot of ball goes to dick fingers Gutherson. Meanwhile Jennings is a ball hog that never passes to his winger, limiting the stuff that Semi can do really. Parra would be a much better side if those two swapped, but they haven’t which is really good for us.

    Recently Parramatta have had one up over us, winning the past 3 games we have played. However I think that is more due to the fact that Brad Arthur knew how we played under Toovey so well because he was our assistant coach in 2013. It is no co-incidence we just magically played worse against Parra, they knew how to counter us. However now we have a very new squad, a new coach and a new playing style. Their advantage over us has crumbled away, meanwhile we have a very good idea about how their main attacking weapon plays. Expect us to really shut Foran down this week.


    Who doesn’t love a good Brookie ambush? People are writing us off, especially after how easily Parramatta crushed the Raiders but I just have this feeling we will pull the rug from under them. I just think we are going to go out there and surprise many. Parra will come into this complacent, and we will come in fired up and ready to win in front of our home crowd. I predict we will win in a close game by 10 points. This might just be me being biased but I have a feeling the lol@Parra thread is going to get a lot of use come Thursday night.
    • Like Like x 7
    • Agree Agree x 4


    Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by lsz, Apr 14, 2016.

      1. lsz

        lsz Well-Known Member Staff Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

        +4,843 /102
        Make sure to show @KeithSheldon some love for another great preview
      2. manlyfan76

        manlyfan76 Parra Trolls are the best. Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

        +8,030 /174
        Nathan peats isnot overrated by me, I've always thought he is crap.
        • Funny Funny x 2
        • nightster

          nightster I feel like a young girl from Melbourne Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

          +3,164 /78
          great rap @KeithSheldon in total agreement with most of what you say ...
          Go The Mighty Seaeagles
          • Like Like x 1
          • Moondog

            Moondog What's up Darth? Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

            +5,245 /51
            Luckily for us Semi is playing outside Jennings, the biggest ball hog I have ever seen play.
          • SeaEagleRock8

            SeaEagleRock8 Sea Eagle Lach Staff Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

            +10,544 /214
            Nice preview but of course comparing line-ups only tells part of the story.

            Both teams are on an upward curve when it comes to self-belief. The Eels are ahead of us currently on that score, and Foran has added a lot to their cohesion and stability. The cap scandal isn't slowing them yet, but will derail them pretty soon.

            Manly are less cohesive as a team, with all our new personnel and well-documented halves issues, yet we are starting to score points and the defence is looking better organised.

            Both sides are coming off a 5 day turnaround, and Manly also had to travel back from NZ. Manly are more used to 5 day turnarounds, but on the other hand might start to feel some accumulated effects from our ridiculous schedule.

            If our players can overcome the jet-lag/5 day syndrome then we will be right in this. I think the team will be up for it, as they won't want to give fans another home loss.

            This determination might be enough to get us home tonight, so I predict Manly by 4, with Killer's goal-kicking helping us home!
          • mjb136

            mjb136 MWSE fanatic Premium Member

            +1,544 /34
            Manly by 13+
            • Like Like x 1
            • Agree Agree x 1
            • maxta

              maxta Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

              +4,500 /100
              Stop the go forward in the middle & Manly win.
              Big Paulo & Co have dominated early exchanges recently, laying the platform for the halves to carve up the defence.
              Let's keep it real, Canberra were flat last week & had an off day as much as the Eels did play well.
              The Eels defence is their Achilles heel & have seen a few games in 2016 when they snuff out the opposition, fighting off repeat sets - then put on 2-3 quick tries on the back of it.
              Shows they have good attitude atm & Manly will have to hang tough to get over the top of them.
              Could be a real arm wrestle where the winner will be decided by desire.
              I see Manly 17-10 winners with best bet Tom Trjobovic anytime try, into a Manly win the best bet.
            • Turbo

              Turbo Well-Known Member

              +1,565 /497
              Parra are a bunch of cheating wankers and are bought not bred have a look a there side...


              14.De gois-Bought

              Plus they have to take our best players and turn them to **** coz they can't produce and good players like us. They've got no good under 20s players so they go buy form other sides. It's a disgusting culture and I'm afraid Foran isn't going to be the great player at manly he once was.

              Here's a combined side of manly and Parras team (best player in each position gets picked) for tonight based on form


              14.De gois

              We have the better side it's just combos that are hurting us IMO. Hope we flog them but I doubt it but manly rarely lose 2 in a row at Brookie and I've had my opinion changed over the week. I think we can win off the back of emotion and our playmakers need to shine I think they will. One thing I hate hearing about is how good Norman is! He isn't good at all he has no kicking game he throws a lot of hospital passes and should be playing fullback but Brad (Never made the finals and play first grade) Arthur is to dumb. Bench is the difference in this clash along with the form of our young gun halfback Koroisau.

              Manly 18 (Snake, Koroisau, Trbojevic tries-Lyon 3/3 goals)
              Parra 12 (Jennings, Peats tries-Gordon 2/2 goals)

              MOTM Koroisau
            • Mark from Brisbane

              Mark from Brisbane Living the dream Premium Member

              +19,635 /383
              • Like Like x 3
              • KeithSheldon

                KeithSheldon Well-Known Member

                +775 /40
                Also if you think this article isn't as good as the other ones I will take a leaf out of our coach's book and blame the five day turnaround. My fingers are fatigued.
                • Like Like x 1
                • Funny Funny x 1
                • The Who

                  The Who Well-Known Member Premium Member

                  +7,247 /173
                  If we are to win I believe Brett will have to play a large role. He needs to be at his best for us to score tries. He is the key, imo.
                  • Agree Agree x 1
                  • Clever Clever x 1
                  • Fibro Eagle

                    Fibro Eagle Well-Known Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

                    +1,100 /44
                    Tough game tonight the Sqeels have proven they are hard to score against but in return don't score alot either exception last week against a poor Canberra
                    We have struggled for cohesion in attack many times this season
                    So for me its going to be close the key to stop Semi from scoring and Manly can get the points if Semi doesn't score Manly win
                    Go Manly & Skivi to put a rattler on Foran

                Share This Page