Quite a few guys have improved this year.I think he mentioned 4 finals in 10 years to save his arse.
Trying to defend not making the finals.
If we do not improve next year, he will be gone as well as his coaching career.
I hope for Manly’s sake he suceeds. Hopefully he will actually coach players to be better and improve - if he can do that and Tommy is not injured, we will make the semis in 2024.
The main thing is that Garrick wasn’t seriously injured….can’t see him playing next week tho. CNK was genuinely concerned for Garrick. He’s not a dirty player but should have been at least a penalty.Absolute madness that that wasn’t deemed a dangerous tackle. Do we have to have another Alex McKinnon for that rule to be changed or at least call it what is was…a very fkn dangerous tackle.
The only positive to come out of it was Seibs doing his block…finally.
I like what he is trying to do. He has identified several things that aren't working and has made efforts to fix them. I honestly think that if Lodge didn't get injured against the roosters we'd all be talking about the finals right now.Quite a few guys have improved this year.
DCE has arguably had his best season at 34. Paseka and Saab are others.
I still haven't made my mind up on Seibold - he's not the next Bellamy but he's also not the worst coach in the game as some on here would have you believe.
Believe it or not but he is the only coach in Broncos Proud History to coach them down to a Wooden spoon feathered friendI still haven't made my mind up on Seibold - he's not the next Bellamy but he's also not the worst coach in the game as some on here would have you believe.
To complete to what you are saying
Perspective time - he also coached Souths to a finals position. Best to be balanced in these things.
Perspective time on the Seibold coaching Souths to a finals positionPerspective time - he also coached Souths to a finals position. Best to be balanced in these things.
I'm neutral on Seibold. Like I said previously he is not the next coming of Bellamy but he's not as bad as some on here put out there. To be honest, I think the team would have finished this year in the same spot as if Hasler was still the coach.
Coaches and teams go up and down. A few months ago, Adam O'Brien was a dead man walking and now he is got an overachieving knights' team into the 8.
What about Ciraldo? The golden boy is probably coaching the most disappointing team of the year.
Not as far backwards as Winning a spoon feathered frien
Perspective time - I haven't seen anyone on here compare him to a great Manly coach.Perspective time on the Seibold coaching Souths to a finals position
That team he coached to a Finals consisted of a previous Grand final Winning Souths team
When he coaches a Manly team to win the Grand final we can compare him to our other Benchmark Manly coaches