SMH article about Manly’s shambolic salary cap situation

Terry Zarsoff

First Grader
From Dan Walsh, SMH

Manly’s biggest need – emergency roster surgery – will linger after DCE leaves

By Dan Walsh
August 19, 2025 — 5.33am

Amid the season-long Daly Cherry-Evans saga, a Sea Eagles succession plan around Anthony Seibold’s eventual shift from coaching, the Manly old boys agitating for his exit far sooner and a 2025 campaign down the gurgler, two numbers stand starkest.

The slew of sidelined forwards watching Sunday’s capitulation to Wests Tigers, which wouldn’t give much change from $4 million.

And the back-ended deals of the club’s heart and soul, Jake and Tom Trbojevic, which next year will combine for around $2.4 million on the salary cap.

Misery has company aplenty on the Northern Beaches after three-straight losses that have torpedoed their finals prospects, an ignominious early end to what had shaped as the most promising season of Seibold’s tenure.

Jake Trbojevic is unlikely to play again this season, not that Manly’s finals hopes would have dictated his availability. His well-being was always going to come before taking the field, regardless of the stakes.

Three concussions in the past four months have an extended rest and precautionary neurological testing on the cards before any thought turns to playing on in 2026, and a possible contract extension beyond that.

IMG_1129.webp

Jake Trbojevic is likely to be rested for the remainder of the 2025 season.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

Contract talks on reduced deals with the brothers have been ongoing for months, with Manly officials well aware their roster needs restructuring at the same time. This masthead reported in June that Tom has made clear he does not want any new contract to impact retention talks with key players, while Jake has long gone above and beyond for his junior club.

The current Trbojevic deals totalled more than $12 million when they were signed in 2019 under a previous Sea Eagles administration. Both were back-ended most heavily in 2026, the final year of each deal.

Along with Cherry-Evans’ seven-figure pay packet as captain and one of the game’s elite halfbacks, Manly’s salary cap configuration is the closest to that long-adopted at Melbourne.

The Storm’s famed ‘big three’ cap model around Cameron Smith, Billy Slater and Cooper Cronk has expanded to a ‘big four’ of Ryan Papenhuyzen, Cameron Munster, Jahrome Hughes and Harry Grant.

IMG_1130.webp

Cameron Munster and Ryan Papenhuyzen are Melbourne’s prize-winning match-winners.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

Melbourne boast the best spine in the NRL and spend more money on their play-making quartet than any other side. They have long built around their highest earners with a support cast that punches above their weight under Craig Bellamy’s coaching.

Cherry-Evans and the Trbojevic family money pit have been Manly’s backbone for more than a decade and are paid as such.

But as the trio struggle for form and fitness like never before, club officials are painfully aware of the shortfall in the rest of their roster.

Injuries to star forwards Taniela Paseka and Haumole Olakau’atu (who was upgraded on an eight-year deal worth more than $7 million in late 2023) have robbed Manly of their best big men this season.

Haas opens up on defection to Samoa
Payne Haas talks about his decision to change his international playing allegiance from Australia to Samoa.

A submission for Josh Aloiai’s medical retirement due to a shoulder injury has been made to the NRL. If approved, the club would free up around $1 million from their cap over the next two years.

Similar concerns are held for hooker Lachlan Croker given his concussion history. Nathan Brown has been sidelined with a ruptured biceps since late June.

Manly’s middle depth was already the biggest question mark over their title hopes before a ball was kicked.

“We’re probably missing some of our key guys, particularly some of our bigger bodies,” Seibold said after the listless 26-12 loss to the Tigers.

IMG_1131.webp

Manly coach Mr Blobby.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

“We lost the battle there in the middle. I can bull**** you, but that’s where we lost it.”

Manly’s injury woes have exacerbated their roster shortfalls, and the Sea Eagles concede that a more balanced approach to their cap is needed.

The club is actively hunting for front-rowers in a market short on them as veteran prop Toafofoa Sipley and utility Jazz Tevaga both move to Super League next season. Matt Lodge is set to be upgraded from a train-and-trial deal to Manly’s top 30.

Canterbury’s Jake ‘Dick’ Turpin is being sized up as dummy-half cover for Croker and teammate Blake Wilson as depth out wide, but big bodies are needed alongside incoming halfback Jamal Fogarty next season.

By 2027, the plan is for Manly’s salary cap to have a distinctly different look to it - with the two eldest Trbojevic brothers on reduced contracts, Jake’s by as much as 50 per cent.

As Seibold lamented with a nod to his injured forwards on Sunday though, “we’ve got no one coming back to save us.”

The next million-dollar question, though, is who comes in to save them?
 
I feel like this article was written by ChatSMH as it looks like it has cobbled together all the Silvertail posts and spat out what's wrong with the club. Altho, it doesn't mention Penn 😂.
We all know the roster needs an overhaul and that our forwards remain the starting point. But at least the problem is being shouted out loud now, where the heck are those players going to come from??!!
 
So the way I see it the chance for improvement next year lies in some young players breaking out.

Our stocks aren't bursting at the seems in the regard so not wildly optimistic.

Obviously that may change with medical retirements to any of Jake, Aloiai or Crokes.

2027 is the year though and we have a real opportunity to set ourselves up for success.

Need to made the right calls there.
 
From Dan Walsh, SMH

Manly’s biggest need – emergency roster surgery – will linger after DCE leaves

By Dan Walsh
August 19, 2025 — 5.33am

Amid the season-long Daly Cherry-Evans saga, a Sea Eagles succession plan around Anthony Seibold’s eventual shift from coaching, the Manly old boys agitating for his exit far sooner and a 2025 campaign down the gurgler, two numbers stand starkest.

The slew of sidelined forwards watching Sunday’s capitulation to Wests Tigers, which wouldn’t give much change from $4 million.

And the back-ended deals of the club’s heart and soul, Jake and Tom Trbojevic, which next year will combine for around $2.4 million on the salary cap.

Misery has company aplenty on the Northern Beaches after three-straight losses that have torpedoed their finals prospects, an ignominious early end to what had shaped as the most promising season of Seibold’s tenure.

Jake Trbojevic is unlikely to play again this season, not that Manly’s finals hopes would have dictated his availability. His well-being was always going to come before taking the field, regardless of the stakes.

Three concussions in the past four months have an extended rest and precautionary neurological testing on the cards before any thought turns to playing on in 2026, and a possible contract extension beyond that.

View attachment 31002
Jake Trbojevic is likely to be rested for the remainder of the 2025 season.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

Contract talks on reduced deals with the brothers have been ongoing for months, with Manly officials well aware their roster needs restructuring at the same time. This masthead reported in June that Tom has made clear he does not want any new contract to impact retention talks with key players, while Jake has long gone above and beyond for his junior club.

The current Trbojevic deals totalled more than $12 million when they were signed in 2019 under a previous Sea Eagles administration. Both were back-ended most heavily in 2026, the final year of each deal.

Along with Cherry-Evans’ seven-figure pay packet as captain and one of the game’s elite halfbacks, Manly’s salary cap configuration is the closest to that long-adopted at Melbourne.

The Storm’s famed ‘big three’ cap model around Cameron Smith, Billy Slater and Cooper Cronk has expanded to a ‘big four’ of Ryan Papenhuyzen, Cameron Munster, Jahrome Hughes and Harry Grant.

View attachment 31003
Cameron Munster and Ryan Papenhuyzen are Melbourne’s prize-winning match-winners.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

Melbourne boast the best spine in the NRL and spend more money on their play-making quartet than any other side. They have long built around their highest earners with a support cast that punches above their weight under Craig Bellamy’s coaching.

Cherry-Evans and the Trbojevic family money pit have been Manly’s backbone for more than a decade and are paid as such.

But as the trio struggle for form and fitness like never before, club officials are painfully aware of the shortfall in the rest of their roster.

Injuries to star forwards Taniela Paseka and Haumole Olakau’atu (who was upgraded on an eight-year deal worth more than $7 million in late 2023) have robbed Manly of their best big men this season.

Haas opens up on defection to Samoa
Payne Haas talks about his decision to change his international playing allegiance from Australia to Samoa.

A submission for Josh Aloiai’s medical retirement due to a shoulder injury has been made to the NRL. If approved, the club would free up around $1 million from their cap over the next two years.

Similar concerns are held for hooker Lachlan Croker given his concussion history. Nathan Brown has been sidelined with a ruptured biceps since late June.

Manly’s middle depth was already the biggest question mark over their title hopes before a ball was kicked.

“We’re probably missing some of our key guys, particularly some of our bigger bodies,” Seibold said after the listless 26-12 loss to the Tigers.

View attachment 31004
Manly coach Mr Blobby.CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

“We lost the battle there in the middle. I can bull**** you, but that’s where we lost it.”

Manly’s injury woes have exacerbated their roster shortfalls, and the Sea Eagles concede that a more balanced approach to their cap is needed.

The club is actively hunting for front-rowers in a market short on them as veteran prop Toafofoa Sipley and utility Jazz Tevaga both move to Super League next season. Matt Lodge is set to be upgraded from a train-and-trial deal to Manly’s top 30.

Canterbury’s Jake ‘Dick’ Turpin is being sized up as dummy-half cover for Croker and teammate Blake Wilson as depth out wide, but big bodies are needed alongside incoming halfback Jamal Fogarty next season.

By 2027, the plan is for Manly’s salary cap to have a distinctly different look to it - with the two eldest Trbojevic brothers on reduced contracts, Jake’s by as much as 50 per cent.

As Seibold lamented with a nod to his injured forwards on Sunday though, “we’ve got no one coming back to save us.”

The next million-dollar question, though, is who comes in to save them?
Do your basic fact checking, Mr Walsh. Four losses in a row.
And no, you can't bull**** us, Mr Blobby.
 
They are clearly targeting the mass contract ending surge associated with the Bears and PNG entering the competition. Player managers would be all over this.

Problem for us is this does not help 2026 which looks like our season is doomed 7 rounds earlier than 2025.
 
They are clearly targeting the mass contract ending surge associated with the Bears and PNG entering the competition. Player managers would be all over this.

Problem for us is this does not help 2026 which looks like our season is doomed 7 rounds earlier than 2025.
Yet another reason to move Seibold on.What will be different to his first 3 years at the helm? Obviously nothing in regards to recruitment given Lodge appears to be in line for an extension.Given Fogarty is basically coming for $$ and will be playing behind an ordinary pack,whats to guarantee he’ll be playing at or better than his current level.A lot of people talking up 2027 is the year,but unless there’s a flood of juniors coming through,how are Manly going to compete in the market with the new teams financially and having Seibold as the lure?
 
Last edited:
Yet another reason to move Seibold on.What will be different to his first 3 years at the helm? Obviously nothing in regards to recruitment given Lodge appears to be in line for an extension.Given Fogarty is basically coming for $$ and will be playing behind an ordinary pack,whats to guarantee he’ll be playing at or better than his current level.A lot of people talking up 2027 is the year,but unless there’s a flood of juniors coming through,how are Manly going to compete in the market with the new teams financially and having Seibold has the lure?
Seibold would be loving all this. Just more excuses he can hide behind. We are not a results driven business, we are an excuse driven business.
 
Already signed up for 2026. New contracts would be from 2027.

Yes, aware of that. I remember at the time of signing it was reported the Turbo brothers would extend with Manly for unders.

Jake is now the highest paid forward in the NRL. What a JOKE.

What a load of schiit that the brothers took unders.

They are bigger mercenaries than the much maligned DCE.
 
Last edited:
Jake at 50% ! ,of next years 1.2 ??
No thank you .
Maybe 30% ,as a 50 min prop ,for one year.
(If he makes it that far & still healthy)
 
I am highly confident Jake will turn out for 2026, he is too much of a competitor to give it away on this note. But I rather wish he would because I am also very highly confident he gets concussed at least once in 2026. I hope he might consent to at least wear protective headgear!
 
Yes, aware of that. I remember at the time of signing it was reported the Turbo brothers would extend with Manly for unders.

Jake is now the highest paid forward in the NRL. What a JOKE.

What a load of schiit that the brothers took unders.

They are bigger mercenaries than the much maligned DCE.
Is Jake really highest paid forward? Surely it can't be so? FMD ......
 
Yes, aware of that. I remember at the time of signing it was reported the Turbo brothers would extend with Manly for unders.

Jake is now the highest paid forward in the NRL. What a JOKE.

What a load of schiit that the brothers took unders.

They are bigger mercenaries than the much maligned DCE.
The unders is for their next contract, beginning 2027
 
Yes, aware of that. I remember at the time of signing it was reported the Turbo brothers would extend with Manly for unders.

Jake is now the highest paid forward in the NRL. What a JOKE.

What a load of schiit that the brothers took unders.

They are bigger mercenaries than the much maligned DCE.

It was reported extensively at the time that they took less to stay at Manly than what the Bulldogs offered.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 21 17 0 4 168 40
2 Storm 21 16 0 5 252 38
3 Bulldogs 21 15 0 6 120 36
4 Warriors 21 13 0 8 12 32
5 Panthers 21 12 1 8 115 31
6 Broncos 21 12 0 9 114 30
7 Sharks 22 13 0 9 67 30
8 Roosters 21 11 0 10 92 28
9 Dolphins 21 10 0 11 109 26
10 Sea Eagles 21 9 0 12 -24 24
11 Tigers 21 9 0 12 -107 24
12 Dragons 21 8 0 13 -54 22
13 Cowboys 22 8 1 13 -144 21
14 Eels 21 7 0 14 -156 20
15 Rabbitohs 22 8 0 14 -191 20
16 Knights 21 6 0 15 -186 18
17 Titans 21 5 0 16 -187 16
Back
Top Bottom