Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by clontaago, Apr 27, 2012.
Ok guys time to get voting on your choice of 5/8 for the Blues.
Who voted Mullen? lol
Torn between Carney and Mullen, Carney is more creative, but Mullen is a better all round player
I think the halves pretty much vote for themselves, if Carney gets too far in front I will envoke the Mercy Rule.
I do not get the hype with Mullen. I will admit I do not watch much of Newcastle but when I do he has never done anything of note.
Mullen is more often hamstrung by his team mates and Gidley than anything else. When he takes charge he is a very solid player, and good in defense too
Yeah, i'm with you Dan. I'm a big Mullen fan and have been pushing for him for years. Having said that, City v Country did its job and injury aside, the halves were sorted. A begrudging vote for Carney.
What about Maloney?
Forgot about Maloney ME. Im tipping the selctors have too!! I will close voting for 5/8 at Midday.
Mullen is an interesting player. Skill and ability-wise he is tremendous. Mentally he is just not in the game. This has been the case for years.
He was my no 6 about a month ago but I don't think he's a chance. I wouldn't have minded if he got picked on the bench in the CvC game and spent some time at dummy half. The one thing I do like about him, is he's one of the best support players in the comp and I think using forwards who can off load the one way NSW can win.
Just voted for Carney. He didn't need it though.
If someone votes for Hayne at 5/8, they should be banned from the forum.
Ok so that was a whitewash as expected. Moving into Halfback.
carney by a long way
Separate names with a comma.