SeaEagles v Dragons MnF @WIN Jubilee Rd8 Game day thread #GoManly

Pick the Margin Manly v Dragons


  • Total voters
    52
  • Poll closed .
mickqld said:
This shoulder charge rule is a total joke. There is no way Saints deserved to be penalised for what Vidot did. It's a tough game for god sake stop putting skirts on them.

Im not watching (listening only). If we put aside the shoulder charge validity, if Vidot was penalised should it have been construed as a penalty try ?
 
If we do put on say 24 unanswered points, i'd like to see us go on with it like the Roosters have been doing, not put the cue in the rack.
Now with Morris off there's really no excuse to put a big score on
 
That penalty for the strip was poor. It has given the Dragons a huge run of possession now. Also spewing that they let the whole set play out after the shoulder charge.
 
Are we the only **** ing team that goes on report for a shoulder charge. **** I am sick of this **** ed up rule.
 
Kiwi Eagle said:
No, refs were told pre season that shoulder charges can't turn into a penalty try

That would be a dumb rule. Shoulder charge is now no different to a high shot.
The vidot hit couldn't result in a penalty try there was far to much doubt over him scoring
 
Kiwi Eagle' pid='491168' dateline='1367833287' said:
Lol what a f**king joke, that wasn't a shoulder charge

Agreed. Thought that was a good hit.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 24 19 0 5 148 44
2 Storm 24 17 0 7 212 40
3 Bulldogs 24 16 0 8 120 38
4 Broncos 24 15 0 9 172 36
5 Sharks 24 15 0 9 109 36
6 Warriors 24 14 0 10 21 34
7 Panthers 24 13 1 10 107 33
8 Roosters 24 13 0 11 132 32
9 Dolphins 24 12 0 12 125 30
10 Sea Eagles 24 12 0 12 21 30
11 Eels 24 10 0 14 -76 26
12 Cowboys 24 9 1 14 -146 25
13 Tigers 24 9 0 15 -135 24
14 Rabbitohs 24 9 0 15 -181 24
15 Dragons 24 8 0 16 -130 22
16 Titans 24 6 0 18 -199 18
17 Knights 24 6 0 18 -300 18
Back
Top Bottom